Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Qualitative discourse analysis reveals nonbinary self-identification depends on intersubjective power relations in diverse speakers, highlighting limits of purely individualized gender autonomy.
In this article, I discuss how nonbinary gender in the West is constructed through discourses of self‐identification, such as refusing to ascribe gender to the body and disregarding the social forces of cisnormative perception. However, both sociolinguistic research on language and identity and transgender studies suggest that nonbinary self‐identification is more intersubjective than meets the eye. Sociolinguistics has long theorized identity as socially emergent and highly dialogic, while trans studies scholars have recently critiqued the trans focus on agentive self‐identification as entrenched in colonial logics. Through analyses of tactics of intersubjectivity within semi‐structured interviews with Black and White nonbinary individuals and a short‐form social media video of a transmasculine nonbinary Latinx creator, I deconstruct how these nonbinary discourses are nevertheless embedded in, dependent on, and in dialogue with intersubjective power relations. In so doing, I define a critical transfeminist sociolinguistic method for the study of language and identity.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ariana Steele (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: