Key result
Exercise blood pressure and heart rate responses provide prognostic information in coronary artery disease, though clinical significance depends heavily on underlying left ventricular function.
Why the study?
Does the assessment of exercise blood pressure and heart rate provide prognostic value in patients with coronary artery disease?
Does the assessment of exercise blood pressure and heart rate provide prognostic value in patients with coronary artery disease?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The prognostic value of exercise blood pressure and heart rate responses is highly dependent on underlying cardiac function, where blunted responses in CAD patients indicate higher risk.
Introduction Exercise testing is currently considered a useful modality for assessing a subject with suspected coronary heart disease. However, a number of studies have extended our knowledge on the clinical significance of exercise testing, suggesting that the prognostic value of this test may have been underestimated. Parameters other than those directly related to myocardial ischemia have proved to be independent predictors of mortality. Among these, the blood pressure response to exercise and the assessment of heart rate during exercise and recovery have gained much credit. Several prospective studies have demonstrated that excessive increases in blood pressure during exercise testing may be a marker of future hypertension and increased risk of cardiovascular mortality [1–5]. However, other studies failed to show a prognostic advantage from assessment of exercise blood pressure [6,7], and some studies even found an inverse relationship between changes in blood pressure during exercise and mortality [8,9]. The results obtained by Habibzadeh et al. [10], published in this issue of the Journal, are in keeping with those of the latter studies [8,9]. The authors addressed the question of whether an abnormal blood pressure or heart rate response to exercise testing performed on a treadmill may help identify coronary patients at increased risk of cardiovascular events or death. They found that participants with systolic blood pressure increases in the highest quartile had a decreased rate of hospitalization for heart failure, myocardial infarction, stroke or transient ischemic attack, and all-cause mortality. After adjusting for several potential confounders including resting heart rate and blood pressure, participants with systolic blood pressure increase in the highest quartile remained at lowest risk of myocardial infarction, hospitalization for heart failure and death, although these associations were largely explained by greater exercise capacity in the patients with the greatest systolic blood pressure increment. Changes in heart rate had similar relationships with cardiovascular outcomes. Blood pressure hemodynamics during exercise During dynamic exercise the need for increasing oxygen delivery to the working muscles is fulfilled by local vasodilatation [11]. A simultaneous vasoconstriction occurs in the nonworking muscles and in the splanchnic vascular district. Venous return increases to provide an appropriate rise in cardiac filling. This results in an increase in stroke volume, which coupled with the increase in heart rate, produces a marked rise in cardiac output. The net integration of these hemodynamic changes results in a considerable increase in systolic blood pressure. The extent to which blood pressure increases during exercise may vary, however, in relation to the hemodynamic components of blood pressure [12]. In a hypertensive subject with increased peripheral resistance and normal left ventricular performance, an increased blood pressure response is likely to occur during exercise for a failure to reduce total peripheral resistance. In contrast, in a cardiac patient with depressed left ventricular pump function, a reduced increase in blood pressure can be found at peak exercise even in the presence of increased peripheral resistance for a failure to properly increase cardiac output. The importance of the hemodynamic components of blood pressure for the prediction of cardiovascular events was highlighted by Fagard et al. [12] in a leading study performed with intra-arterial blood pressure measurement. In that study, exercise blood pressure did not significantly predict the incidence of cardiovascular events over and above pressure at rest; by contrast, exercise systemic vascular resistance added prognostic precision to vascular resistance at rest, and cardiac output measured with the Fick's method showed even a tendency to an inverse relationship with outcome [12]. The above data indicate that the practical value of blood pressure measurements during routine exercise testing for more precise determination of the cardiovascular risk profile is of little value when performed in a heterogeneous population. In fact, if left ventricular pump function is normal, increased peripheral resistance will result in an exaggerated blood pressure response to exercise. However, if left ventricular performance is depressed, a normal blood pressure increase can be seen during exercise in spite of an elevated peripheral resistance. The above data reconcile the apparently conflicting results of the literature. In many patients with coronary artery disease, such as those investigated by Habibzadeh et al.[10] in the Heart and Soul study, high-level exercise can unmask a left ventricular dysfunction. The inverse relationship between exercise blood pressure and cardiovascular events found by Habibzadeh et al. [10] would thus reflect a more compromised pump function in the subjects with the lowest systolic blood pressure increase. This is suggested also by the clinical characteristics of the Heart and Soul Study participants with blood pressure increases in the lowest quartiles [10]. Indeed, a positive history of myocardial infarction or hypertension was more common in these patients, who used more frequently diuretics, β-blockers, and calcium channel blockers, indicating the presence of more advanced cardiac disease. Previous studies that showed an inverse association between exercise blood pressure and outcome were also performed in cardiac patients [8,9], whereas studies in populations of healthy subjects generally showed a direct relationship between the blood pressure response to exercise and cardiovascular events or death [1–5]. Thus, the clinical significance of the blood pressure response to exercise testing heavily depends on the underlying clinical conditions, and interpretation of results may be equivocal. Chronotropic response to exercise Several studies have shown that chronotropic incompetence during exercise is of prognostic value in asymptomatic men [13,14] as well as cardiac patients [15,16] independent of traditional risk factors, and that it is predictive of death also in patients on β-blockers [14,17]. A re-analysis of the Paris Prospective Study I has shown that a low heart rate response to exercise is a powerful predictor of mortality [14]. Several chronotropic indexes have been used in the literature but there is no general agreement on which measure provides the best prognostic information [18]. A common approach is to measure peak heart rate and the change in heart rate during exercise. These are the parameters used in the study by Habibzadeh et al. showing that increased heart rate peak and increased heart rate change during exercise not only predict decreased mortality, but also lower rate of adverse cardiovascular events, including myocardial infarction, heart failure, and stroke. However, it is known that peak heart rate decreases with increasing age. In addition, several other confounding factors may affect the chronotropic response to exercise [18]. That is why the so-called chronotropic index has been used as a marker of abnormal heart rate response during exercise [18]. Recent studies have suggested that this measure is a better predictor of mortality than the more traditional percentage of age-predicted heart rate [19]. To calculate the chronotropic index, age, physical fitness, resting heart rate, and the age-predicted maximum heart rate are taken into account [18], and a threshold value lower than 80% has been used to define chronotropic incompetence [15,19]. According to Elhendy et al. [16], the chronotropic index is superior for predicting cardiac events whereas the use of 85% of age-predicted maximum heart rate is superior for predicting all-cause mortality in patients with coronary artery disease. Therefore, both parameters should be used in the coronary patient, because they provide complementary information. Other indexes of chronotropic incompetence have been recently proposed. According to Savonen et al. [13], the slope of heart rate increase during exercise calculated from heart rate recorded at 40, 60, 80, and 100% of maximal workload, was a better predictor of cardiovascular death than the change in heart rate from rest to peak exercise. As the 40–100% heart rate slope mainly depends on the response of the sympathetic nervous system to stress testing and does not include the early portion of the slope which reflects mainly the withdrawal of the vagal tone, the above data suggest that the main factor mediating the association between chronotropic incompetence and cardiovascular events is a reduced ability to increase sympathetic activity. The assessment of the heart rate changes during exercise testing should always also include the evaluation of heart rate during recovery. After exercise, there is a rapid decline in heart rate, which can be prevented by atropine administration and is thus attributed to vagal reactivation [20]. The post-exercise fall in heart rate has been found to provide useful prognostic information in asymptomatic subjects and in patients undergoing stress testing for diagnostic purposes [21,22]. In a study performed in more than 3500 asymptomatic adults, a failure of the heart rate to decrease by more than 12 beats per minute during the first minute after exercise provided prognostic information for mortality over and above the Framingham risk score or the European risk score [21]. According to Cole et al. [22], a delayed decrease in heart rate after exercise was an independent predictor of mortality also when the chronotropic response during exercise was taken into account. These data indicate that heart rate should be measured also during the recovery period because assessment of heart rate during exercise and the recovery may provide complementary information [23]. Unfortunately, heart rate during the recovery was not available in the Habibzadeh's study [10]. More precise prognostic information could be acquired within the frame of the Heart and Soul Study if the predictive value of more parameters of chronotropic incompetence and heart rate during the recovery period were tested. Exercise changes in heart rate have similar relationships with outcome in healthy subjects and cardiac patients. Chronotropic incompetence is believed to reflect an abnormal modulation of the autonomic nervous system tone, which can be present in several clinical settings including severe coronary artery disease or left ventricular dilation and dysfunction [18]. As a consequence, subjects with abnormal heart rate responses may be more predisposed to life-threatening ventricular arrhythmias chiefly in the presence of coronary artery disease [24]. Patients with impaired heart rate response to exercise have been found also to have endothelial dysfunction, enhanced systemic inflammation, and higher NT-proBNP concentrations [25]. However, it is difficult to establish whether these biomarkers are the primary abnormality underlying chronotropic incompetence or whether there is a common pathway that results in abnormalities of humoral factors and chronotropic response to exercise. Limitations of exercise studies An important limitation of the studies that focused on the prognostic value of hemodynamic assessment during exercise is the lack of objective data for establishing normalcy limits for the blood pressure response to exercise or for the measures of chronotropic incompetence [26]. The problem is particularly complicated for the blood pressure changes for which both upper and lower limits of normality should be established. Furthermore, exercise hemodynamics may vary according to the type of ergometer used for stress testing. Several studies have demonstrated that bicycle ergometry tends to produce a lower peak v˙O2 compared with treadmill because untrained subjects usually terminate cycle exercise at a 10 to 20% lower peak work rate due to muscle fatigue [27]. Chronotropic incompetence has been found to be lower in treadmill than in bicycle [28]. Also, patients have a slower drop in heart rate during the early phase of recovery during treadmill than bicycle ergometry with a significantly higher rate of abnormal response [28]. These ergometer-related differences make it even more difficult to identify universal normalcy limits for the hemodynamic parameters measured during exercise. Another important limitation of exercise studies when performed chiefly in cardiac patients is the confounding effect of cardio-active and antihypertensive medications. This is well exemplified in the Habibzadeh et al. study, in which cardio-active drug use was unbalanced across the quartiles of hemodynamic changes [10]. Use of statistical adjustments can hardly eliminate the confounding effect of each single drug, which is determined not only by the presence or absence of medication but also by drug doses and combinations. Finally, it should be always taken into account that resting heart rate and heart rate responses to exercise, though depending to a large extent on sympathetic function, cannot be regarded as variables modulated only by adrenergic mechanisms. This consideration makes it difficult to extrapolate, from the heart rate behaviour at rest or during exercise, information selectively focused on sympathetic neural function [26]. Conclusion Tests capable of identifying cardiac patients at increased risk of cardiovascular complications can improve the appropriate prescription of life-saving drugs such as aspirin, statins, or β-blockers. The blood pressure and heart rate responses to exercise testing have been associated to adverse outcome in several studies. Chronotropic incompetence has been shown to predict cardiovascular morbidity over and above the traditional risk factors. The clinical significance of an abnormal blood pressure response to stress testing is more equivocal and there is no evidence as yet that gaining this knowledge leads to improved patients' management. Sources of variability and protocol standardization remain contentious issues. The main problem with exercise blood pressure is that results are commensurate to the underlying clinical condition. In healthy subjects with normal left ventricular function, an increased response to exercise may predict development of hypertension and future cardiovascular events. Conversely, in coronary patients with left ventricular dysfunction a relatively greater response to exercise is associated with improved outcome. Whether the hemodynamic response to exercise can be modified and whether pursuing aggressive risk factor changes in patients with abnormal response can improve outcomes in asymptomatic adults or cardiac patients is not known. Improvement in the present knowledge could be achieved by better standardizing the protocols of exercise testing and by measuring blood pressure and heart rate throughout exercise and recovery in order to identify the most meaningful parameters.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Palatini et al. (2010) conducted an editorial in Coronary artery disease. Exercise blood pressure and heart rate assessment was evaluated. Exercise blood pressure and heart rate responses provide prognostic information in coronary artery disease, though clinical significance depends heavily on underlying left ventricular function.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: