Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The impact of the DCFR on third party rights under shipping documents -a UK perspective on the potential for harmonisation* IntroductionCould the Draft Common Frame of Reference (DCFR) 1 change shipping law?Although only soft law at present, what would be the impact of implementing its rules on third party rights under transport documents in the laws of EU Member States?Would this result in a true change in UK shipping law regarding third party rights?After setting out the UK framework, this article will discuss the DCFR rules and compare and contrast them with the current provisions in the UK.As will be shown, the situation in the UK is far from straightforward.Analysing the impact of the DCFR rules against this framework, it will be argued that implementation of the DCFR third party rules throughout, including the whole of shipping and transport law, would have potential for welcome simplification.It is generally accepted that a bill of lading in the appropriate form is able to function as a document of title and that the holder of the bill of lading can claim delivery of the goods enshrined therein from the carrier. 2 How the third party obtains this right to delivery has been explained in different ways by different legal systems.Many theories seem to point to a contractual solution, even if there are also some approaches which are non-contractual, mainly the statutory solution in the UK or views that the holder's position should be categorised as sui generis. 3 Continental Europe seems to generally favour the contractual approach and see the contract of carriage as a contract for the benefit of a third party or as a three-party contract. 4 This seems to be confirmed by the stipulations in favour of the third party consignee in transport conventions which were heavily influenced by continental thinking, 5 such as the CMR, 6 COTIF-CIM 7 and the CMNI, 8
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Simone Lamont-Black (2015) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 9 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: