Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Seismic retrofitting of existing buildings is inherently a multi-objective optimisation problem, as policy directives, community expectations, and stakeholder priorities define multiple, often competing objectives related to economy, resilience, sustainability, and seismic performance outcomes. Nevertheless, conventional seismic retrofit design optimisation approaches usually rely on cost-driven or aggregated formulations that conceal trade-offs and limit exploration of the design space. This study examines the influence of objective selection on multi-objective optimisation outcomes for seismic retrofit design. A recently developed optimisation framework, incorporating a stochastic iterative retrofitting algorithm (SIRA) for generating initial population sets, is applied to a reinforced concrete building with unreinforced masonry infills, representative of buildings constructed prior to the adoption of modern seismic design codes. Six objectives are considered, including installation cost and environmental impact as investment-oriented criteria, and expected annual losses, expected annual environmental impact, expected annual downtime, and the ratio of non-structural to total economic losses as performance-oriented criteria. Four objective subsets are investigated, ranging from cost-only and cost–economic losses to more comprehensive multi-objective sets reflecting different engineering and decision-making practices. The results demonstrate that objective selection strongly influences the structure, extent, and interpretability of the resulting Pareto fronts. While cost-only formulations converge toward narrow regions of the solution space, multi-objective formulations reveal broader and more informative trade-off patterns and support more robust optimisation behaviour. Overall, the findings underscore the importance of explicit and transparent objective selection in multi-objective seismic retrofit optimisation, enabling more informed retrofit design under competing economic, resilience, and sustainability considerations.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Yükselen et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: