Key result
Arm crank exercise elicits higher heart rates and lactate than cycling at matched oxygen uptake.
Why the study?
Does arm crank exercise elicit different physiological responses compared to cycle exercise in healthy males?
Does arm crank exercise elicit different physiological responses compared to cycle exercise in healthy males?
p-value: p=< 0.05
Upper-body exercise can be performed for 60 minutes at a relative intensity sufficient for cardiovascular training, though exercise prescriptions based on heart rate may need modification due to lower heart rates compared to lower-body exercise.
Greater physiological strain during arm cranking at matched VO2 warrants caution in intensity monitoring; leaves open optimal upper-body exercise prescriptions.
PIMENTAL, NANCY A., MICHAEL N. SAWKA, DARKEN S. BILLINGS, and LAURIE A. TRAD. Physiological responses to prolonged upper-body exercise. Med. Sci. Sports Exerc., Vol. 16, No. 4, pp. 360–365, 1984. To date, investigators have not examined physiological responses to prolonged upper-body exercise. Knowledge of the feasibility of performing this type of exercise and the elicited responses could have application in designing continuous training programs for upger-body muscle groups. Nine males, with a peak oxygen uptake (V ± SD) of 49 V7 for cycle (CY) and 35 ± 6 ml. min-1 kg-1 for arm crank (AC) exercise, completed four 60-min exercise tests. The subjects performed AC and CY exercise at the same absolute (ABS) oxygen uptake (1.6 1.min-1) and at the same relative (REL) percent of ergometer-specific peak oxygen uptake (60%). During the ABS tests, AC exercise elicited significantly (P < 0.05) greater heart rate (HR), ventilatory equivalent of oxygen (Ve ± VO2-1), blood lactate (La), and percent decrease in plasma volume (PV) than CY exercise. During the REL tests, HR was lower and VeVVo2-1 was higher for AC than CY exercise; there were no differences between AC and CY exercise in La or PV responses. These data demonstrate that upper-body exercise can be performed for 60 min at a relative intensity which might be sufficient to elicit a cardiovascular training effect. However, because heart rates are lower during upper-than lower-body exercise at the same relative intensity, exercise prescriptions based on heart rate alone may need to be modified for upper-body exercise.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Pimental et al. (1984) studied this question. Arm crank (AC) exercise vs. Cycle (CY) exercise was evaluated on Heart rate, ventilatory equivalent of oxygen, blood lactate, and percent decrease in plasma volume (p=< 0.05). Arm crank exercise at the same absolute oxygen uptake elicited significantly greater heart rate, ventilatory equivalent of oxygen, blood lactate, and plasma volume decrease than cycle exercise (P<0.05).
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: