Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The move in the United States to use competency tests for grade-to-grade promotion decisions is likely to have far-reaching effects thoughout the school system. The United States can benefit from the experience of other nations that have used similar tests as an administrative mechanism. We examine some of the negative outcomes of the mandatory external primary school-leaving certificate examination--officially entitled the Examination for Primary School Certificate--that was administered to all sixth-grade pupils in Ireland between 1943 and 1967. The similarity between the process of initiating the primary certificate examination and the present minimum competency test movement is highlighted. Attention is focused on the primary certificate examination itself, its content, its level of reading difficulty and passing standards, and its effects on instructional emphasis and on grade-to-grade promotion practices. The formal resistance of the teachers to the examination is described. The article shows that sixth-grade teachers tended to emphasize subject areas covered by the examination to the detriment of other subjects. The content of previous examinations came to define the curriculum. Teachers tended to adopt a policy of not promoting weaker pupils in order to control the potential failure rate on the examination. The authors conclude that the Irish experience should at the very least offer warning signals to American educators of the possible dangers inherent in the use of minimum competency tests as the sole or primary determinant of decisions concerning grade-to-grade promotion.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Madaus et al. (1985) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: