Key result
Direct fluorescent antibody staining correctly identifies ~93% of stool specimens containing Coxsackie or ECHO viruses.
Why the study?
Does direct fluorescent antibody staining accurately identify Coxsackie and ECHO viruses compared to routine neutralization tests?
Does direct fluorescent antibody staining accurately identify Coxsackie and ECHO viruses compared to routine neutralization tests?
Direct fluorescent antibody staining provides a more rapid method for identifying Coxsackie and ECHO viruses from stool specimens compared to routine neutralization tests.
May accelerate stool-based enterovirus identification; leaves open routine adoption pending larger prospective validation.
A direct fluorescent antibody staining method for laboratory identification of 3 Coxsackie and 3 ECHO viruses isolated from stool specimens is reported. In the method, monkey kidney tissue cultures inoculated with stool suspensions are stained when they show early cytopathic effect. Seventy stools were studied as unknowns by the fluorescent antibody method. Fifty-five of these had previously been found to contain 1 of the 6 viruses by routine procedures involving neutralization tests. Fifty-one were correctly identified by the fluorescent antibody method. Of the 4 failures, 3 were found negative and 1 was incorrectly typed. Fifteen specimens shown not to contain any of the 6 viruses by the routine method were negative by fluorescent antibody. The reasons for the 4 failures with fluorescent antibody were investigated and modifications introduced into the method that should make it as sensitive and specific as the procedure using neutralization tests. Identification of the viruses was made much more rapidly with fluorescent antibody.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Milford H. Hatch (1963) studied Coxsackie and ECHO virus infection (n=70). Direct fluorescent antibody staining method vs. Routine procedures involving neutralization tests was evaluated on Correct identification of virus isolates. A direct fluorescent antibody staining method correctly identified 51 of 55 stool specimens known to contain Coxsackie or ECHO viruses, and correctly identified all 15 negative specimens.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: