Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Emergy synthesis-based sustainability assessment of greenhouse agricultural systems carries substantial parametric uncertainty arising from unit emergy values (UEVs), resource-flow estimations, and modelling assumptions. This study presents a horticultural uncertainty quantification framework built on true input-level Monte Carlo propagation. Rather than perturbing model outputs, the framework samples 14 raw resource flows, 14 UEVs, and the energy yield — 29 uncertain quantities in total — from log-normal priors, then recomputes Equations (1)–(6) for every draw. Validation spans 60 greenhouse cases covering four crops (tomato, cucumber, pepper, strawberry) across three seasons and five technology archetypes ranging from low-tech tunnel to industrial systems, with 10,000 Monte Carlo draws per case. A Saltelli-design Sobol decomposition (∼127,000 model evaluations) identifies dominant input drivers; the law of total variance separates within-case aleatoric from between-case epistemic contributions. Three principal findings emerge. First, the labour UEV is the dominant first-order driver of every indicator (first-order Sobol index 0.32–1.00, and ≥ 0.49 for five of six), identifying it as the binding data-quality constraint; for the emergy yield ratio the groundwater UEV is comparable (S₁ = 0.26). Second, the Environmental Sustainability Index proves the most reliable composite indicator (R² = 0.84, PICP = 100%, composite reliability 80.5/100), while the Emergy Yield Ratio remains poorly identifiable under realistic input uncertainty (R² = 0.07, PICP = 50%). Third, Spearman correlations between indicators are large and non-zero (|ρ| = 0.53–1.00), reflecting the mathematical coupling introduced by shared R, N, and F emergy flows; the identity EYR = 1/EIR + 1 is preserved sample-by-sample. Robustness is confirmed under truncated-Normal, symmetric-Triangular, and ±50% uniform CV scaling.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
mirshekari et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: