Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Two species of small gekkonid lizards, genus Sphaerodactylus, occur on St. Croix. S. macrolepis occupies most of the island, and S. beattyi is restricted to three disjunct areas in the eastern part of St. Croix. There is little or no overlap of the two species' ranges. At several points the two are very sharply parapatric. We compare the current distributions with records from the late 1930's and from 1965. Borders between the two species appear to have oscillated back and forth during the last 40 years. This distributional pattern is probably due to the competitive exclusion of beattyi by macrolepis from the more mesic portions of the island, which appears to be the most favorable habitat for both species. Evaporative water loss is significantly lower for beattyi, supporting this interpretation. We discuss a model of interspecific competition along an environmental gradient which could explain these observations. CURRENT INTERPRETATIONS OF PATTERNS in island biogeography depend on the belief that regularities are to be found in the extinction and colonization of species on islands. A 'distant' view of insular biotas (discussed by Williams 1969) tries to explain the number of species as a balance between colonization and extinction rates, which are considered functions of variables such as area and distance from the source of colonists (e.g., Gilpin and Diamond 1972). Complementing this line of investigation is the close view of islands, in which one pays close attention to the biological details of a small group of species in order to understand the ways an island community can react to invasion, and tries to delineate the essential features of a good colonist (Williams 1969, Lack 1976). One problem facing the latter approach to island studies is that certain transient stages in the colonization process are rarely found. In particular, the initial contact between ecologically similar species is a seldom-observed stage in island colonization, because the colonizing species suffers rapid extinction, drives the resident species to extinction, orpresumably the least likely possibility-both species evolve niche differences that allow coexistence. Two species of the lizard genus Sphaerodactylus on the island of St. Croix (U.S. Virgin Islands), S. macrolepis and S. beattyi, appear to be at this critical stage of faunal build-up. In this paper we discuss the distribution of these species on St. Croix. Our data indicate that macrolepis is a fairly recent invader of St. Croix and that it has excluded the endemic beattyi from most of the island. In addition, our data, together with previous distributional surveys, show that the edges of the two species' ranges have fluctuated back and forth during the last 40 years, perhaps in response to short-term climatic fluctuations. SUBJECTS, SETTINGS AND METHODS Sphaerodactylus is a small gekkonid lizard which is diverse and widespread in the West Indies (56 species according to Schwartz and Thomas 1975). The two St. Croix species are strictly terrestrial, rarely ascending more than a few inches onto the vegetation. Both species are abundant in situations where leaf litter accumulates, such as on forest floors, along walls, and in gullies, and eat small arthropods. In such places these lizards may be found by turning over rocks and logs or by shuffling through the litter. In dry forest with rocky soil and little litter they are uncommon, and they are essentially absent from fields and other dry, open habitats. During early September 1975 and January 1976 we spent two weeks surveying the distributions of the two species on St. Croix. One of us (WPM) returned in April 1976. Using the distributional data of Thomas and Schwartz (1966, see fig. 3) we began our survey at the points of contact between the two species as previously known, searching until we found the current contacts between the ranges. We sought the lizards in all accessible areas with suitable microhabitat. At all but the most barren sites, we searched until we found several animals. We also hunted for beattyi in the eastern two-thirds of St. Croix, although our mapping efforts there were less 1Present address: Museum of Natural History, University of Kansas, Lawrence, Kansas 66044, U.S.A. BIOTROPICA 11(3): 189-195 1979 189 This content downloaded from 157.55.39.175 on Sun, 02 Oct 2016 05:55:43 UTC All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms intense than near contact zones. The two species are readily and unequivocally identifiable in the field. St. Croix's area is 230 km2, and its highest elevation is 355 m. Rainfall is highly seasonal and variable from year to year (by about a factor of 2 ). Figure 1 shows the 400 ft (121 m) contours and the localities to which we refer. Figure 2 depicts isohets of mean annual rainfall. Where undisturbed, the northwestern range is cloaked with moist forest and the rest of the island with dry forest, grading to cactus scrub at the eastern and southwestern peninsular projections. Most of St. Croix's vegetation has been disturbed by man at one time or another. RESULTS The present distribution of S. beattyi comprises three disjunct areas, two of which are surrounded by the range of S. macrolepis. Figure 3 summarizes the distributional data discussed below. We describe each area and compare the current ranges to those found by Beatty in the 1930's (Grant and Beatty 1944) and by Thomas and Schwartz (1966). These data show that at least one and possibly all three areas have varied considerably in extent during the last 40 years. AREA 1, EASTERN ST. CROIX.-Only S. beattyi now occurs to the east of a line connecting Coakley Bay and the east end of Great Pond. The beach at Coakley Bay is approximately 370 m long; only macrolepis occurs at the west end, and only beattyi at the east end. The intervening area is salt pond and manchineel thicket; no lizards were found there, or elsewhere near this very poisonous tree. Along Seven Hills Road, macrolepis was alone in the lower, level area and only beattyi was found above 500 ft. elevation. In between was a new housing development, where neither species was found. The most intriguing spot we found in this area was immediately east of Great Pond, where we have observed changes in the distribution of both species during the period of our work. Approximately one hectare of thick, low thorn scrub is dissected by a gully. In September 1975 the gully was filled with dead leaves and debris, macrolepis was very abundant but no beattyi was seen. We returned in January 1976 to find beattyi in large numbers, but no macrolepis. The surrounding brush had a low density of lizards. Only macrolepis was found to the west (none found within 35 m) and only beattyi to the east (10 m). In April 1976, the amount of litter in the gully was greatly reduced, and both X/~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Z~Sl ie FIGURS 1 ad 2. igur 1 (aove).St. roix ith pace ames sed i textand 00-fot conours Figue 2s(llow Distrbutio, in nches of man anual rinfal for ears 918-167 (Jrdan r975) . ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~Atn Laoo . _y 190 MacLean and Holt This content downloaded from 157.55.39.175 on Sun, 02 Oct 2016 05:55:43 UTC All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
MacLean et al. (1979) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: