Key result
Frequent home nocturnal hemodialysis saves ~$6,700 and improves quality-adjusted life years versus conventional hemodialysis.
Why the study?
The cost-effectiveness of frequent home nocturnal hemodialysis compared with conventional hemodialysis was unknown.
Does frequent home nocturnal hemodialysis improve cost-effectiveness compared to conventional hemodialysis in patients requiring dialysis?
Does frequent home nocturnal hemodialysis improve cost-effectiveness compared to conventional hemodialysis in patients requiring dialysis?
Frequent home nocturnal hemodialysis is economically attractive compared with in-center conventional hemodialysis, though its cost-effectiveness is sensitive to technique failure rates and training times.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Supports cost-effectiveness of frequent home nocturnal hemodialysis; leaves open real-world applicability given sensitivity to failure rates and training.
Provider and patient enthusiasm for frequent home nocturnal hemodialysis (FHNHD) has been renewed; however, the cost-effectiveness of this technique is unknown. We performed a cost-utility analysis of FHNHD compared with conventional hemodialysis (CvHD; 4 hours three times per week) from a health payer perspective over a lifetime horizon using patient information from the Alberta NHD randomized controlled trial. Costs, including training costs, were obtained using microcosting and administrative data (CAN$2012). We determined the incremental cost per quality-adjusted life year (QALY) gained. Robustness was assessed using scenario, sensitivity, and probabilistic sensitivity analyses. Compared with CvHD (61% in-center, 14% satellite, and 25% home dialysis), FHNHD led to incremental cost savings (-$6700) and an additional 0.38 QALYs. In sensitivity analyses, when the annual probability of technique failure with FHNHD increased from 7.6% (reference case) to ≥19%, FHNHD became unattractive (>$75,000/QALY). The cost/QALY gained became $13,000 if average training time for FHNHD increased from 3.7 to 6 weeks. In scenarios with alternate comparator modalities, FHNHD remained dominant compared with in-center CvHD; cost/QALYs gained were $18,500, $198,000, and $423,000 compared with satellite CvHD, home CvHD, and peritoneal dialysis, respectively. In summary, FHNHD is attractive compared with in-center CvHD in this cohort. However, the attractiveness of FHNHD varies by technique failure rate, training time, and dialysis modalities from which patients are drawn, and these variables should be considered when establishing FHNHD programs.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Klarenbach et al. (2013) studied Hemodialysis. Frequent home nocturnal hemodialysis (FHNHD) vs. Conventional hemodialysis (CvHD; 4 hours three times per week) was evaluated on Incremental cost per quality-adjusted life year (QALY) gained (savings of $6700 and 0.38 additional QALYs). Compared with conventional hemodialysis, frequent home nocturnal hemodialysis led to incremental cost savings of $6,700 and an additional 0.38 quality-adjusted life years.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: