Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In this month’s issue, we have the trio of content noted in the title and some guest coauthors. First, we turn to our editorial board members Bruce Jacobs and Sam Washington for a mini review on our Health Services Research Methodology Section. JUOP HEALTH SERVICES RESEARCH INTRODUCTION AND HIGHLIGHTS The Journal of Urology Open Plus recognizes the value of health services research and is eager to publish high-quality health services research studies that use quantitative, qualitative, and mixed-methods (ie, quantitative and qualitative) approaches. Quantitative research has served as the backbone for health services research for decades. Examining large cancer registries (eg, SEER-Medicare data, National Cancer Database) and retrospective data collected from multiple institutions provides insight into changing practice patterns, clinical decision-making, and treatment outcomes for our patients.1-3 Furthermore, these studies are often pooled together in systemic reviews or meta-analyses that offer a broader perspective on specific clinical questions.4 Quantitative research can be hypothesis-generating and provide a crucial foundation for further study. As a whole, quantitative research provides new knowledge while also elucidating knowledge gaps. Quantitative research helps us understand what we know and what we do not know and helps inform other methodologies that can further our understanding. Qualitative research is emerging as a complementary approach to the standard health services research studies that typically use a quantitative approach using large, observational data sets. Although there is not a universal definition, qualitative research can be defined as the “investigation of phenomena, typically in an in-depth and holistic fashion, through the collection of rich narrative materials using a flexible research design.”5 It explores and provides deep insights into real-world problems, often relying on participant interviews.6 There are many benefits to qualitative research, including the ability to gain context surrounding a research topic and exploring factors that are not typically collected as part of larger data sets. While familiarity with qualitative research is growing, it is still an approach that is not yet widely accepted, so publishing qualitative research studies can be cumbersome.7 The Journal of Urology Open Plus appreciates the value of qualitative research as a major contributor to the breadth of health services research and encourages researchers with qualitative studies to submit their work for consideration. We have already published several qualitative studies to date.8-10 Publishing high-quality health services research studies is a priority of The Journal of Urology Open Plus. We are open to considering more traditional health services research studies, such as those that use large, observational data sets, and more novel ones, including those that use qualitative research approaches or those that use a mixed-methods approach, which combines both quantitative and qualitative work within the same study. We hope that the Journal of Urology Open Plus will be one of the premier destinations for these types of studies within urology in the future. MAY 2024 JUOP NEW ARTICLES Health Services Research Li et al11 looked at the question of overall prognosis for bladder cancer in patients age older than 75 years. Using the Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results Program (SEER) database (one of the originals for health services research), they found 13,505 cases in this age group from 2000 to 2018 and well distributed in 5-year age increments (75-79 years, 80-84 years, 85 years or older). Overall the 5-year survival was 49%, with multivariate predictors of survival to include age, grade, tumor size, American Joint Committee on Cancer stage, surgery, chemotherapy, and radiation. The 3-year and 5-year survival for stage IV was 17% and 11%, respectively. These variables were used to construct a prognostic nomogram. There are the usual limitations of this database but overall a useful way to predict survival and weight treatment choices in this age group. Houjaij et al12 performed a comparison of partial to radical nephrectomy, looking at complications and contributions to mortality. This group used the National Surgical Quality Improvement program which yielded a database of 24,830 patients and propensity score matching used to improve the comparative groups. Overall, the radical nephrectomy group had 20.5% rate of any surgical complication vs 15.9% for partial. The partial group had more infectious and bleeding complications. There are more details available, but overall this paper is a good illustration of some of the issues in health services research—a nice sized database, but with some key limitations such as a lack of details on tumor pathology and surgical approach (open/lap/robotic). Rare Conditions In a challenging case presentation, Garabed et al13 present a case of significant benign prostatic hypertrophy and bulbar obliterative stricture managed with a combined holmium laser enucleation of the prostate (HoLEP) of the 200cc gland and buccal graft urethroplasty. We had a spirited discussion on this one in peer review, as the combined case length was over 9 hours. Some of this was patient driven (patient refused perineal urethrostomy). There are a number of different solutions possible here and well discussed, but overall a novel 2-procedure/2-surgeon solution. Video Manuscripts Kong et al14 demonstrate a robotic approach to a retained ureteral stent with significant encrustation. This publication format is an effective way to highlight an interesting case, demonstrate key surgical technique (robotic and use of a ureteroscope via laparoscopic access), discuss outcomes, and present a key review of the literature. Well done. Yang et al15 present a video manuscript that shows another use of the medium—a demonstration of a surgical model with scientific comparisons. The goal was to investigate different ureteroscopic irrigation methods and to test them in a model. The video is a state-of-the-art lecture with video examples. This work was submitted to the 2024 AUA annual meeting and accepted as a pathway to publication manuscript. In another 2024 AUA annual meeting pathway to publication submission, Yanes et al16 present their work on a 3D printed model for training vasectomies. This model uses a low-cost, effective model suing hydrogel materials. Future work is needed to test performance in real training situations. Finally—a special thanks to our peer reviewers—this issue includes a listed of 2023 top JUOP reviewers.17 People, Places, and Things—A Visiting Professor Experience by Daniel A. Igel, MD Urology programs across the United States and the world regularly welcome visiting professors, hoping to bring an outside perspective to their institution. At the University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center, we recently had the great pleasure of hosting Cheryl T. Lee, MD, the Dorothy M. Davis Chair in Cancer Research, Professor and Chair of the Department of Urology at The Ohio State University as our visiting professor. After her touchdown in Houston, she was hosted by the faculty for dinner and a talk/discussion on educational topics—Figures 1 and 2. The day with the fellows started with Dr Lee sharing her experience and expertise in increasing patient representation in genitourinary oncology trials with the entire MD Anderson multidisciplinary Genitourinary Cancer Center. As an international expert in this area, she demonstrated the great importance of diversity in clinical trials and had numerous insights and tips into how this can be accomplished with careful adjustment of trial inclusion criteria and outreach efforts to recruit underserved populations. This talk was followed by a fellow-focused interactive lecture on education and mentorship. With her wealth of experience as an educator and scientist, she shared her perspective on providing clinical and especially surgical education to trainees grounded in the evidence-based literature on the topic, much of which was from her group at The Ohio State University. This was followed by fellow research presentations, with thoughtful feedback from Dr Lee on how each of our projects could be improved to have the greatest impact. After a brief break for lunch, the day resumed with a nontraditional leadership activity where we learned about the organizational “Hedgehog Concept,” which focuses on the advantages of organizational specialization. This came complete with a creative exercise with groups of fellows presenting their insights into these concepts using posters made from wrapping paper and magazine clippings—Figure 3. As is true with many of our visiting professors, the highlight of the day was networking with Dr Lee over margaritas and the finest Tex-Mex that Houston has to offer after the formal presentations were over—Figure 4.Figure 1.: Places. Visiting Professor Cheryl Lee meets with the MD Anderson Urology faculty at Brennan’s private room (A) to present and discuss challenges in surgical training. Brennan’s is a great venue to show off Houston culinary options with its Creole style dining. Finishing the night is the memorable table-side prepared Bananas Foster (B).Figure 2.: People. The Program Directors—Cheryl Lee from Ohio State and Brian Chapin from MD Anderson coordinate visiting professor events many months in advance.Figure 3.: Places. The visiting professor gets a nice conference room and a whole day to interact with trainees on lectures, case presentations, discussions, and apparently a craft project on the board.Figure 4.: People. Visiting professor Cheryl Lee poses with all 10 urologic oncology fellows at MD Anderson Cancer Center. Left to right: Wei Shen Tan, Alberto Martini, Côme Tholomier, Suzanne Lange, Valentina Grajales, Cheryl Lee, Amanda Myers, Alexis Steinmetz, Andrew Fang, Jamaal Jackson, and Daniel Igel.Hosting a visiting professor like Dr Lee comes with numerous learning opportunities. Most obviously is the didactic learning, in this case we learned a great deal about enhancing diversity in clinical trials and how to provide surgical education to residents and fellows and critical concepts in the daily life of a urologic oncologist. The learning environment for a visiting professor is drastically different than a lecture at a conference or online, as the sessions are truly interactive, allowing trainees to ask questions, present their own work, and gain unique insights into how they can improve their clinical and scholarly work. Probably the most valuable part of hosting a visiting professor, particularly for trainees, is the rare opportunity to network with giants in our field in a familiar and even casual setting. For an academician of her standing, Dr Lee was humble, open, and friendly with trainees and staff alike, setting an example for us to aspire to in our own careers. For perspective—a bonus photo from the MD Anderson visiting professor visit by Jay Smith in 2002—Figure 5—setting up decades of networking/collaboration with Dr Smith and Vanderbilt.Figure 5.: People. Visiting professor memories can last a long time. In this 2002 photo, former Journal of Urology editor Jay Smith was the visiting professor during my fellowship. Left to right: John Paul Sweeney, Charles Rosser, John Davis, Sam Huang, David Shepherd, Jay Smith, David Swanson, Carlos Bermejo, Ashish Kamat, and Jason Gee.Sending her back to Ohio State in style—Dr Lee receives a commemorative plaque and some MD Anderson “merch”—Figure 6.Figure 6.: Things. No visiting professor experience is complete without a commemorative plaque to mark the occasion.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Washington et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: