Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
There is a resurgence of interest in programs for early identification of hearing loss in infants in India. Implementation of a Universal Newborn Hearing Screening (UNHS) program is the avowed policy of the government. The Government of India launched a National Program for Prevention and Control of Deafness in 2005 (but implemented only in 2007), which was a strong statement from the government that early screening of the pediatric population for hearing and their rehabilitation later is the responsibility of the state. It is a different thing though that several problems have plagued this project since its launching. The Government of India has recently reconstituted the National Coordination Committee entrusted with the responsibility of running this program, and the new younger committee is very enthusiastic about implementing the program throughout India and eager to make this a success. Implementation of a program of this nature in a vast country like ours is not going to be easy, however, nonavailability of trained personnel in adequate numbers, the gargantuan size of the population to be screened, geographical vastness for coverage, lack of instrumentation, poor awareness/education of the people, administrative apathy, and lack of policy backup are some of the issues that can be considered impediments for a successful screening project. Therefore, a word or two about the perceived outcome of this kind of program and alternate avenues to overcome some of the above problems is timely and appropriate. There are many programs for early screening and identification of speech, language, and hearing disorders in the pediatric population in this country, and for many years now. Some are hospital-based, some are school-based, and some are camp-based. Most of the hospital-based programs have focused on screening newborns for hearing. Each of these programs has witnessed varying degrees of success. Though we talk of early identification of speech, language, and hearing disorders, it is better to keep our focus on early screening of children for language and hearing disorders. Any speech problem in the absence of language or hearing or cognitive aspects being affected is not going to be a significant problem. When language is attended to, speech problems are also accounted for. Even if speech problems are not identified say at 1 or even 2 years, there is still time. One does not have to take serious consideration of prevention or early identification of speech problems as a separate entity. However, irrespective of the dimension of the screening programs, the central question before us is how do we organize early identification and intervention services to screen children in a vast country like ours? As United Nations International Children’s Emergency Fund (United Nations International Children’s Emergency Fund [UNICEF], 2023) statistics show, India witnesses 67,385 births per day or 24.595 million per year. Though infant mortality is also very high, still everyday addition to the pediatric population of this country is significantly high. More importantly, nearly 3.5 million babies in India are born too early, 1.7 million babies are born with birth defects, and 1 million new-borns are discharged each year from Special Newborn Care Units (United Nations International Children’s Emergency Fund [UNICEF], 2023). These newborns remain at high risk of death, stunting, developmental delay, and communication disorders. Therefore, newborns have to be screened for several developmental disorders. Early identification and intervention mean that we are on the path to creating a life akin to ours for some or most of these children. We believe that the cost of screening/identifying a baby with disability would be much less than the cost of managing the child later in his/her life. Therefore, early identification programs are a necessity and in order. Pedestrian Approach As I said earlier, the general belief is that the cost of screening/identifying a baby with disability would be much less than the cost of managing the child later in his/her life. I tend to believe that it is a cliché, or at best, philosophical. The various programs that we have implemented, or thinking of instituting are inherently uneconomical in terms of time, effort, and money. The magnitude of the requirements in terms of equipment, manpower, and logistics to screen 24.595 million children every year is overwhelming. No doubt with improvement in literacy and earning capacity, the birth rate will come down in this country. Even then, it would still be a large number of children to be screened considering the base figure of 1.42 billion-size population of this country. Many studies have commented on the usefulness of the UNHS programs in identifying permanent bilateral hearing (Butcher, Dezateux, Cortina-Borja, & Knowles, 2019; Edmond et al., 2022). Significantly, better outcomes have been reported for children identified early through UNHS programs (Yoshinaga-Itano, Manchaiah, & Hunnicutt, 2021). Therefore, irrespective of the economic cost associated, all babies need to be screened. There is no second thinking on that issue. There are about 31,053 primary health centers (PHCs) in India, 6064 Community Health Centers, and 161,829 functional sub-centers in India as of March 2022 (Rural India Online, 2023). Finding personnel (audiologists, in the present thinking) to screen 24.5 million babies every year, and the equipment (otoacoustic emission analyzers and screeners) will be next to impossible. Therefore, there is a need to strategize differently considering the enormous resources required for implementing a UNHS program in India. Biochemical Markers Today, behaviorism may dominating in our approach to communication disorders. That is, largely because of the absence of alternate logical approaches. The human body, after all, functions because of innumerable chemical reactions. Every behavior of us has to have a biochemical basis (Baker, 2007). Genetics, hormones, and the nervous system are all based on behavior. However, we know that there are certainly no genes that endow us with speech. However, we are aware that there are children who fail to acquire speech–language skills despite adequate environmental input and overtly normal neurological and anatomical development. There is indirect evidence that the human genome might hold some answers to this enigma (Fisher, 2007). We should start looking for biomarkers that may act as indicators of hidden disability. As of now, we do not know many biomarkers that indicate communication disorders except some genomic transpositions like FOXP2 protein associated with developmental dyslexia and childhood apraxia of speech (Lai et al., 2000). The findings from recent genetic mapping studies are consistent with the view that there exist some risk factors that are common to speech sound disorders and dyslexia (Smith, Pennington, Boada, & Shriberg, 2005; Stein et al., 2004). Some evidence documents disruption of one copy of the SHANK3 gene in autism spectrum disorder (ASD; Durand et al., 2007), and duplication of the 7q11.23 Williams–Beuren syndrome region in developmental verbal dyspraxia (Somerville et al., 2005) suggests that altered gene dosage may be a general theme underlying speech/language deficits in the human population (Fisher, 2005). There is evidence to show that dyslexia susceptibility involves the effects of multiple genes (on chromosomes 1, 2, 3, 6, 15, and 18; Fisher & DeFries, 2002). There are extensive research attempts studying neurotransmitters (serotonin), brain-derived neurotrophic factor, tryptophan, and metabolites of the tryptophan-derived kynurenine for their alterations in children with autism (Carpita, 2022). Many promising biomarkers have been developed for ASD. However, many biomarkers are preliminary and need to be validated and their role in the diagnosis and treatment of ASD needs to be defined (Frye, Vassall, Kaur, Lewis, Karim, & Rossignol, 2019). I know that searching for biomarkers for hearing and communication disorders is akin to finding a needle in a big hay stalk, but I believe, this is an “economically” viable way ahead for us. I know that searching for biomarkers for hearing and communication disorders is akin to finding a needle in a big hay stalk, but I believe, this is the “economically” viable way ahead for us. Searching for biomarkers means that we are dissecting the neural bases of human communication. It is a method that takes genes and molecules as a starting point (Fisher, 2007). A practical approach to search for biomarkers would be to look for metabolic disorders, possible genetic dislocations characterizing them, expression or lack of expression of enzymes and proteins because of genetic transpositions, and the myriad ways, in which they can influence the development of speech–language and hearing functions. With present day technology, it is possible to screen for about 50 metabolic disorders like hypothyroidism, phenylketonuria, and sickle cell anemia with just a drop of blood. The scope of this screening can be enhanced. Search for a possible association between pathological bases of these disorders to speech–language deviations. We might find something. In summary, the approaches that we are following for the identification of communication and hearing disorders in the pediatric population all these days are pedestrian and uneconomical. We need to think of alternate approaches, and in this direction, a search for biochemical indicators may turn out to be a more profitable approach. However, I am aware that finding biomarkers is not an easy thing. It is time-consuming, requires major and multipronged research, and the outcome of research is not guaranteed, but a beginning needs to be made. New Approach to Choice of Personnel and Training I mentioned earlier, some of the practical factors that make early identification of disability unviable. One of the major factors that hinders a screening program in India is the nonavailability of trained personnel, particularly audiologists, in adequate numbers. It is also true of speech–language pathologists (SLPs). Anybody who is involved in an early identification program will know the seriousness of this situation. Even if audiologists are available in large numbers, believe me, they will not take up positions in this program because of various reasons. The two most commonly advanced reasons are curtailment of the scope of work and the requirement to work in rural/semi-urban centers. We have to think of alternative personnel who can do this work—maybe doctors in PHCs or nurses or some other identified group. The point I want to make is that having SLP–audiologists or training some others in large numbers to do screening and identification work relating to just one disability is time-consuming, impractical, and unviable economically. I advocate training a new breed of personnel who can undertake early identification and prevention of all disabilities—those five main disabilities and their subcategories mentioned under the PWD Act 2016. Students can be intensively trained for a year or two on early identification of multiple disabilities for which they will earn a diploma, maybe a postgraduate diploma. Such personnel will have specialized knowledge though in a narrow area, will have work throughout the year, and if they were also compensated suitably to do this work, there would be a great demand for them. There are 926 institutes in the area of disability in India recognized by the Rehabilitation Council of India and even if 75% of these institutes train 25 students every year, we will have the services of about 17,375 personnel every year (695 × 25). It would be better if the personnel for such training programs come from a biochemistry background, which would enable them to conveniently fit into the program on screening for metabolic disorders. I am sure this will work, but somebody has to take the lead. Peripatetic Personnel I advocate not only training a new breed of personnel but also that they be peripatetic. Peripatetic assistants/therapists were in vogue in the UK in the middle of the last century. Peripatetic speech therapists would visit homes and offer services. However, with advancements in all spheres of life, such a practice is outdated now. I am advocating reinvention of this system. These peripatetic assistants will move between PHCs and hospitals—private and public—within a predefined geographical boundary, carry screening/testing babies soon after birth and once or twice later, collect the recommended biological samples, transport them to the district hospitals for analysis, keep records, advice the parents, and make appropriate referrals to professionals/institutes when required. They will carry equipment from center to center. They will be connected to one monitoring center in a district, maybe at the district hospital, where experts monitor some part of the work. Screening itself can be very simple with comprehensive screening checklists, questionnaires, simple tests, and noisemakers or whatever technology permits, to tap developmental features that may harmthe status of their speech, language, and hearing. This level of screening may not be ideal, but will give valuable clues and indicators to suspect a hearing problem in the immediate time frame or deviant development of speech–language later. The scope of screening can be expanded later with the availability of technology. We do not always need Western solutions and methods. Active assistance from the Anganwadi personnel and Accredited Social Health Activists is a requirement for the peripatetic assistants to screen every child within a minor window and to ensure that no baby/child is missed. We can work out the logistics of the scheme with the knowledge of the geography of the region, health infrastructure, and administrative support. I do believe this is workable. Financial support and sponsorship Nil. Conflict of interest There is no conflict of interest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
M. Jayaram (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: