This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Moderate to large lower eyelid defects following skin cancer excision or trauma present a challenge for the reconstructive surgeon. A myriad of techniques have been described in the literature; however, the goal remains to replace the missing anatomical layers and restore lower eyelid form and function. For the purpose of reconstruction, the lower eyelid is often divided into anterior and posterior lamellae: the posterior lamella, comprising tarsus and conjunctiva, provides protection to the eye by preventing conjunctival drying, providing a mechanical barrier to trauma and facilitating atraumatic eyelid closure with its lubricated, smooth surface. The anterior lamella, comprising skin and orbicularis oculi, provides an additional barrier and also facilitates eyelid movement. Large defects of the lower eyelid have traditionally been repaired using a range of methods, most notably those of Mustarde, Tenzel and Hughes. Mustarde's technique, reserved for large defects, comprises a large rotational flap from the ipsilateral temple/cheek combined with a chondromucosal graft from nasal septum.1 Tenzel described a semicircular-shaped superolateral myocutaneous flap to repair moderate-sized central defects, with advanced lateral conjunctiva to repair the posterior lamella defects limited to less than half the eyelids horizontal length.2 Hughes described a novel technique of eyelid sharing, whereby a tarsoconjunctival flap was raised at the upper lid mucocutaneous junction on a superiorly based pedicle and advanced inferiorly into the defect together with superiorly advanced cheek tissue. A second procedure, 2–4 weeks later, was described for the free grafting of upper eyelid lashes and a third, some 16 weeks after the original procedure, for the division and inset of the flap.3 By replacing like tissue with like, Hughes technique was a major step forward in lower eyelid reconstruction; however, it was not without significant drawbacks: the necessity for multiple procedures over a protracted time course, during which time the eye was completely occluded, as well as the potential for lower lid ectropion and loss of upper lid form. The Hughes' technique has undergone several key modifications since its description in 1937. One of the most significant modifications has been the development of a one-stage procedure for lower eyelid reconstruction using a free, rather than pedicled, tarsoconjunctival graft. First described by Beyer and Bathrick,4 this technique obviated the need for a second-stage procedure; however, it required vascularized anterior lamella reconstruction to supply the posterior lamella graft. The authors contend that the technique of free tarsoconjunctival graft together with upper eyelid myocutaneous transposition flap best mimics the natural form and function of the lower eyelid.5 It has an advantage over the traditional Hughes' technique of being a one-stage procedure, and makes use of the redundant upper eyelid skin and muscle often found in this patient demographic. The need for a vascularized flap for anterior lamella reconstruction does however increase the potential for scarring, disfigurement and lower lid ectropion. We describe our experience with a one-step technique of lower eyelid reconstruction using a free tarsoconjunctival graft combined with an upper eyelid myocutaneous transposition flap. Figure 1 illustrates our technique for both medial and lateral large lower lid lesions. One-step reconstruction of large lower eyelid defects using a free tarsoconjunctival graft and myocutaneous transposition flap. Preoperative markings for (a) medially based upper lid myocutaneous flap for medial defects and (b) laterally based flap for lateral defects; (c + d) tarsoconjunctival graft harvest with upper eyelid eversion, leaving at least 4 mm of lid margin to preserve upper eyelid form; (e) graft inset into defect to reconstruct posterior lamella; (f) myocutaneous flap inset to reconstruct anterior lamella. Flap donor site closed primarily whilst graft donor site left to heal by secondary intention. The authors reviewed 12 cases of lower eyelid reconstruction performed between 2006 and 2010 at two tertiary referral hospitals in Sydney. Seven medially based and five laterally based myocutaneous flaps were reviewed. Patients had a mean age of 78 and mean length of follow up of 146 days (range 7–510 days). Pathology reported 67% basal cell carcinoma, 25% Bowen's disease and 8% entropion (one case secondary to ocular cicatricial pemphygoid). Clear margins were excised in 91% of cases. The solitary case of incomplete excision was an infiltrative basal cell carcinoma extending into the orbit, necessitating postoperative radiotherapy. Follow up revealed excellent cosmetic results, with no cases of graft failure or flap necrosis. Minor complications included notching (25%) and granuloma formation (25%) in the reconstructed lower eyelid and notching (8%) in the upper eyelid donor site. Of note, cases of notching and granuloma did not affect functional eyelid closure nor did these complications cause any visual disturbance or ocular irritation. Only one patient required minor revisional surgery, whereas all other cases of notching and granuloma resolved spontaneously with conservative management alone. Figures 2 and 3 illustrate preoperative and postoperative appearance of cases for both medial and lateral lower lid reconstruction. Medial lower eyelid reconstruction. (a) Basal cell carcinoma (BCC) right lower eyelid involving lacrimal system. Note preoperative skin markings; (b) tarsoconjunctival graft raised prior to excision; (c) procedure after closure; (d) postop appearance at 12 months. Lateral lower eyelid reconstruction. (a) Basal cell carcinoma (BCC) right lower eyelid involving lateral canthus. Note preoperative skin markings; (b) tarsoconjunctival graft raised and excised at superior border; (c) procedure after closure; (d) postop appearance at 2 months. Hawes et al.6 describe very similar results to our findings, with free tarsoconjunctival graft and myocutaneous flap technique for reconstruction of moderate to large lower eyelid defects shown to be a reliable and effective practice. Their large retrospective review not only supports our conclusions, but demonstrates a much lower complication rate of this technique in comparison with patients having undergone Hughes' pedicled tarsoconjunctival flap reconstruction with full thickness skin graft. We conclude that a one-step procedure of combined free tarsoconjunctival graft with upper eyelid myocutaneous transposition flap is a useful technique for reconstruction of moderate to large lower eyelid defects, with low associated morbidity. It replaces like tissues with like, minimizes scarring to the periorbital region, and thus provides excellent long-term functional and aesthetic results.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Katz et al. (2014) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: