Key result
In fetal sheep at 0.85 gestation, mean fetal heart rate in low-voltage sleep was 159 beats/min after sympathectomy compared to 173 beats/min in control fetuses.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The authors reiterate that high-frequency spectral power of fetal heart rate variability is minimal in the last third of gestation in fetal sheep and is largely unaffected by autonomic blockade.
We are delighted with the interest from Casati & Frasch (2014) in our study of the development of the power spectrum of fetal heart rate variability (FHRV). We are confused by the call to adhere to a fetal standard when there is currently no consensus or a strong evidence base to justify a fetal range. Our goal was systematically to quantify changes in FHRV spectral power in the last third of gestation to see whether these changes could be related to the known maturation of sympathetic activity (Booth et al. 2011). The most striking finding was that there is very little high-frequency activity over the last third of gestation in the fetal sheep. This is consistent with previous reports in human pregnancy from magnetocardiogram recordings that included assessment of higher frequency activity from 0.4 to 1.7 Hz that nearly all FHR power was less than 0.2 Hz, showing that there is relatively limited additional value in measuring power above 0.4 Hz (David et al. 2007). Given that lower frequency FHRV power represented a mixture of sympathetic and parasympathetic activity, the small amount of (primarily) parasympathetic-mediated high-frequency activity must limit the utility of FHR power spectral analysis. Although it is of considerable interest to measure the maturation of autonomic activity in multiple regions (Booth et al. 2011), this would be a very indirect way of assessing control of FHR. The respondents may wish to reflect that they are hypothesizing that sympathetic activity does not contribute to the high-frequency band and thus they do not anticipate a correlation between high-frequency activity and changes in sympathetic activity. Instead, we used sympathectomy and parasympathetic blockade to induce large, categorical changes in autonomic activity to show unequivocally the limited impact on high-frequency spectral power after either intervention. This finding is robust. If the reference to subtle changes in the FHR simply means high frequency activity, then we respectfully disagree. We recorded the fetal ECG at 1024 Hz, which is more than sufficient to resolve beat-to-beat variation to less than 1 ms. Given how little high-frequency activity we observed even at 0.85 gestation, in practice the difference from estimates derived from lower frequency recordings would be trivial. Could this conclusion be affected by breathing movements? Irrespective of whether non-ventilatory fetal breathing movements are sufficient to induce changes in heart rate, near-term fetuses show no breathing movements in high-voltage sleep, and the greatest rate of movements occurs in low-voltage sleep, at a mean of 56 breaths min−1 (Bennet et al. 1990). Preterm fetuses ‘breathe’ more or less continuously, but at a lower overall rate. Given that in our study the mean FHR at 0.85 gestation in low-voltage sleep was 173 beats min−1 in control fetuses and 159 beats min−1 after sympathectomy, we can be confident that breathing movements were consistently much less than half mean FHR, and so according to the Nyquist criterion, that no aliasing occurred that would reduce measured frequency of FHRV. Readers are invited to give their opinion on this article. To submit a comment, go to: http://ep.physoc.org/letters/submit/expphysiol;99/2/468.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Koome et al. (2014) conducted a letter in Fetal heart rate variability. Sympathectomy and parasympathetic blockade vs. Control fetuses was evaluated on Mean fetal heart rate (FHR) at 0.85 gestation in low-voltage sleep. In fetal sheep at 0.85 gestation, mean fetal heart rate in low-voltage sleep was 159 beats/min after sympathectomy compared to 173 beats/min in control fetuses.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: