Key result
Surgery for pericardial syndromes shows no same-admission recurrences but ~24% mortality, driven by malignant effusions.
Why the study?
The 2015 European Society of Cardiology guidelines highlighted the surgical management of pericardial disease as an unmet need with questionable aspects requiring clarification.
What are the clinical outcomes and mortality rates associated with surgical management of pericardial syndromes in adults and children?
Observational (n=45)
No
What are the clinical outcomes and mortality rates associated with surgical management of pericardial syndromes in adults and children?
Surgical management of pericardial syndromes is effective with no same-admission recurrences, though mortality remains significant and is largely driven by underlying malignant etiologies.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Should not yet change practice for surgical management of pericardial syndromes; leaves open the need.
Background: The knowledge on pericardial disease has increased but the European Society of Cardiology in the last guidelines 2015 stated a section of perspective and unmet needs referring to the surgical management as one of these needs. Here, we present an institutional experience to contribute with other studies in explanation of questionable aspects about their surgical management. Methods: Among 127 cases (93 adults and 34 children) that were diagnosed as pericardial syndrome, we retrospectively analyzed 45 cases (40 adults and 5 children) operated for pericardial syndrome from May 2012 to June 2019. Echocardiogram was the main preoperative diagnostic tool. Surgical approach was selected according to each diagnosis. Postoperative clinical assessment, recurrence and mortality rate were the main determinants of outcome. Results: Regarding pericardial effusions, the mean preoperative medical treatment period was 17.7 ± 21.9 days and pericardial window through thoracotomy was the common approach (54.5%). In constrictive pericarditis, infection was the main etiology (40%), mean preoperative medical treatment period was 16 ± 8.8 days and complete pericardiectomy was the surgical procedure for most cases. Trans-sternal drainage was the standard approach for cardiac tamponade. No postoperative same admission recurrences were reported and 11 (24.4%) mortalities were recorded, 7 (15.5%) cases of them were diagnosed as malignant effusions. Conclusion: Decision making and surgical approach affect the outcome of surgery for pericardial syndromes. Children are more responsive to medical treatment than adults are. Primary etiology and patient’s condition are still the leading determinants of morbidity and mortality.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Elassal et al. (2020) conducted an observational in Pericardial syndrome (n=45). Surgical management was evaluated on Postoperative clinical assessment, recurrence and mortality rate. Surgical management of pericardial syndromes in 45 patients resulted in no same-admission recurrences and an overall mortality rate of 24.4%, with 7 of the 11 deaths due to malignant effusions.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: