Key result
Second opinions for coronary angiography defer the procedure in ~80% of cases with low cardiac mortality.
Why the study?
Does a second opinion program safely reduce unnecessary coronary angiography in patients with coronary artery disease?
Observational (n=171)
No
Does a second opinion program safely reduce unnecessary coronary angiography in patients with coronary artery disease?
A second opinion can safely defer coronary angiography in a large proportion of medically stable patients with coronary artery disease.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Second-opinion deferral of angiography was associated with low mortality in stable CAD; hypothesis-generating and requires prospective validation before practice change.
OBJECTIVE: To assess the feasibility of carrying out a second-opinion trial for patients urged to undergo coronary angiography and to assess the long-range outcome of such patients denied that procedure, and the criteria evolved for reaching such a conclusion. DESIGN: A case series of patients referred for a second opinion as to the need for coronary angiography. Patients were followed up by questionnaire, telephone call, and center visits. SETTING: Cardiovascular referral center and teaching hospital in Boston, Mass. PATIENTS: One hundred seventy-one patients with coronary artery disease (144 men, average age 60 years; range, 36 to 88 years). Three patients became unavailable for follow-up during a mean of 46.5 months. OUTCOME MEASURES: Concordant-discordant outcome as to the second opinion, cardiac events, invasive interventions, quality of life questionnaire, and level of symptoms. RESULTS: One hundred thirty-four (80%) of the 168 patients were judged not to require angiography; it was recommended in six. In 28 (16%) recommendation was deferred pending further studies. At a mean follow-up of 46.5 months among the 168 patients, there were seven cardiac deaths (annualized cardiac mortality of 1.1%); 19 patients experienced a new myocardial infarction (2.7% annualized rate), while 27 patients (4.3%) were judged to have developed unstable angina. Twenty-six patients (15.4%) ultimately underwent either coronary bypass or angioplasty. CONCLUSIONS: In a large fraction of medically stable patients with coronary disease who are urged to undergo coronary angiography, the procedure can be safely deferred. While there may be a limitation in terms of generalizing this experience to all patients with coronary disease, we reasonably conclude that an estimated 50% of coronary angiography currently being undertaken in the United States is unnecessary, or at least could be postponed.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Thomas B. Graboys (1992) conducted an observational in Coronary artery disease (n=171). Second opinion for coronary angiography was evaluated on Concordant-discordant outcome as to the second opinion, cardiac events, invasive interventions, quality of life questionnaire, and level of symptoms. A second opinion for coronary angiography resulted in deferral of the procedure in 80% of patients, with an annualized cardiac mortality of 1.1% over a mean follow-up of 46.5 months.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: