Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In the past few years, I have noticed a decrease in the number of infants referred to my practice for evaluation of colic. Simultaneously, there has been an increase in referrals of young infants with gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD). Often, these children are already receiving therapy with acid suppressors or prokinetic agents when they reach my office. These healthy infants, of whom many would have had a diagnosis of colic 10 years ago, have usually been referred because their reflux has not improved with therapy. They are referred for more aggressive treatment and further diagnostic investigation of what the parent and referring physician believe is “severe GERD.” A decade ago, I would have been the one to decide whether a diagnostic workup of GER was indicated, let alone treatment. Could it be that my “epidemic” of GER represents a simple reclassification of colic as GER? Traditionally, pediatricians have used the “rule of three” to define colic: crying for at least 3 hours a day, for 3 days a week, or for 3 weeks in a row (1). Surveys show that a surprising 23% of infants demonstrate symptoms of colic by 6 weeks of age (2). Crying in healthy infants peaks at 6 weeks of age, and at 3 months of age still occupies approximately 1 hour per day (3). No gastrointestinal symptoms are specified for the diagnosis of colic; however, symptoms reported by parents frequently include abdominal pain and distention, excessive gas, infrequent stools and emesis. In this highly charged situation, faced with a parent who may resent the diagnosis of colic as insufficient to explain the intensity of crying behavior, I think primary physicians may be ignoring the rule of three and may be substituting “diagnosis inflation” by offering to the family what sounds like a more believable cause for crying. Gastroesophageal reflux has become this convenient diagnostic culprit. There is not a great deal of evidence to support the relation between acid reflux and colic. In one study of pH probe data from infants with excessive crying and presumed GER, a reflux index more than 10% was found in only 1 of 24 infants younger than 3 months of age and in 10 of 46 infants older than 3 months of age. All infants with positive pH probes had excessive vomiting (4). This would suggest that in the absence of vomiting, GER is an uncommon cause of infant irritability. A recent review of pH probe studies supports this view by failing to find a correlation between irritability and episodes of reflux on prolonged recordings (5). Other research suggests that colic is the primary event that produces emesis and positive test results for reflux. Crying infants swallow air, which may increase the frequency of transient lower esophageal sphincter relaxations and thus promote acid reflux episodes (6). Overfeeding colicky infants in an effort to placate them may also increase postcibal reflux episodes (7). Since GER is considered a disease, this creates a momentum for diagnostic tests and subsequent therapy. The most frequent diagnostic test performed by the referring pediatricians in my geographic area is a radiocontrast upper gastrointestinal series, which has a significant false-positive rate for the diagnosis of reflux. Other tests, including upper endoscopy, pH probe, and even manometry increase the cost of the evaluation and the anxiety of the parent. When these test results are negative, it is difficult to “retreat” to a diagnosis of colic. Because heartburn cannot be completely excluded as a cause for pain even with negative test results for GER (5), a therapeutic trial of acid inhibition seems reasonable regardless of test results. In my opinion, an empirical trial of acid blockade is appropriate in fussy infants before invasive tests. I have adopted a nonaggressive approach toward the vigorous, well-grown, irritable infant with frequent nonprojectile emesis. I have found that this approach avoids diagnostic escalation and allows me and the parents to adopt a more realistic approach to their child's symptoms and expectations of control. Rather than attaching the label of GERD to these infants and implying thereby that I will “cure” it, I recommend the following therapy: (1) Limit the total formula administration to 100 to 120 mL · kg−1 · d−1, preferably at feeding intervals of 3 hours or less; (2) teach careful burping; (3) if necessary, add an osmotic laxative to produce at least 1 stool per day; (4) thicken feeds with cereal or add solid foods for satiety and use water, not juice (8) for thirst. Counseling parents about recognizing infant cues and taking steps to prevent the establishment of the crying state before it becomes impossible to intervene is very helpful. Often, these conservative, simple steps correct both the irritability and the spitting. The issue of sleeping position for these children is an important one. Because there is a very large population of infants with simple colic, advising the parents of colicky infants to place their children in a prone position as a “noninvasive” treatment for potential GER could put these infants at risk for sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS). Although side-sleeping may be helpful for GER and offers a compromise (9), it is a difficult position to maintain. Head elevation may not offer additional advantage in either the prone or the supine position (9). Available data suggest that widespread use of the supine sleeping position has not increased episodes of aspiration (10). We do not, however, have good data on what the supine sleeping position has done in regard to the incidence of gastroesophageal reflux since its widespread acceptance in North America. I regret that prone positioning has been removed from my list of conservative measures for an infant that spits; however, the weight of evidence regarding the decreased incidence of SIDS is compelling, and I agree with the recently published NASPGN position paper on GER that has endorsed the supine sleeping position for infants with GER unless severe symptoms are present (11). Overuse of the diagnosis of GERD in fussy infants strikes me as being like the man who tried to use a shovel to escape from a hole. Making the diagnosis of GERD in these infants increases anxiety and expectations for cure, creating a hole from which we gastroenterologists may find escape difficult.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
James L. Sutphen (2001) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: