Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
To the Editor Krause et al. (1) have reported the effects on cochlear function of acoustic stimuli used in eliciting cervical vestibular evoked myogenic potentials (cVEMPs). They reported some subjective complaints of muffling of hearing, no significant change in pure-tone audiometry, but some reduction in distortion product otoacoustic emissions in the high-frequency range when measured 5 minutes after the cVEMP. Although the abnormal features settled the following day and were not considered to represent clinically relevant temporary hearing loss, the authors felt that patients need to be informed about the risk of adverse effects on hearing. The safety of diagnostic tests is an important consideration, although it is also recognized that some investigations do entail some risk to patients (e.g., ionizing radiation with conventional radiology). Any test that is to be used in large numbers of patients or in healthy volunteers should be as safe as possible. The cVEMP has become a popular additional investigation of inner ear function and can provide clinically relevant information in diseases such as superior canal dehiscence (SCD), otosclerosis, Méneière’s disease, vestibular neuritis, and other conditions (2). The intensities of sound required to evoke the cVEMP are high (3), and correctly calibrated stimuli and audiometric equipment are essential. The technique has been widely used and very few side effects have been reported to date, although caution is suggested with patients with tinnitus. Although technically tone bursts are impulse noise, they are not typical of naturally occurring impulse noise and are probably better regarded simply as an interrupted sinusoidal waveform. Hearing damage is generally thought to relate to the peak intensity of sound pressure (blast-type injuries) or the total sound energy delivered to the ear (4). Industrial legislation in many countries reflects these concerns by specifying both the maximum sound pressure level (SPL) and the total sound energy exposure measured during a specified period (e.g., 8 h), with more intense sound requiring a reduction in the duration of exposure. For example, the European Union (2003) and U.K. (2005) guidelines for occupational exposure specify an upper limit of 200 Pa (140 dB peak SPL, C weighted) and an exposure equivalent to 87 dB LAeq,8h. Although these guidelines are not intended to cover medical contexts, it is prudent to consider the recommended levels and the reason behind them when selecting VEMP stimuli. Commercial VEMP systems usually allow users to choose between clicks and tone bursts and generally specify stimulus intensity in decibel SPL or normal hearing level (nHL). However, these intensities do not reflect the total sound energy in a stimulus because the duration is not taken into account. Longer stimuli contain proportionately greater sound energy. The options for stimulus duration and shape are often limited in commercial systems, and sine waves sometimes require a minimum number of rise/fall or plateau cycles. Tone bursts of up to about 6 ms in duration are therefore quite common in the VEMP literature. LAeq is a measure of equivalent “A”-weighted sound intensity over the measurement period, the usual reference being 1 second and thus gives a measure of energy delivered to the ear over the period specified. A-weighting is commonly used, possibly because this is similar to the attenuation of the middle ear (5). Total energy exposure is the product of sound intensity and time exposure and is also measured in decibels, where the reference energy (0 dB) is a pressure of 20 μPa applied for 1 second. An 87-dB LAeq stimulus given over 8 hours represents 132 dB of energy delivered to the ear, compared to this reference. Rosengren et al. (6) investigated the effects of different acoustic waveforms and energies on the VEMP and concluded that waveform energy was an important determinant of cVEMP amplitude. They calculated that, to stay within the required “upper exposure action values” (of 85 dB LAeq,8h, slightly less than the absolute upper limit of 87 dB), a 105-dB LAeq,1s stimulus could be presented at a rate of 5/s for a total of almost 5 minutes to each ear. For stimuli given at 5/s, a 105-dB LAeq,1s stimulus consisting of 0.1-ms duration click would be expected to have an intensity of 138 dB peak SPL; and for a 2-ms 500 Hz tone burst, an intensity of 131 dB peak SPL (see Appendix). Krause et al. (1) used a 500-Hz, 133-dB SPL stimulus to evoke cVEMPs, but the duration (10 ms) was longer than commonly used. The sound energy delivered by this stimulus (200 repetitions of a 500-Hz, 10-ms tone burst at 133 dB SPL at 5/s, assuming their intensity is measured as root mean square [RMS]) is equivalent to 133 dB. If all 200 stimuli are delivered, the energy slightly exceeds the maximum LAeq exposure specified by the EU limits (by 1 dB). The results of Krause et al. show that stimulating near the recommended limit in their sample of young subjects with normal hearing did not have any serious effects. But at this intensity/duration, there is little scope for safely increasing the number of stimuli given, which is needed when the reflex waveform is small or unclear, as often occurs in older subjects. Longer stimuli increase the amount of sound energy delivered to the ear but do not necessarily yield larger or clearer reflexes. Welgampola and Colebatch (7) showed that VEMPs increased in amplitude with the duration of the 1-kHz stimulus to 7 ms and then decreased with longer stimuli. Corresponding results were reported by Cheng and Murofushi (8) and Lim et al. (9), who found a similar pattern for the 500-Hz tone bursts, with a maximum amplitude for a 6-ms stimulus, while a 10-ms stimulus had an average amplitude between that for a 2-ms and a 4-ms stimulus. A shorter stimulus given at the same peak intensity can be delivered for more repetitions without sacrificing the quality of the recording. For example, the 105-dB LAeq,1s stimulus used by Rosengren et al. (6) (namely 500 Hz, 2 ms) can be delivered 1,440 times at 5/s for a total of 130 dB of energy delivery, a total large enough to allow for additional repeated recordings when necessary. While long stimuli such as a 10-ms stimulus can be useful (e.g., in experimental contexts to provide sufficient duration for comparing different stimulus frequencies in tuning studies), they are uncommon in clinical settings. We recommend that in both clinical and experimental situations consideration be given to the total sound exposure when designing VEMP stimuli. The findings of Krause et al. (1) are interesting as they show that, even if sound exposure is greater than that typically used or required, there is no evidence of any permanent deleterious effects on cochlear function. Given that VEMP stimuli used in clinical settings are typically shorter, and provided that peak intensity limits are also not exceeded, VEMPs recorded for diagnostic purposes are unlikely to cause damage to the cochlea. James G. Colebatch, M.B., B.S., D.Sc Prince of Wales Hospital Clinical School and Neuroscience Research Australia, University of New South Wales Sydney, Australia Sally M. Rosengren, Ph.D.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Colebatch et al. (2014) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: