Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Duncan Hunter’s (2013) representation of my position is not entirely accurate, as I shall show below. He has also, however, made some valid points, which I can certainly learn from and will think about further. At the end of the day, despite Hunter’s protestations, our positions are perhaps not so distant from one another as would appear at first glance! Much of his article is based on a rejection of the claim, attributed to me in his opening passage, that ‘teachers have, for too long, allowed their practice to be constrained by theory-driven “methods” (Hunter 2013: 475). I make no such claim: in my introductory section I say explicitly that it is the ‘English language teacher preparation courses and the literature on ELT’ which adopt such constraints; practitioners, on the whole, are too sensible to do so. My plea is not that teachers should stop teaching ‘methods’ (most of them do not do this anyway, a point made in my concluding section), but that methodologists and teacher educators should adopt and promote a more flexible model, which I have called ‘situated pedagogy’.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
P. Ur (2013) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: