Key result
First-quartile birthdates are linked to ~376% higher FC Barcelona selection likelihood, diminishing with age.
Why the study?
The study sought to evaluate the relative age effect within an elite multi-sport context at FC Barcelona.
Cross-Sectional (n=6,542)
No
A significant relative age effect exists in elite multi-sport talent identification, with athletes born earlier in the selection year being significantly more likely to be selected despite the use of psychological and perceptual-cognitive markers.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Relative age bias persists in multi-sport talent selection; leaves open mitigation strategies for prospective cohorts.
The relative age effect is a selection bias toward those individuals born earlier within the selection-year. This study sought to evaluate the relative age effect (RAE) within an elite multi-sport context; FC Barcelona. The birth-dates of all players (n = 6542) affiliated to each sport (male Basketball [n = 1013], male [n = 3012] and female [n = 449] Soccer, male Futsal [n = 761], male Handball [n = 999] and male Indoor Roller Hockey [n = 308]) across all age groups from U10 to Senior were recorded. These were then categorised into quartiles from the start of the selection year (Q1=Jan-Mar; Q2=Apr-Jun; Q3=Jul-Sep; Q4=Oct-Dec) and analysed for; a) each sport, b) each age group, irrespective of the sport and c) each age group within each sport, using Chi-squared statistics and odds ratio’s (OR) with 95% confidence intervals. Birthdates across the entire club revealed a RAE (Q1= 46.1%, Q2= 27.1%, Q3=17.1% & Q4 = 9.7%, X2 = 29.8, P < 0.01), with OR in Q1, Q2 and Q3 representing a 4.76 (95% CI’s:1.96-11.57), 2.80 (1.12-7.03) and 1.77 (0.67-4.63) increased likelihood for selection, when compared to Q4, respectively. Despite a talent identification model that primarily uses psychological and perceptual-cognitive markers, the RAE was still present within youth age groups (<18 yrs old). The current findings provide support that the RAE is more prevalent within high-profile sports and reduces with increasing age, however, given the talent identification processes within the current context, additional factors beyond the physical dominance, such as enhanced psychological and perceptual-cognitive attributes, in those born earlier in the selection year may further exacerbate the RAE.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Doncaster et al. (2020) conducted a cross-sectional in Athletic talent identification (n=6,542). Birth in the first quartile of the selection year (Q1) vs. Birth in the fourth quartile of the selection year (Q4) was evaluated on Likelihood of selection (birthdate distribution) (OR 4.76, 95% CI 1.96-11.57, p=<0.01). Being born in the first quartile of the selection year increased the likelihood of selection into FC Barcelona's sporting programs compared to the fourth quartile, though this relative age effect diminished with increasing age.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: