Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Two series of experiments with calves to determine the net energy value of whole milk have been published, one in Austria (Soxhlet, 1878) and one in Russia (Tomme & Taranenko, 1939).Soxhlet determined carbon and nitrogen balances in three experiments at a high nutritional plane and, from the results he obtained Armsby, (1917) calculated the net availability of the metabolizable energy of whole milk.T o accomplish this Armsby assumed that the maintenance requirement of the calf, per unit of surface area, was 10 yo' higher than that of the adult steer.He commented that the value he obtained was much lower than would be expected on the basis of the application of Rubner's factors of 69 yo for protein, 87 yo for fat and 94 % for carbohydrate to the proximate principles present in whole milk.Kellner's (1926) computation of the net energy value of whole milk was, however, considerably lower than Armsby's value, and so indeed was Hansson's (1926).These estimates were made by the application of factors, determined by Kellner on mature cattle, to the proximate principles digested by the calf.Russian workers (Urmaliat, Reinbot & Elitchiev, 1937 ; Lebehdiev, I 937) realized these large discrepancies between estimates of the nutritive value of COW'S milk, and in 1939 Tomme & Taranenko made six determinations of energy balance with young calves given 7-8 1. of whole milk as the sole diet.They calculated that the starch equivalent of whole milk containing 4 yo fat was 21.7, a value higher than Kellner's value of 14-7 and lower than Armsby's value of 27.1.It is uncertain from Tomme & Taranenko's paper what method was used to calculate the maintenance requirement upon which the calculation of net energy ultimately depends.It would appear, however, that fasting heat production determined 12-18 h after the last meal was the basis.Blaxter & Wood (1951 a), however, have shown that the heat production of the calf determined at this time is markedly affected by the previous plane of nutrition.There is therefore some uncertainty regarding the nutritive value of the gross energy
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
K. L. Blaxter (1952) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: