Key result
Routine use of pulse oximetry during anesthesia was associated with significantly fewer Recovery Room Impact Events among 12,088 patients, though cause and effect could not be determined.
Why the study?
Does routine use of pulse oximetry reduce Recovery Room Impact Events in patients undergoing anesthesia?
Does routine use of pulse oximetry reduce Recovery Room Impact Events in patients undergoing anesthesia?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The historical implementation of anesthesia monitoring standards, including pulse oximetry, was associated with a reduction in recovery room impact events and a subsequent drop in malpractice premiums.
To the Editor We thank the authors of the article titled, “The Origins, Evolution, and Spread of Anesthesia Monitoring Standards: From Boston to Around the World,” for their excellent summary of our work in developing the first standards of care in the specialty of anesthesiology.1 We wish to clarify and expand on a few points. In 1984, the chiefs of Harvard Medical School’s anesthesia departments asked us to “study” the problem of disproportionately high payouts relative to anesthesia claims. Having concluded that continuous monitoring was key to detecting preventable errors, we mandated minimal monitoring standards that would include what prudent anesthesiologists were already doing. We rejected “recommendations” and “guidelines.” If approved by the anesthesia department chiefs, we would set the precedent that these basic rules should be followed by all anesthesia providers at our hospitals. We could and did add other standards over the next few years.2 While the emphasis was on practice behaviors, new technologies greatly exceeded the ability of human senses to detect changes in oxygenation and ventilation, providing earlier warning of adverse events. However, pulse oximetry was not included in the initial standards because it was quite new to the vast majority of anesthesia providers. There was no evidence that its use was efficacious or improved outcomes. Mandating the use of pulse oximetry at the time would have risked objections from some vocal, influential anesthesia faculty who might then have succeeded in blocking the entire effort. Even to this day, there are no well-controlled studies showing a statistically significant benefit on outcomes with pulse oximetry. While it is true that “not everything that counts can be counted (and not everything that can be counted counts),” such an argument to include pulse oximetry in the standards might not have been persuasive. Obviously, being able to detect oxygen desaturation before it reached critical levels had the potential to avoid anesthetic mishaps. Yet, until more experience with pulse oximetry was gained and a tipping point was achieved to induce its almost universal use, many considered it an interesting gimmick that needed to pass the test of time. The committee member who left the meeting room in frustration (James H. Philip) was prescient and later would be proven correct about the value of pulse oximetry. But, to achieve our main goals, we would have to wait a bit for that to play out, which it did soon thereafter. To illustrate this point, a quality assurance study of Recovery Room Impact Events (RRIE) began in 1985 at Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH), initially having nothing to do with pulse oximetry.3 Essentially, an RRIE was an anesthetic mishap that required intervention, impacted Recovery Room care, and did or could cause at least moderate morbidity. When the MGH installed pulse oximetry in every operating room on 1 day in January, 1986, we were able to compare the data collected on RRIEs in the several months before, and then after pulse oximetry was used routinely. Among the 12,088 patients studied, significantly fewer experienced any type of RRIE following pulse oximetry used during their anesthetics. Of course, cause and effect could not be determined. Importantly, there was no significant difference in hypoxic RRIEs before versus after routine use of pulse oximetry. Expecting a reduction in claims and payouts, Controlled Risk Insurance Company’s promise to reduce malpractice premiums if the standards were adopted was the carrot to the stick of mandating standards. Indeed, anesthesia malpractice premiums plummeted over the next few years and have remained low nationwide, about one-third of their peak in the mid 1980s, thus constituting evidence (an alternative to “P < .05”) that the practices (and facilitating technologies) of intraoperative safety monitoring effectively reduced the number and severity of anesthesia mishaps. An indirect but important effect of the standards was to help influence a culture change in patient safety. The biotechnology industry was incentivized to research, develop, and build better instrumentation for convenient, continuous monitoring, About the same time, Dr Ellison (Jeep) Pierce facilitated establishing the Anesthesia Patient Safety Foundation. The American Society of Anesthesiologists' (ASA)-Closed Claims Study showed that pulse oximetry and capnography prevented respiratory-related claims and poor patient outcomes.4 After extensive publicity in the lay press, the 1986 article about the Standards published in the Journal of the American Medical Association,5 led to the ASA’s adopting the Minimal Monitoring Standards almost verbatim, and ultimately, internationally. In 2015, that article was listed as the tenth most important manuscript in the history of anesthesiology.6 We hope this information supplements the authors’ superb review of this topic.1 David J. Cullen, MDDepartment of Anesthesia, Critical Care and Pain MedicineMassachusetts General HospitalHarvard Medical School (retired)Department of Anesthesia and Pain MedicineSt. Elizabeth’s Medical Center and Tufts University School of Medicine (Retired)Boston, MA Jeffrey B. Cooper, PhDDepartment of Anesthesia, Critical Care, and Pain MedicineMassachusetts General HospitalHarvard Medical SchoolBoston, MA[email protected] John H. Eichhorn, MDDepartment of AnesthesiologyUniversity of Kentucky College of Medicine (Retired)Lexington, KY Ward R. Maier, MDDepartment of Anesthesia, Critical Care and Pain MedicineMassachusetts General HospitalHarvard Medical School (retired)Boston, MA James H. Philip, MDDepartment of Anesthesiology, Perioperative and Pain MedicineBrigham and Women’s HospitalHarvard Medical SchoolBoston, MA Robert S. Holzman, MDDepartment of Anesthesiology, Critical Care, and Pain MedicineBoston Children’s HospitalHarvard Medical SchoolBoston, MA
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Cullen et al. (2021) conducted a letter in Patients undergoing anesthesia (n=12,088). Routine use of pulse oximetry vs. Before routine use of pulse oximetry was evaluated on Recovery Room Impact Events (RRIE). Routine use of pulse oximetry during anesthesia was associated with significantly fewer Recovery Room Impact Events among 12,088 patients, though cause and effect could not be determined.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: