Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Co-production, in my view, involves genuine power-sharing and therefore a fundamental democratizing of relationships between professionals and service users in mental health. Understood this way, co-production is more radical than shared decision-making which can leave power imbalances intact (Slay & Stephens 2013). As a general rule, authentic power-sharing has yet to become established in mental health care (Webber et al. 2014). Here, I consider how power imbalances may be redressed through the wider organizational adoption of relationship-centred practice. At the same time, I argue that cultural change is inextricably linked to individual actions and behaviour. Cultural transformation is not merely contingent on ‘change from above’, it is also facilitated by individuals ‘on the ground’. Before proceeding further, I should explain that my interest in co-production came about through my experience as a sociologist conducting research with a range of people marginalized for reasons related to social disadvantage, disability, mental health and political stigma. People whose identities are constantly devalued in their interaction with others can become fixed in positions of helplessness. If powerlessness is internalized people no longer see themselves as citizens with legitimate values, thoughts and expertise. Hope and self-belief are eroded, and people suffering from mental distress are less likely to move on positively in their lives (Fisher & Lees 2015). In other words, power imbalances are often injurious to recovery. While co-production could be justified purely on the principles of natural justice, there is a body of qualitative evidence, which suggests that co-production promotes recovery by addressing stigma, improving skills and employability, and by enhancing mental and physical well-being outcomes (Slay & Stephens 2013). To be clear, co-production is not synonymous with recovery, however, co-production is a strategy towards recovery which is based on a belief that recovery is possible (see Barker & Buchanan-Barker 2005). But, co-production is also more than this: it is about viewing service users first and foremost as citizens who can legitimately inform mental health care commissioning and policy (Needham & Carr 2009). That said, it follows that for a variety of reasons, some citizens may prefer not to engage in co-production, and it is important to acknowledge this. If co-production is an obligation, it is de facto no longer co-production, but yet another form of coercion. Co-production requires changes to organizational cultures and management strategies. A first step in the right direction might be greater organizational recognition of the value of relationship-centred approaches in mental health. Relationship-centred approaches were first developed in the care of people with dementia (Nolan et al. 2003). From a relationship-centred perspective, therapeutic relationships are seen as enriching the lives of professionals and service users alike. Relationship-centred care is arguably the starting point for co-production. Mutually rewarding relationships are not necessarily based on power-sharing, but they are a first step towards facilitating a re-distribution of power. Nolan et al. (2003) argue that relationship-centred practice can be best promoted through an adoption of a ‘senses’ framework. The latter captures important subjective and perceptual aspects of care that should be experienced by both service users and professionals. In brief, service users and professionals should all benefit from a sense of security, belonging, purpose as well as a sense of fulfilment and/or achievement. Crucially, service users and professionals should feel that what they do matters and that they are valued as a person of worth. In order to create these ‘senses’, professionals have to experience them for themselves. This is why cultural change within services and policy making organizations is crucial (Dewar & Nolan 2013). Some may argue that a relationship-centred approach is transferable only to mental health care environments, which have been significantly shaped by the values of postpsychiatry (Bracken & Thomas 2001). Whether or not, this is the case requires in-depth consideration which is beyond the scope of this editorial. Nevertheless, it is self-evident that relationship-centred care requires professionals to think beyond the reason/madness binary which fixes service users in a position of powerlessness and dependence. Equally, relationship-centred care will not flourish if professionals remain closed to alternative perspectives. At its core, relationship-centred care is about a way of being human which potentially opens the door towards relationships of equality. If the widespread adoption at organizational levels of relationship-centred care offers the best hope for the realization of co-productive services based on power-sharing with service users, then change may take a long time. That said, professionals sometimes wait for change from above while failing to recognize that they have a role to play in the evolution of organizational culture. According to the moral philosopher Charles Taylor (1989), the formation of individual identities and social environments are interlinked processes. In Sources of the Self, (see Fisher & Freshwater 2015), Taylor (1989) argues that a person's identity develops through an ongoing process of critical evaluation in which they are prepared to subject personal convictions and identification to scrutiny. This is achieved through engaging in relationships of respect and equality and through being open to others' perspectives. This does not involve casting personal convictions aside, but it demands a readiness to revise convictions as a continuous process of identity development. In other words, critical evaluation requires professionals to engage with service users as equals and to have the openness to subject professional practice and values to ongoing scrutiny informed by their encounters with service users. While calling for openness may seem an obvious appeal to make, the point is that openness is often extremely difficult to achieve, painful even. Professionals who apply critical evaluation in their work with service users would be open to perspectives, which may confront professional ‘regimes of truth’ central to their sense of self. ‘Received wisdoms’ would not necessarily be overturned, but would be viewed as revisable in ways that cannot be anticipated. This would be lived co-production in action. Co-production, through critical evaluation, recognizes that personal development and cultural change are enmeshed processes.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Pamela Fisher (2016) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: