Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Experimental study reveals that consumer-cause congruence strongly drives consumer responses even with low company-cause fit, suggesting personal relevance outweighs organizational alignment.
Purpose This study examines corporate social responsibility (CSR) fit as a two-dimensional construct by distinguishing between company-cause fit (organizational congruence) and consumer-cause fit (personal congruence). It aims to clarify the roles of these two types of fit in shaping consumer responses to CSR initiatives. Design/methodology/approach Two web-based experimental studies were conducted using a hypothetical sporting goods company. Study 1 employed a repeated-measures design to examine the effects of high versus low company-cause fit. Study 2 investigated the impact of consumer-cause fit within a low company-cause fit context by segmenting participants based on perceived cause importance. The outcome variables included company image, attitudes toward the company and behavioral intention. Findings The results of Study 1 indicate that company-cause fit significantly enhances consumer attitudes, with weaker effects on company image and behavioral intention. In contrast, Study 2 demonstrates that consumer-cause fit exerts a stronger and more consistent influence across all outcome variables, even when company-cause fit is low. These findings suggest that CSR effectiveness operates through two complementary mechanisms: organizational congruence, which primarily influences attitudinal evaluations and personal congruence, which more broadly shapes consumer responses. Practical implications The findings highlight the importance of aligning CSR initiatives with both a firm's core business and the value orientations of target audiences. While company-cause fit contributes to perceived credibility and favorable attitudes, consumer-cause fit can enhance overall effectiveness by increasing personal relevance. Managers should therefore adopt a dual approach that integrates brand alignment with audience segmentation to maximize the impact of CSR strategies. Originality/value This study advances CSR research by conceptualizing fit as a multi-dimensional construct and empirically demonstrating the distinct roles of organizational and personal congruence. By showing that consumer-cause fit can compensate for low company-cause fit, it provides new insights into how CSR initiatives influence consumer responses and offers a more nuanced understanding of CSR effectiveness.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Lee et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: