Key result
The author argues that obtaining written consent for anaesthesia should be part of normal pre-operative assessment to ensure adequate patient explanation and reduce potential legal costs.
Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Design
Editorial
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The author argues for the importance of proper medical documentation and written consent for anaesthesia to protect against negligence litigation.
I read the editorial by Dr Bogod [1] with interest and would like to comment. In discussing the cases of Kerr and Wooley and Roe, it was not made clear that these cases were heard before the advent of the Civil Procedure Rules, introduced in 1997 as a result of the Woolf reforms. Before this, experts were instructed by the relevant side and were expected to be supportive of whosoever was paying their fees. However, now the responsibility of experts is to the court and not to the person who has instructed them or is paying their fees. With regard to ‘defensive medicine,’ I decided to follow the exhortation, ‘to weed out those articles that appear to have been created primarily for the purpose of protection against possible litigation’ by examining one of my current medicolegal reports. After removing the nursing and management records, I was not able to find anything in this medical record that was there solely to reduce the risk of litigation. In fact, the opposite was true. The production of a defence was difficult because of the lack of basic documentation, such as ensuring that the page contained the patient’s name, that entries were dated and timed and that the name of the doctor was written legibly as well as signed. I believe the presence of an anaesthetic consent form would have formed an extremely robust defence in this case. The outcome of litigation can often hang on the presence or absence of a properly completed consent form, as this is the one document signed by both doctor and patient, indicating exactly what has been agreed, and what are the potential benefits and risks. Our community is becoming more knowledgeable and litigious and I believe that we should strongly consider taking written consent for anaesthesia as part of our normal pre-operative assessment. This would entail time and therefore financial implications, but should ensure that patients receive adequate pre-operative explanation and may well save legal costs following complications. I agree with Dr Bogod that ‘looking over your shoulder may not be the safest way to move forward,’ but any driver would agree that the judicious use of a rear view mirror may stop you getting into trouble.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Geoffrey Harrison (2011) reported a letter. The author argues that obtaining written consent for anaesthesia should be part of normal pre-operative assessment to ensure adequate patient explanation and reduce potential legal costs.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: