Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
To the Editor: The article by Bouaziz et al. [1], which details the midhumeral approach to regional anesthesia of the upper limb, is an elegant introduction of this block to the English-language anesthesia literature. We have been routinely using this approach in our practice since visiting Dupre [2] in 1995 and agree with the authors concerning its ease of performance and the success rates achieved (87% of a total 78 blocks performed; H.P. Frizelle, unpublished data). However, there are some points that need further clarification. The authors compare the four-nerve stimulation technique with the two-nerve stimulation technique (musculocutaneous and another) of Lavoie et al. [3]. They cite the risk of neurological damage and the high success rate (94%) of Lavoie et al. as the reason for this decision. However, their rate of successful sensory block was 54%, considerably less than that reported in the Lavoie et al. article. The definition of successful block varies little between the two groups, i.e., fine touch versus Wartenburg pinwheel. Other work suggests that the more nerves detected, the higher the success rate of the block [4]. Perhaps a comparison of the Dupre technique with a four-nerve stimulation axillary approach would be more valid. Some additional comments can be made on the description of the technique used. The use of a palpating finger to locate the brachial artery, although necessary, must be performed with care. The needle tip can be approximated to the median nerve by this palpating finger, although it is, in reality, much further away. Evoked motor activity at 0.5 mA or less must be present in the median nerve distribution when the palpating finger has been removed, or a failed block may ensue. Second, the use of the term midhumeral is inappropriate. The authors correctly suggest the entry point of the needle to be the junction of the upper and middle third of the arm. The importance of this needs to be emphasized, because a lower approach will result in failure to block the radial nerve, which passes in the groove posterior to the humerus. Thus, a midhumeral approach will miss this nerve, which is in a lateral position at this point. Keeping the above nomenclature in mind, we suggest Dupre's technique be known as the brachial or humeral canal approach to the brachial plexus, which is not only closer to the original French description, but also more anatomically correct. Henry P. Frizelle, MB, FFARCSI Denis C. Moriarty, MB, FFARCSI Department of Anesthesia; Mater Misericordiae Hospital, Dublin 7, Ireland.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Frizelle et al. (1998) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: