Key result
HHT yields similar EEG spectral indices to FFT but provides better frequency resolution.
Observational (n=34)
No
The Hilbert-Huang transform provides better frequency resolution than FFT for spectral analysis of EEG intrinsic mode functions in healthy humans.
EMD-based IMF spectral analysis offers a data-driven EEG method without arbitrary bands; hypothesis-generating and requires validation before clinical adoption.
Considering the properties of the empirical mode decomposition to extract from a signal its natural oscillatory components known as intrinsic mode functions (IMFs), the spectral analysis of these IMFs could provide a novel alternative for the quantitative EEG analysis without a priori establish more or less arbitrary band limits. This approach has begun to be used in the last years for studies of EEG records of patients included in database repositories or including a low number of individuals or of limited EEG leads, but a detailed study in healthy humans has not yet been reported. Therefore, in this study the aims were to explore and describe the main spectral indices of the IMFs of the EEG in healthy humans using a method based on the FFT and another on the Hilbert-Huang transform (HHT). The EEG of 34 healthy volunteers was recorded and decomposed using a recently developed multivariate empirical mode decomposition algorithm. Extracted IMFs were submitted to spectral analysis with, and the results were compared with an ANOVA test. The first six decomposed IMFs from the EEG showed frequency values in the range of the classical bands of the EEG (1.5 to 56 Hz). Both methods showed in general similar results for mean weighted frequencies and estimations of power spectral density, although the HHT is recommended because of its better frequency resolution. It was shown the presence of the mode-mixing problem producing a slight overlapping of spectral frequencies mainly between the IMF3 and IMF4 modes.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Arrufat‐Pié et al. (2020) conducted an observational in Healthy (n=34). Hilbert-Huang transform (HHT) vs. Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) was evaluated on Mean weighted frequencies and power spectral density of IMFs. Both FFT and HHT methods showed generally similar results for mean weighted frequencies and power spectral density of EEG intrinsic mode functions, although HHT provided better frequency resolution.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: