This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
As a young nurse and student midwife in the 1970s, I always dreamed of working in a developing country and, after practicing midwifery for several years, my dream became a reality. I moved with my family to southeast Africa to work for the Ministry of Health (MOH) of Mozambique as a cooperante. Cooperantes were health workers, water engineers, agronomists, and other professionals who came from around the world to work, teach, and contribute to the new society being built after Mozambique won independence from Portugal. In those early years, a small number of Mozambican doctors and nurses, working with limited resources and a strong public health vision, led the international cooperantes in the work of educating the next generation of health professionals and providing health care to the people. I was assigned to the Provincial Hospital and Health Science Institute of Quelimane, a port city on the Indian Ocean. Amidst severe shortages of both staff and supplies, I struggled to define my roles as a midwife, teacher, and maternal and child health (MCH) supervisor. Despite setbacks and frustrations, it was very rewarding to be part of a well-organized MCH system that was implementing free prenatal care, an effective immunization program, child health clinics, and maternity centers where women could give birth with a trained attendant. My understanding of what mattered for health quickly broadened to include factors like clean water, sanitation, small animal farming, and female literacy. I practiced and taught midwifery, and provided support and continuing education to midwives in the outlying maternities, and to village traditional birth attendants (TBAs) who were not yet part of the MOH's focus. As a teacher, I had to re-evaluate every aspect of my own midwifery education in order to identify and adapt essential content to our students' educational backgrounds and local conditions. These hard-working young women entered the Health Science Institute around age 18 after six years of primary school; upon graduation, they were often placed in charge of remote, rural maternities that lacked physician back-up and transport. Something I did not think about in Mozambique was research, despite the admonitions of a wise, older surgeon to “collect baseline data, and measure what you do!” It was many years before I understood the powerful role that research can play in changing health practices, particularly when it is grounded in a vision of global equity and focused on the problems of those most in need. So I was excited and intrigued when the article, “Views on involving a social support person in labor in Zambian maternities” was submitted to the Journal of Midwifery & Women's Health (JMWH). As I read the study (the first stimulus for this special issue), I vividly recalled the Quelimane maternity where labor support was also prohibited. How I had wished we midwives had been able to provide women with more kindness and comfort in labor! So it was wonderful to learn that a Zambian midwife and doctoral candidate was examining this problem from a research perspective and thus laying the groundwork for changes in the labor ward policies of her country. The Journal of Midwifery & Women's Health herewith presents a special issue on international health, featuring research studies from Zambia, Tanzania, Mozambique, South Africa, and the ACNM's Division of Global Outreach. Science Update reports on the daunting challenge of mother-to-child HIV transmission in developing countries. Other features remember Bonnie Pedersen, one of ACNM's international health pioneers, and honor Tina Nduna, the Zimbabwean midwife who received the first award established in Bonnie's memory. A notable feature of this issue is that African midwives or nurses are first authors on three articles and co-authors on another. This is an impressive accomplishment in light of the formidable obstacles to research that exist on that continent, as in many other parts of the world. (1) Nurse and midwife researchers are few in number and lack a supportive research infrastructure and mentoring. They may also lack current books, journals, computers, e-mail, and internet access. Post-baccalaureate nursing degrees are unavailable in most developing countries, so aspiring researchers must secure funding to study abroad and then balance an intensive program of study with continuing work obligations and family commitments at home. When the training is completed, the nurse/midwife is likely to be promoted high in the health system, leaving little time to put new research skills into practice or to write up findings for publication. Manuscripts must usually be submitted to foreign journals, since few developing countries have their own nursing and midwifery journals, and even fewer of these publish research. Addressing essential MCH research needs poses special challenges for nurse and midwife researchers in developing nations. First, there is the struggle to place maternal health high on their country's health research agenda, where it must compete for scarce resources with other urgent needs such as HIV/AIDS, malaria prevention, child survival, and tuberculosis control. It should also be noted that developing nations must struggle to advance their own national health research agendas in the face of competing priorities set by foreign donors, including aid agencies, international foundations, nongovernmental organizations (NGOs), and universities. It is now well-understood that less than 10% of global spending on health research is devoted to 90% of the world's health problems (2). This “10/90 gap” is the central problem in international health research; it signifies that the lion's share of global health research funding is devoted to solving medical problems in the wealthy countries, while little is directed toward improving health services for such conditions as diarrhea, malnutrition, infectious and parasitic diseases, and maternal mortality, that affect billions of poor people in developing nations. Another challenge is to achieve legitimacy for nursing and midwifery research questions that are often considered “soft” and difficult to measure compared to traditional markers like disease prevalence or mortality. Consider, for example, some questions posed by the African nurse/midwife researchers in this issue, questions that are shaped by providing maternity services to women in the antenatal clinics and labor wards. Would women benefit by being allowed to have a supportive companion remain with them in labor? What do women need to know to take care of themselves and their babies in the postpartum period? And how does the treatment of women by their midwives during antenatal care impact their clinic attendance? It is unlikely that any of these important questions would be asked by traditional, biomedically-oriented MCH studies. The studies from Indonesia and Mozambique focus on the training of village midwives and traditional birth attendants (TBAs) and raise important issues about project evaluation in international health research. In Indonesia, ACNM midwives and their Indonesian colleagues evaluated the effectiveness of two approaches to village midwife training in a large development project. The midwives conducted this evaluation on their own initiative because they thought it was important to measure the training outcomes and to share this information with the MOH. Unfortunately, many international health projects are never evaluated, even those with large budgets that cause major shifts of resources and manpower in the delivery of health services. These midwife researchers are, therefore, to be commended on several levels: for conducting the evaluation, for doing so in true partnership with the Indonesian Midwifery Association and the MOH, and for designing meaningful tools to measure midwifery knowledge, confidence, and skills. Readers of this report will gain fresh insights into why the ACNM's Division of Global Outreach is internationally respected for the high quality of its development work. For many years, Ministries of Health and donor agencies have organized TBA training programs as a cost-effective way to decrease maternal and infant mortality. So, it is surprising to realize that the evidence regarding the effectiveness of this popular intervention in reducing mortality is mixed. The controlled evaluation of a model TBA training program in Mozambique, carried out by a U.S.-Mozambican research team, has made an important contribution to this debate. The authors found no significant reduction in perinatal mortality in TBA-attended births and a preference for health facility birth over home birth among rural women. A final article by members of the Department of Global Outreach introduces their Home Based Life Saving Skills initiative, designed to help families and communities manage obstetric emergencies. This work branches out from the ACNM's internationally known Life-Saving Skills Manuals, which focused on training midwives in health facilities, to address the management of obstetric emergencies at home, where most of the world's births still occur. Partnerships based on mutual support and respect can be a powerful force for advancing midwifery in developing countries. The ACNM's Department of Global Outreach has set a high standard for projects that empower and train midwives and strengthen their professional societies and local leaders. More and more U.S. midwives are exploring international work, through the ACNM, NGOs, or university affiliations. As we plan and participate in projects overseas, U.S. midwives can be an important voice, helping to ensure that the service, training, and research conducted is truly of benefit to midwives, mothers, and babies in the host country. Our contributions are most effective when we affirm that nursing and midwifery clinicians, teachers, and researchers of the developing countries must define their own priorities and lead the effort to advance MCH care on a local and national level. Such international collaborations can be richly rewarding for all involved; the American College of Nurse-Midwives and the JMWH are pleased and proud to have the opportunity to contribute to this process.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
J RAISLER (2001) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: