Key result
Return-to-play literature restricts focus to medical factors with only ~9% addressing the decision-making process.
Systematic Review (n=148)
There is a lack of specific literature focusing on the comprehensive return-to-play decision-making process, highlighting a need for further research on the team physician's role.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Return-to-play decisions lack evidence-based non-medical frameworks; extends research on team physician decision processes.
OBJECTIVE: Return-to-play (RTP) decisions are a central component of the Team Physician's clinical work, yet there is little more than anecdotal reference to these in the literature. We recently published a 3-step model for return-to-play medical decision making and, in the current paper, undertook a systematic review of the literature to determine the level of evidence in support of this model. DATA SOURCES: PubMed, Web of Science, and CINAHL electronic databases. Any article specifically related to concussion, head injuries, neck injuries, illness, medical conditions (including cardiovascular and renal), and preparticipation in sport or that reported RTP as a clinical outcome was excluded. Any article that contained a discussion on one of the components of the 3-step decision-based RTP model was included. RESULTS: We reviewed 148 articles that met the criteria for inclusion and found 98 review articles, 39 original articles, 6 case reports, and 5 editorials. Of these, 141 articles mentioned Step 1 of the medical decision-making process for RTP (Medical Factors), 26 mentioned Step 2 (Sport Risk Modifiers), and 20 mentioned Step 3 (Decision Modifiers). Of the 148 articles in total, only 13 focused on RTP as the main subject and the remaining 135 mentioned RTP anecdotally. Of these 13 articles, 5 were reviews, 4 were editorials, and 4 were original research. CONCLUSIONS: Although 148 articles we retrieved mention RTP in relation to a specific injury, medical condition, or specific topic, only 13 articles focused specifically on the RTP decision-making process, and 6 of 13 were restricted to Step 1 of the 3-step model (Medical Factors). Return-to-play is a fertile field for research and thought leadership beginning with a focus on the Team Physician's appropriate role in RTP decision making, particularly considering the factors identified in Step 3 (Decision Modification).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Matheson et al. (2010) conducted a systematic review in Return-to-play decisions (n=148). 3-step model for return-to-play medical decision making was evaluated on Level of evidence in support of the 3-step model. A systematic review of 148 articles on return-to-play found that only 13 focused specifically on the decision-making process, with most literature restricted to medical factors.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: