Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Criminalisation, criminal records and rehabilitation: from supervision to citizenship?Scholars of criminal justice have long described contact with the penal system as involving different forms of 'pain'.Paradigmatically, Skyes (1958) outlined the 'pains of imprisonment' whereby the incarcerated experience deprivations of liberty, autonomy, security, goods and services, and heterosexual relationships.Subsequently, Crewe (2011) described 21st century imprisonment as involving pains associated with indeterminacy, psychological assessment and selfgovernment in his analysis of the 'depth', 'weight' and 'tightness' of the contemporary prison experience.However, the notion of a 'painful' criminal justice experience has not been limited to studies of incarceration.Durnescu (2011; 2019) applied Sykes' approach to non-custodial supervision, suggesting that amongst other 'pains of probation' or 're-entry' were the sense of instability or 'walking on thin ice', the uncomfortable aspects of being forced to return to and confront one's offending, and the stigmatisation effects of the juridical status of the probationer.Hayes (2015) has also considered the various 'pains of community penalties', noting how supervision may involve an intrusive and, in some cases, hostile degree of intervention by various agencies in the lives of lawbreakers.In addition to this more established focus amongst academics on imprisonment and community punishment, increasing attention is now being paid to so-called 'collateral consequences' of a criminal record.These 'invisible punishments' (Travis, 2002) include numerous de jure provisions and de facto practices which involve people with criminal records being treated less favourably than others in a wide range of life domains outside of the sphere of criminal justice and often long after the completion of their sentences.Scholarship in this field has focused predominantly on the United States where many thousands of laws exist restricting rights in areas such as employment, housing, participation in democracy and access to social security (see inter alia Jacobs, 2015; Kirk and Wakefield, 2018;Corda, 2018).However, greater focus is now starting to be placed on discriminatory practices against people with criminal records in Europe (Kurtovic and Rovira, 2017; Larrauri and Rovira, 2018) and to how this might be tackled (Larrauri, 2014a;Henley, 2019).It is appropriate to reflect then, not merely on the pains associated with imprisonment and reentry, or with community penalties and probation supervision, but with the status of holding a criminal record itself.In post-sentence life, the pains of criminalisation associated with the stigma of a criminal record may even have more harmful and long-lasting impacts on the citizenship and life chances of former lawbreakers than the sentence itself (Henley 2018a; 2019).Arguably these pains should therefore be considered not merely as 'collateral' but as central to social practices of punishment involving shame and moral stigmatisation.HM Prison and Probation Service state ambitions to 'prevent victims by changing lives' and 'reduce reoffending by rehabilitating the people in our care through education and employment' (UK Government 2022).Similarly, in relation to criminal justice social work, the Scottish Government (2022) states that '[w]hilst crime should be punished, we believe that people should also be given support where possible to turn their lives around.'Whilst official discourse about the aims of criminal justice in the UK has, for at least two decades now, been grounded in unambiguously punitive but also utilitarian crime reduction motives, research indicates that many probation practitioners see their work as guided by values more commonly associated with probation's founding 'advise, assist and befriend' ethos (see Worrall and Mawby 2014;Canton 2018).Yet potentially painful experiences of criminal justice supervision combined with the harsh realities of post-sentence life with a criminal record are clearly at odds with goals of rehabilitation and social inclusion.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Andrew Henley (2022) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: