Key result
COVID-19 psychosocial stress may increase the risk of adverse cardiovascular outcomes.
Why the study?
Studies examining the impact of psychosocial factors during the COVID-19 pandemic were limited, and the impact on cardiovascular health was not yet ascertained.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The psychosocial stress induced by the COVID-19 pandemic, including depression and anxiety, may significantly worsen cardiovascular health outcomes.
INTRODUCTION The outbreak of the 2019 novel Coronavirus (COVID-19) originated in the Wuhan province of China in December 2019[1] and spread across the world within 4 months, infecting over 4,355,456 people and resulting in the death of 2,93,090 individuals (at the time of penning this article).[2] The contagiousness of the disease with limited effectiveness in the efforts to curtail the spread, explosiveness, and severity of the attack rates and minimal population immunity has forced many countries to introduce various stringent measures such as lockdown of all services, social distancing, quarantine, and isolation. These measures, which are indispensable in curtailing the infection, have debilitated the social and economical stability of all the affected countries including the developed nations and resulted in a wide range of emotional and mental disturbances in people.[3] These disturbances are closely associated with an increased prevalence of psychological and social problems across all age groups[4,5] which can have a negative impact on the physical health of individuals,[1,6,7] especially on the cardiovascular health.[8] Identification of people exposed to negative psychosocial factors and thus susceptible and at-risk for ill-health is important for timely intervention to prevent secondary mental and physical health issues.[9] Studies that examined the impact of psychosocial factors of the COVID-19 pandemic are very limited.[8] As the impact on cardiovascular health is still not ascertained, we explore the various psychosocial problems that can result from COVID-19 and how these could affect cardiovascular health. PSYCHOSOCIAL FACTORS ASSOCIATED WITH COVID-19 The current outbreak of COVID-19 can cause a wide spectrum of psychosocial stress on human lives. A mental breakdown may happen in anyone who fears of getting infected and thereby falling ill or dying. They may experience helplessness and hopelessness and thus feel uneasy in coming in contact with others owing to fear of acquiring infection.[10] People who are uncomfortable of being quarantined may feel isolation, discrimination, frustration, exhaustion, shame, guilt, and anger which could all lead to depression, anxiety, stress, insomnia, denial, and fear.[1,7] They also experience weepiness, nightmares, and poor concentration.[11] People requiring a longer duration of quarantine have a higher prevalence of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD).[12] Factors influencing PTSD include quality of treatment received, accessibility to medical care and medications, the environmental condition of the quarantined place, and emotional and mental support that has been received.[6,12] The infected and quarantined people could also notice stigma and discrimination from society. These emotions fueled by preexisting psychological problems, if any, may negatively affect them and bring about remodeling of their behavior and social life.[8] The viral infection has also taken a toll on the psychosocial health of medical and allied staff. Longer working hours in isolation wards, the possibility of directly being exposed to the infected patients, the uneasiness of wearing personal protective equipment and inadequacy of protection, all of them may result in heightened anxiety. The fear of contracting infection or transmitting infection to their family members or loved ones, could have adverse psychiatric outcomes.[13] These individuals may become highly stressful, emotionally imbalanced, and traumatized which all can also result in depression, anxiety, PTSD, anger, and disgust.[14] The elderly and people with chronic illnesses such as heart disease, cancer, and kidney diseases are severely affected by virus infection. They may be exposed to emotional disturbances, anxiety, fear of infection or death, confusion, and depression[6] because of isolation, financial strain, limited accessibility to medical treatment or medications, and the uncertainty of the disease status.[9] Those who are experiencing emotional trauma from a sudden loss of a loved one often find it difficult to cope with the loss and have anger, grief, and resentment.[15] The family members of patients with COVID-19 may also face discrimination and stigmatization from others. A survey conducted during the initial stage of the COVID-19 outbreak found that 53.8% of respondents had moderate-to-severe symptoms of psychosocial problems associated with the outbreak.[1] Among them, 16.5% had moderate-to-severe symptoms of depression, 28.8% had moderate-to-severe symptoms of anxiety, and 8% had moderate-to-severe symptoms of stress. Studies carried out during the severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) epidemic had observed acute psychosis among a few patients,[16] and the psychosocial impact was persisting even after the outbreak had subsided. In another study, 13%–32% of patients reported moderate-to-severe levels of anxiety, 18%–26% reported moderate-to-severe levels of depression, and around 4% reported PTSD even after their discharge from hospital.[17,18] Even though data on the impact of psychosocial factors on the health of the SARS survivors on a longer follow-up are unavailable, studies have shown that these psychosocial disturbances evolve over time. SARS survivors 3 months after their discharge from hospital have reported diminished symptoms of anxiety and posttraumatic intrusion and posttraumatic hyperarousal, but depression and posttraumatic avoidance symptoms remained constant.[18] The longest follow-up study examining the prevalence of PTSD, anxiety, and depression among SARS survivors reported that 36.5% of them had PTSD, 36.5% had sleep problems, 34.9% had anxiety, and 30.2% had depression. Patients who were on ventilators or with family members who died from SARS infection had a higher prevalence of PTSD, anxiety, and depression than those without such history.[19] These studies suggest that patients who are affected by COVID-19 may also experience psychosocial problems for over a period of time. HOW CAN PSYCHOSOCIAL FACTORS INFLUENCE CARDIOVASCULAR HEALTH? Psychological variables can affect the physiological mechanism of an individual either directly or indirectly and have a significant impact on the health or illness conditions of a person. Individuals who are prone to negative psychological conditions can have unfavorable cardiovascular outcomes and a very poor cardiovascular profile.[20,21] Plausible mechanisms An important link between emotions and heart is provided by the hypothalamic–pituitary–adrenal (HPA) axis and the stress hormone cortisol. The HPA axis discharges the hormones into the blood for preparing the body to react to various threats. The mechanism controls the levels of the hormones, depending on the threat levels.[22,23] Constant exposure to cortisol can result in hypercortisolemia, impairment of platelet function, elevated heart rate, and reduced heart rate variability and is thus detrimental to the heart and the entire cardiovascular system and may contribute to cardiovascular diseases (CVDs).[24,25] Cortisol also slows down growth hormone and gonadal axes[7,8] leading to increased visceral fat causing dyslipidemia, hypercortisolism, and hyperinsulinism, increasing the risk for CVDs and other disorders.[26] Stress can accelerate the atherosclerotic process leading to arterial occlusion,[27] plaque rupture and thrombosis resulting in myocardial infarction (MI), or cerebral stroke.[28] Depression causes sympathetic hyperactivity, increased platelet reactivity,[29,30] pro-inflammatory processes, and an elevation of interleukin-6, which is a primary pro-inflammatory cytokine.[31,32] A pro-inflammatory condition can accelerate atherosclerosis and lead to increased cardiovascular events.[33] There are also other factors linking depression with CVDs. Depression can result in nonadherence with medical treatments,[34] higher rates of smoking without cessation,[35] and greater risk for obesity because of a sedentary lifestyle.[36] Anxiety can contribute to a chain reaction in the body, most likely mediated by the sympathetic nervous system and culminating in the sensitization of cardiac sympathetic nerves.[37] Constant anxiety can predispose an individual to cardiac rhythm changes and risk for coronary artery spasm.[37] Individuals whose sympathetic nervous system response to stress is exaggerated and prolonged are at a higher risk for atherosclerosis and subsequent coronary artery diseases (CADs).[4] Socially isolated people may have a different mood state or disturbing complex emotional experience which could result in dejection or demoralization and physical problems.[38] It is also related to health risk behaviors such as reduced physical activity, reduced sleep quality, smoking, and poor mental health[39,40] which could all eventually cause physical illness. Social support can offer a protective effect against progression of CVDs and death by facilitating greater adherence to medical therapies and lifestyle modifications and reducing negative emotional interferences.[41] Social support also provides protection from various stressors, disengages people from risky behaviors such as excessive consumption of nicotine, alcohol, or narcotic drugs, and reinforces healthy behaviors and better mental health.[42] People who are exposed to societal discrimination have negative cardiovascular health outcomes such as alterations in blood pressure,[43] heart rate/heart rate variability,[44] and changes in the body levels of CVD biomarkers.[45] Those who are unemployed or have job insecurity have multiple health problems such as autoimmune disorders, certain types of cancers, metabolic syndrome (including abdominal obesity, dyslipidemia, high blood pressure, insulin resistance, and prothrombotic state), and increased cardiovascular morbidity and mortality.[46,47,48,49] Moreover, long-term financial problems owing to unemployment directly affect cardiovascular health by limiting access to good quality food, increased negative habits such as smoking, lower physical activity, and indirectly through psychological pathways: higher prevalence of depression, anxiety, exhaustion, or hostility. These increase the risk for coronary heart diseases (CHDs) and poor prognosis, by bringing about acute or chronic physiological changes.[50,51] Current evidences Despite some heterogeneity of findings, a large amount of evidence supports the notion that psychosocial factors are risk factors for all-cause mortality from CVDs as well as for composite outcomes including nonfatal cardiac events.[52] A meta-analysis of 293 studies comprising 1 813 733 participants from 35 countries has revealed a relative risk of mortality of 1.52 (95% confidence interval [CI] = 1.45–1.59) in depressed people compared to nondepressed ones.[53] The authors concluded that patients with depressive symptoms were at increased risk of mortality from cardiac events. Another meta-analysis with a total of 3, 23, 709 participants reported a total of 8447 patients with MI and coronary deaths during follow-up which ranged from 4 to 37 years. The pooled adjusted hazard ratios (HRs) for patients with depression versus those without depression were 1.22 (95% CI: 1.13–1.32) for MI and 1.31 (95% CI: 1.09–1.57) for deaths from CHD.[54] Studies have also identified that patients with CVD have a higher prevalence of depressive symptoms when compared to a normal population[55] and that they are likely to have MI or heart failure.[52] This finding was reaffirmed in another study by May et al.[56] who reported that patients who had depressive disorders after an angiographically confirmed diagnosis of CAD were at two-fold risk of death. In this study, among 24,137 patients with angiographically determined CAD, 3646 were diagnosed as depressed. The authors reported that depression after CAD was strongly associated with death (HR = 2.00, P < 0.0001). The potential relationship between anxiety and CVD is revealed in a meta-analysis of 37 studies which included 15, 65, 699 participants.[57] The analysis revealed that anxiety was associated with 52% of increased incidence of CVD (HR: 1.52; 95% CI: 1.36–1.71), and the association remained significant even after adjusting for publication bias (HR: 1.41; 95% CI: 1.26–1.57). The authors concluded that anxiety is an independent risk factor for CVD. Anxiety not only increases the risk for CHD but also death from CVD as well.[58] This is indicated in a meta-analysis of 21 prospective studies. The authors found that anxiety increased the risk for CHD by 26% and anxious persons were at 48% more risk for cardiac mortality as compared to nonanxious persons. There are also studies that suggest that anxiety causes nearly two-fold increased risk for adverse cardiac events in patients with stable CAD over 2 years[59] and a two-fold risk for death in the next 10 years after the first event.[60] A population-based controlled cohort study in siblings consisting of 136,637 patients in the Swedish National Patient Register revealed that stress-related disorders were more robustly related to early onset of various types of CVD.[61] Researchers have also found that perceived social stress is also significantly associated with incidence of MI.[62] Stressful life events such as the death of the spouse or natural disasters also can lead to MI and sudden cardiac death.[63] Stressful working environments with high demands and low decision latitude are also related to high blood pressure and the risk for CHD.[64,65,66] Several studies indicate that socially isolated people are prone to a higher risk of developing CHD. A systematic review and meta-analysis of 16 longitudinal datasets aimed at finding the relationship between loneliness or social isolation and incident CHD reported 4628 CHD events during a follow-up of 3–21 years.[67] The authors reported that people with poor social relationships or who are socially isolated have a 29% increased risk of CHD. Another study found that individuals with low social support or who are socially isolated have higher odds for MI as compared to those with higher social support.[68] Loneliness has a potentially negative effect on our biological stress responses and would be injurious to one's health.[69] This was identified in a study aimed at determining the health risk factors of loneliness or social isolation in 240 working men and women aged 47–59 years. Lonely or socially isolated individuals had a higher level of fibrinogen (P = 0.038) and cortisol levels were also found to be increased (P = 0.046). WHAT NEEDS TO BE DONE? As indicated earlier, the severity, longevity, and broad spectrum of psychosocial problems lead to diseases[70] depending on the effects of several factors such as the kind of traumatic event, length of the trauma, and available supports. Similarly, COVID-19-induced negative psychosocial problems could facilitate the initiation, progression, and perpetuation of cardiac problems or function as a trigger for reoccurrence of cardiac problems in patients with previous history[71] and could also create an situation conducive for the initiation and perpetuation of atrial fibrillation.[72] Depression, anxiety, PTSD, and social isolation could precipitate ventricular arrhythmia and MI even among individuals with or without any history of CHD.[68, 71,[73,74,75] Comprehensive psychosocial assessment Therefore, it is advisable that the high-risk groups in any community are identified and health workers conduct initial psychosocial assessments so that appropriate interventions can be undertaken early to limit psychosocial morbidity associated with the outbreak of COVID-19. The assessment could focus on the pandemic-related stressors such as the possibility of exposure to infection, death of family members or loved ones and disconnectedness with the external world, psychological problems such as depression, anxiety, fear, grief, and PTSD, as well as social problems including unemployment, isolation, substance abuse, and domestic violence. Preexisting disease conditions also needs assessment.[3] Proper communication Evidence-based genuine communication is to be provided to the public to reduce the incidence of psychosocial problems associated with the infection.[76] Health authorities may ensure the communication process. They have also to provide instructions regarding what people should do if they develop any health problems and proper follow-up of patients in the high-risk category is to be ensured. This could reassure those in quarantine and thus lessen the impact of the outbreak.[6] Education and training Appropriate education and training to evaluate and handle psychosocial problems could be provided to all first-level responders and health-care professionals including general practitioners and emergency care physicians. They are to screen along with physiological problems, the psychosocial aspects of patients with COVID-19, and address to the best of their ability psychosocial concerns that are identified. Patients may be referred to mental health professionals as necessitated by seriousness of the problems.[3] To prevent the possibility of health-care providers themselves becoming victims of mental health problems, there should be support from the hospital management, superiors, and co-workers. Proper training for infection control practices and other precautionary measures and monitoring could facilitate adaptive stress responses.[8,11] Creation of social support networks Social media platforms can be used to provide social support networks and improve social belongingness.[77] Interventions could involve more frequent telephone contact with close family and friends, voluntary organizations, and health-care professionals or community outreach programs, which provide peer support throughout enforced isolation. Further, cognitive and behavioral therapies could also be delivered online to decrease the effects of loneliness and improve mental wellbeing.[78] Monitoring and follow-up The health authorities are expected to ensure constant monitoring of psychosocial problems and initiation of suitable interventions during the post-COVID-19 pandemic period as well. These could reduce the after-effects of psychosocial impact on the mental and physical health of the affected and advance their return to normal life. CONCLUSION The psychosocial impact of the COVID-19 outbreak could be enormous. The pandemic has debilitated the social and economical stability of all countries. Although the impact of the outbreak has the potential to affect all, it is likely to be more among vulnerable populations such as children, the elderly, those with a history of mental illness, socially isolated people, and low-income group. The outbreak could result in several psychological and social problems including depression, anxiety, PTSD, fear, anger, grief, stigmatization, and social isolation. These psychological and social problems, though may often be transient, could produce a negative impact on the physical health of individuals including increased risk for CVDs and adverse cardiovascular outcomes. There is necessity to rein in the psychosocial impact of the outbreak by developing and implementing a timely, comprehensive, and balanced intervention strategies as a post-COVID-19 increase in incidence of psychosocial problems could lead to poor mental health of a large proportion of vulnerable people and further debilitate both economical and social structure of the society. There is certainly an urgent need for studies related to the psychosocial impact of COVID-19 and on their long-term effects on individual's physical health, particularly on cardiovascular health. Financial support and sponsorship Nil. Conflicts of interest There are no conflicts of interest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Manoj et al. (2020) conducted a review in COVID-19 and cardiovascular health. Psychosocial stress from COVID-19 was evaluated. The COVID-19 pandemic causes significant psychosocial stress, which may negatively impact physical health and increase the risk for adverse cardiovascular outcomes.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: