Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The author must be congratulated for quantifying the influence of shear and pointing out the importance of bolt heads, washers, etc., in T-stub and end-plate behavior.The writer wishes to comment briefly on his theoretical approach in the light of findings from his own research.The method suggested by the author incorporates valuable extensions of the continuum mechanics principles proposed by previous researchers .But every such extension increases the number and variety of pertinent parameters; each then involves several new assumptions and approximations.Typically, somewhere along the long and complicated path to the final answer, the effects of the approximations need to be lumped or adjusted to reflect some observed behavior, thus effectively wiping out the originally precise and detailed formulations.The writer believes that this approach has reached the point of diminishing returns, because, as a mathematical model grows more complex, assumptions more numerous, and justification more indirect, its validity becomes more tenuous and questionable.The author has no doubt pointed out the many approximations inherent in his analysis; but his closing comment that "they will not affect the validity of the results of the theory '' somewhat detracts from arguments to their necessity.Much can be said about the degree of reasonableness in a number of these approximations.But the writer would single out the location of the prying force, Q, for more detailed di scussion.Many previous investigators have assumed Q to act at the edge of the T-stub flange or the end plate.Some have recognized the fact that the prying force is actually a pressure bulb with resultant closer to the bolt, but even they have continued to assume an edge force at yielding.There are some analytical studies to support this, as the author has mentioned.Under joint sponsorship by the American Institute of Steel Construction (AISC) and Metal Building Manufacturers Association , the writer has conducted exhaustive two-dimensional and three-dimensional finite element analyses of end-plate connections.These indicate that the prying pressure resultant is rarely close to the edge.(Papers on the writer's research are under preparation; a background paper (19) has already been presented.)
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Natarajan Krishnamurthy (1977) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: