Key result
A theory-informed behavioral intervention to promote exercise in 21 patients with HFpEF modified negative attitudes and barriers, resulting in a mean exercise adherence of 103 minutes per week.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Personalized, theory-driven behavioral interventions are crucial for overcoming barriers and sustaining exercise adherence in patients with HFpEF.
This invited commentary refers to ‘Working me to life’: longitudinal perceptions from adults with heart failure with preserved ejection fraction enrolled in an exercise training clinical trial’, by E. Salahshurian et al. https://doi.org/10.1093/eurjcn/zvae049. Heart failure with preserved ejection fraction (HFpEF) is rapidly becoming the dominant form of heart failure,1 due to the worldwide increases in people living longer with chronic diseases.2 When coupled with improved awareness and detection, exponential rises in caseloads are predicted.3 Recently, major strides in the pharmacological management of HFpEF have been made. Clinical trials showed significant benefit from sodium-glucose cotransporter 2 inhibitors (SGLT2i) in reducing heart failure hospitalization and cardiovascular death, but minimal improvements in quality of life (QoL).4,5 The STEP-HFpEF trial of glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1) receptor agonists in patients with HFpEF and obesity demonstrated improvements in QoL, 6-min walk distance (6MWD), inflammation, and weight compared to the control group.6 There is also evidence of benefit for selected patients with HFpEF from mineralocorticoid antagonists and angiotensin receptor neprilysin inhibitors.7,8 While this pharmacological treatment is welcomed, it does not address all of the needs of patients—both HFpEF and non-HFpEF related—nor obviate the need for non-pharmacological therapy. Patients with HFpEF have a high prevalence of frailty, sarcopaenia, and multiple comorbidities that contribute to functional impairment, activity intolerance, and risk of falling.9 One treatment that has been consistently associated with clinically meaningful improvements in QoL and other outcomes is exercise training. In head-to-head comparisons with heart failure with reduced ejection fraction (HFrEF), those with HFpEF have been shown to benefit more from exercise therapy.10,11 Other groups that can be difficult to manage have also responded to exercise therapy, including those recently hospitalized with a decompensation of their heart failure12 and/or those with severe physical or psychological impairments.12,13 Exercise training, it would seem, is a panacea for the many ills associated with HFpEF. Despite this, there remain multiple unanswered questions. For example, the exact methods by which exercise exerts its beneficial effects are unclear. One might assume improvements in physical function are a direct result of increased cardio-respiratory fitness. However, there is mounting research suggesting that peripheral (i.e. non-heart) factors play an equally important role.14 Advancing our understanding of mechanism of effect will enable the design of interventions that include optimal modalities in aerobic, resistance, and functional exercise to generate positive outcomes. We also need to establish patients’ preferences, explore barriers to uptake, and identify what might affect adherence in the short and long term.14 The publication of the article ‘working me to life’15 addresses some of these critical gaps in our knowledge. In brief, this was a secondary analysis of longitudinal qualitative data, collected in patients with heart failure at 3, 6, 12, or 18 months, who had participated in a theory-informed behavioural intervention to promote adherence to exercise.11,16 For this analysis, interviews from a sub-group of 21 patients with HFpEF who had participated in ≥2 interviews were selected (n = 67 interviews). Qualitative descriptive methods17 with thematic analysis18 were employed to generate themes that explained varied adherence levels observed (adherence was defined as 120 min/week, mean of sample was 103 ± 54, and range based on characteristics provided was 0–207 min/week). Four themes described perceptions and experiences of barriers to adherence (Themes 1 and 2: overcoming negative attitudes, barriers, and injury; motivations to exercise); effects of adherence (Theme 3: exercise—the panacea for HFpEF symptom relief and QoL); and promoters of adherence (Theme 4: advice for others with HFpEF). The first theme provides some rich insights into modifiers of exercise adherence in HFpEF. Misinformation, particularly around the safety of exercising with HFpEF, was widespread. In some cases, participants were not aware they could exercise or lacked the self-confidence to perform exercise in the context of their significant physical impairments and/or complexity introduced by concurrent illness(es). Such barriers were overcome by personalization and modification of the exercise programme, provided by the dedicated (and from interview excerpts, clearly appreciated) coaches. The analysis also highlights the importance of one’s ‘fitness identity’ (sense of one’s own fitness/sporting ability compared to others, i.e. ‘not sporty’ and ‘fitter than others’), a concept identified by McHale et al.,19 in their review of cardiac rehabilitation engagement. The longitudinal interviews showed that negative attitudes to exercise had changed for many at 12 and 18 months, with later interviews indicating greater self-confidence in ability to exercise and strategies for overcoming barriers to exercise. However, the intervention was not always successful at initiating or sustaining exercise adherence (see divergent cases n = 2). This finding is in itself important as it suggests we are still missing key ingredients to make sure we can entice everyone with HFpEF to become and remain physically active. This theme described the importance of theory-driven programme components (goal setting, self-regulation, relapse prevention, and evaluation) and programme characteristics (setting, supervision, and mode) that appeared to affect motivation and thereby modify adherence. This is notable as most programmes involving older adults, including those with heart failure, rely on exercise prescriptions that are typically based on previous small studies or consensus-driven guidelines (i.e. they are ‘theory free’); further, they are not cognisant of the preferences or priorities of the target population.20 It is difficult to measure the effects of these characteristics quantitatively; therefore, qualitative explorations like this are vital to enhancing our understanding of their impact. The multiple descriptions of physiologic and symptom improvements described in this theme are testament to the efficacy of the intervention, which is quantitively validated in a previous publication (6MWD increased by 63.25 m).11 Reading between the lines, it also raises a vital point, that is of the suitability of traditional outcome measures to capture improvements in pain, sleep quality, resilience, and outlook, all of which were documented during interviews. It does seem that goal setting and self-monitoring alerted participants to their progress, thereby encouraging adherence and even instilled a sense of accountability: now I can get from the parking lot to the inside of the building and walk all the way around and get my clothes off and I’m not huffing and puffing. (Female, 72 years) By exploring what helped people to adhere to the programme, we now have a patient perspective of what is most important to, as one participant put it, ‘Get it done’. Key appeared to be addressing safety, routinization, financial and transportation support, encouragement from an engaged professional, goal setting and reflection that instilled accountability and enabled recognition of achievements, assistance with managing relapses, and the sharing of tips and tricks to help motivate participants to start or complete a session (i.e. preparing the night before, using a local centre, and listening to music.) As the authors note, there is one other qualitative report of an exercise intervention in HFpEF.21 This report provides only a retrospective snapshot and does not document longitudinal experiences. By regularly revisiting patients to obtain their experiences of participation and insights on adherence, the researchers were able to capture contemporary influences that may not have been recalled in a single post hoc interview. For example, the importance of supporting people to manage both HFpEF-related and post-exercise fatigue is highlighted by divergent case 2 (female, 84 years), who achieved 125 min/week of exercise at 3 months but had returned to sedentary behaviour by 18 months due to the perception that the intervention did nothing for her other than ‘wear me out’. Equally, many participants started out with a negative attitude towards exercising: ‘ugghh, I gotta go exercise’ (female, 52, 3 months); however, over time, this changed to ‘I can do it’ (female 52, 18 months). This analysis has identified important insights into exercise adherence in HFpEF. Further qualitative assessments of exercise interventions are desperately needed to build the evidence base. Based on the findings described by Salahshurian et al.,15 there is a clear need to better communicate the safety and efficacy of exercise as a treatment for HFpEF, no matter how encumbered or complex the patients might be. It also highlights the substantial effect that non-exercise characteristics like goal setting and self-regulation can have on adherence, a novel finding that is worth exploring further. Such factors were included as a result of the research team’s engagement with a conceptual theory (social cognitive theory and theory of self-regulation), which is unique in exercise trials in HFpEF.10,22–24 Further exercise trials that engage with theory and longitudinally explore preferences and experiences are needed so that we can build an evidence base of what is more likely to help people with HFpEF ‘Get it done’. Not applicable. No new data were used in this invited commentary.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Forsyth et al. (2024) conducted an editorial in Heart failure with preserved ejection fraction (HFpEF) (n=21). Theory-informed behavioural intervention was evaluated on Exercise adherence and qualitative themes. A theory-informed behavioral intervention to promote exercise in 21 patients with HFpEF modified negative attitudes and barriers, resulting in a mean exercise adherence of 103 minutes per week.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: