Key result
5x/week RUL ECT shows a trend toward shorter treatment without added cognitive morbidity vs 3x/week.
Why the study?
Does 5 times per week right unilateral ECT shorten length of stay without increasing adverse effects compared to 2-3 times per week ECT in psychiatric inpatients?
Observational (n=78)
No
Does 5 times per week right unilateral ECT shorten length of stay without increasing adverse effects compared to 2-3 times per week ECT in psychiatric inpatients?
Daily (5 times per week) right unilateral ECT may shorten the course of treatment without increasing cognitive morbidity compared to standard 2-3 times per week regimens.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May support accelerated right unilateral ECT courses without added cognitive risk; leaves open confirmation in randomized trials.
Objective: The study aimed to test whether there was more rapid response with daily Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT) (5 times per week right unilateral) and shorter lengths of stay (LOS) without an increase in adverse effects compared to ECT administered in a routine fashion of 2-3 times/week. Methods: This is a retrospective chart review study of inpatient ECT cases performed over a two year period in a general psychiatric unit. Different practitioners used 5 times/week right unilateral (RUL) ECT, 2-3 times/week right unilateral ECT, or bilateral (BL) ECT. All inpatient records of patients, who received inpatient ECT in a general hospital with 80 psychiatric adult beds, were reviewed in the two year study period. Due to a variation in the quality of documentation, the analysis used proxy variables for improvement and side effects of ECT: LOS following the first ECT to discharge, total treatments in the series, and switches in treatment parameters that indicating poor response or adverse effects. Results: 78 patients received inpatient ECT. 35 cases were started with RUL ECT in the standard 3 times/week frequency. 32 cases were started with 5 times/week frequency. 11 cases continued BL ECT placement 3 times per week for a repeat ECT series. Diagnosis was not factor in lead placement or frequency of treatment. 90% of patients had major depression, and 10% were treated for bipolar disorder or schizophrenia. The number of treatments in a successful series was roughly equivalent irrespective of starting lead placement. 5 times/week RUL lead placement did not lead to significant morbidity based on switch rates. The findings show a trend supporting the use of 5 times/ week RUL ECT as a means to shorten the course of ECT without increasing cognitive morbidity.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kenneth Sakauye Farzana Badrun (2014) conducted an observational in Major depression, bipolar disorder, or schizophrenia (n=78). 5 times per week right unilateral (RUL) ECT vs. 2-3 times/week right unilateral ECT or bilateral ECT was evaluated on Length of stay following the first ECT to discharge, total treatments in the series, and switches in treatment parameters. Five times per week right unilateral ECT showed a trend supporting its use to shorten the course of treatment without increasing cognitive morbidity compared to standard 3 times per week ECT.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: