Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This article introduces a series of reviews covering The Thymus, Lymph nodes, and Lymphatics appearing in Volume 271 of Immunological Reviews. All organisms, from prokaryotes to plants and animals, benefit from immune defense to protect their genetic and/or physical integrity. Even bacteria have evolved adaptive immunity 1, and consequently have been shown to suffer from (albeit rare) autoimmunity 2, highlighting universal principles of immune defense mechanisms that are based on self/non-self discrimination 3. However, the individual mechanistic details of immunity vary widely according to species. During the course of animal evolution, the emergence of general hematopoietic tissues, that are the source of immune-related cell types (for instance macrophages) or their progenitors 4, precedes that of specialized immune-related tissues. Nonetheless, although the precise origin and homology of immune-related cell types and tissues are not always easy to determine, it appears that the overall complexity of immune facilities has increased as evolution has progressed, major innovations occurring with the emergence of vertebrates. All vertebrates possess lymphocytes sensu strictu, as defined by clonal expression of antigen receptors and proliferative response after antigen stimulation, albeit the structure and mode of diversification of antigen receptors differ in the two sister branches, the jawless fishes and the jawed vertebrates 5. For instance, the thymus, an organ primarily dedicated to the development and maturation of T lymphocytes 6, emerged with the vertebrate body plan about 500 million years ago 7. Thymopoietic tissues may have first evolved as a collection of small, anatomically segregated units – as illustrated by the thymus-like structures in the gill basket of jawless fishes – before the individual modules merged into a macroscopically identifiable thymus tissue 8. A similar evolutionary scenario may apply to the emergence of organized secondary lymphoid organs, which are first clearly recognizable in birds 9. However, it is possible that scattered tissue aggregates identified in bony fishes 10 represent a primordial version of germinal centers, which serve as the minimal developmental and functional unit of secondary lymphoid tissues. Thus, in concert, many such small functional units could provide the morphological basis for affinity maturation of antibodies that is already present in such evolutionarily ancient vertebrates as cartilaginous fishes 11. It is conceivable that major anatomical transitions of primary and secondary lymphoid tissues were accompanied by a significant reorganization of intercellular communication in the immune system. This likely applied to interactions within an organ, i.e. between stromal and lymphoid cells, and also to interactions between organs. One consequence of these changes could be the emergence and/or remodeling of lymphatic vasculature 12. This unique conduit not only serves as a dedicated communication route for immune effector cells, but is now recognized as an active player in immune modulation. The reviews in this volume of Immunological Reviews provide a highly topical discussion of our understanding of the structure and function of the thymus, lymphoid organs, and the lymphatics (Fig. 1). The opening chapters of this volume discuss various aspects of thymus function. Ohigashi et al. 13 and Lucas et al. 14 set the stage and discuss the development and function of the cortical and medullary compartments of the thymus, respectively. Ohigashi et al. 13 describe how the cortical epithelium supplies essential environmental cues that coax uncommitted progenitor cells into entering the pathway of T-cell development and how the thymic cortex orchestrates the complex process of positive selection of developing T cells. Finally, they discuss the surprising finding that all thymic epithelial cells appear to pass through a developmental stage that is characterized by the transient expression of molecular markers that later distinguish the cortical epithelial cell type from its medullary counterpart. These results raise many interesting and provocative questions relevant to our understanding of the phylogeny and ontogeny of the thymic stroma. For instance, is there a linear relationship between cortical and medullary epithelial cell types, or is the outcome of lineage-tracing experiments merely indicative of an early and transient expression of cortical markers before the two main epithelial lineages diverge? In the following chapter, Lucas et al. 14 point out an important functional distinction between the cortical and medullary epithelium. Whereas the former appears to develop in a more or less cell-autonomous fashion, the maturation of the latter crucially depends on multiple reciprocal interactions with different types of lymphoid cells. It is interesting to note that these interactions occur via members of the rapidly evolving TNF superfamily of receptors and ligands (many of which also play an important role in the generation of secondary lymphoid organs). By contrast, the crucial environmental factors (at least those that regulate the early steps of T-cell development) are evolutionarily ancient members of signaling pathways, the chemokine CXCL1, and the Notch ligand DLL4 15. Although at present little is known about the regeneration of the cortical epithelium, accumulating evidence indicates the presence of medullary precursor cells capable of sustaining the medullary compartment. Hamazaki et al. 16 summarize recent in vitro and in vivo studies aimed at characterizing the number, half-life and functional activities of medullary precursor cells which were originally identified in chimeric mice 17. Their discussion highlights an interesting conundrum: if medullary epithelial precursor cells are indeed capable of supporting medullary function for the entire lifetime of an animal, why then does thymic involution occur? Could it be that thymic involution is not a detriment (as is generally believed) but rather a programmed process with as yet unknown physiological benefits for the host? While the answer to these and other questions is relevant for a better understanding of the homeostasis of the thymus, Chaudhry et al. 18 remind us of the clinically more urgent problem of failing thymopoiesis after acute and chronic injury, for instance after chemotherapy for malignant disorders. It is interesting to note from their discussion that regeneration depends (at least in part) on factors produced by both stromal cells (such as FGF7, also known as KGF) and hematopoietic cells (for instance IL-22 and IL-23). While these discoveries have paved the way for innovative clinical trials, they also aptly illustrate the intricate cellular interactions (an instructive example of the long-recognized lymphoepithelial cross-talk) occurring in the generation, maintenance, and regeneration of thymopoietic tissues. The reviews by Rothenberg et al. 19 and Taniuchi 20 address the molecular mechanisms by which lymphoid progenitors reach a successful outcome of crucial lineage decisions. Rothenberg et al. 19 take a broad view on the question and discuss how hematopoietic differentiation in general and T-cell specification in particular can be conceived as resulting from the activities of several interconnected gene networks, all operating according to the universal architectural designs of animal developmental pathways. This evolutionary approach breathes new life into studies aimed at understanding lymphoid differentiation in mammals and in doing so succeeds in revealing the unique aspects of T-cell development. However, we must not be surprised if these seemingly unique aspects of T-cell differentiation will be ‘re-discovered’ during studies of other cell fate choice mechanisms and, with hindsight, be described as paradigmatic. Taniuchi 20 examines the precise molecular details underlying the dichotomy of CD4 and CD8 T-cell lineages. This discussion highlights how physiological and molecular biological approaches converged to solve the problem of how a common progenitor pool diverges into functionally distinct and essentially non-overlapping ‘helper’ and ‘cytotoxic’ cell types. It is rewarding to observe that this lineage decision was an early example of how epigenetic mechanisms function in mammalian cellular differentiation. Future studies examining the evolutionary trajectory of the structure and composition of the genetic network underlying this lineage decision are anticipated to provide further details on the molecular intricacies of this process. Given the recent discovery of functionally related ‘adaptive’ and ‘innate’ lymphocyte subsets, such studies may serve as a paradigm which could also lead to a better understanding of emerging complexities of further lymphoid lineages. It is apparent from the above discussion that cellular differentiation in the thymus crucially depends on complex interactions between stromal and hematopoietic components. Recent advances in imaging technology have provided an opportunity to observe these interactions in the thymus in real-time. The difficulties associated with direct in vivo imaging of the thymus were overcome by Kurd and Robey 21 by the use of acute tissue slices. Although many of the conclusions drawn from the analysis of static observations were confirmed, these studies revealed a number of unexpected characteristics of intra-thymic trafficking. Kurd and Robey 21 discuss how these findings further our understanding of how developing T cells interact with stromal cells, for the first time ascribing reproducible physical parameters to the spatial characteristics and dynamics of interactions during positive and negative selection processes in the cortex and medulla of the thymus. This discussion sets the stage for appreciating mechanistic aspects of self-antigen exposure to thymocytes that underlie the formation of a self-tolerant repertoire of mature T cells. Abramson and Husebye 22 focus on the role of Aire, a fascinating transcriptional modulator, which, at least in part, regulates the expression of self-antigens in a subset of medullary epithelial cells during the process of central tolerance formation. Initially recognized as a gene mutated in an autoimmune disorder in human patients, it has now been found that Aire is also implicated in regulating peripheral tolerance. Additional aspects pertaining to the functional complexities of immune regulation are discussed by Perry and Hsieh 23. They indicate how the representation of the peripheral self in the thymus is not only required for clonal deletion (the paradigmatic recessive tolerance mechanism) but also for the development of regulatory T cells, a dominantly acting facility of immune regulation, serving to suppress unwanted damage inflicted by self-reactive effector T cells. In the two following reviews, Passaro et al. 24 and Peaudecerf et al. 25 address the problem of T-cell leukemias originating in the thymus. In order to put the biology of leukemia formation into perspective, Passaro et al. 24 first discuss the molecular features of the bone marrow niches for hematopoietic progenitors and T-cell precursors in particular. Then they explain how the transformed state of leukemic cells allows them to combine the stimuli provided by environmental cues with an altered cellular responsiveness to effectively outcompete their normal counterparts in different environmental niches. Peaudecerf et al. 25 specifically focus on the role of the IL-7 signaling pathway in the thymus and review studies indicating that loss of responsiveness to this cytokine leads to a previously unappreciated capacity of thymocytes for self-renewal. It appears that, owing to the constant influx of new progenitor cells into the thymus and the ensuing competition between ‘old’ and ‘young’ inhabitants of thymic niches, this self-renewal capacity is physiologically irrelevant. However, it may become crucial in situations of insufficient progenitor supply from the bone marrow, for example after myeloablative therapy. Peaudecerf et al. 25 critically examine the findings that have led to the hypothesis that, owing to lack of cellular competition, such unopposed self-renewal paves the way to leukemic transformation of T-cell progenitors. The second part of this volume deals with the development and function of peripheral lymphoid organs. Bar-Ephraïm and Mebius 26 discuss how the so-called lymphoid tissue inducer (LTi) cells participate in the formation, maintenance, and regeneration of some (but not all) types of secondary lymphoid tissue. They recount the fact that LTi cells are recognized as a paradigmatic representative of a steadily growing number of different types of innate lymphoid cells. They go on to explore the developmental and homeostatic roles of the different types of innate lymphoid cells in secondary lymphoid tissues, before summarizing recent work that indicates the surprisingly important role of these ‘innate’ cells in directly shaping adaptive immune responses. These latter findings remind us of the emerging notion that the functional distinction between innate and adaptive immunity was perhaps more academic than real. Gasteiger et al. 27 focus on the functional dynamics of cellular interactions in lymph nodes. They have subscribed to the ‘seeing is believing’ paradigm and discuss recent advances using in vivo imaging techniques which provide a fresh view on how the immune cell network facilitates the uptake and presentation of antigen, and the subsequent activation of effector cells. The ability to analyze immune reactions in a space- and time-resolved manner not only complements similar work on the development of immune cells in the thymus (see Kurd and Robey 21 in this volume), but has opened up an entirely new chapter in immunological research. It is now appears feasible to be able to rapidly examine the mechanism and outcome of therapeutic manipulations of desired and undesired immune reactivity. Acton and Reis e Sousa's 28 review adds yet another dimension to the discussion by examining the anatomical changes occurring in the lymph node upon immune activation. They highlight recent findings whereby dendritic cells (another innate cell type) directly modulate the structure of the vasculature and the fibroblastic reticular network in the lymph node; without such remodeling, adaptive immune responses are severely impaired. These results indicate how a seemingly immobile stromal ‘infrastructure’ itself is malleable in the process of initiating and terminating an immune response. These observations have far-reaching implications with respect to a holistic understanding of the mechanics of an immune response, also prompting us to reevaluate previous interpretations of this vital process. Reboldi and Cyster 29 review our current understanding of Peyer's patches (PP), a unique lymphoid structure in the gut. In contrast to other secondary lymphoid organs, these tissue aggregates receive a constant supply of an extremely complex mixture of antigens which are derived from food and the resident intestinal microbiota. This is achieved through their proximity to a specialized type of intestinal epithelial cells. As a result, PPs orchestrate the production of secretory immunoglobulins and hence decisively contribute to the unique structure and function of the mucosal immune system. These observations not only have relevance for our understanding of host–microbiota interactions (particularly when dysbiosis causes undesired immune pathology) but are also relevant for our understanding of the origins of adaptive immunity in general. According to one hypothesis, the mucosal immune system evolved to expand the metabolic capacity of vertebrates through microbial facilities and hence required flexible and efficient management of microbiome structure and composition. Adding new aspects to the discussion of functional characteristics of secondary lymphoid tissue, Sage and Sharpe 30 focus on the germinal center reaction. They review recent evidence indicating that the previous view of the germinal center as merely the formation site of uniquely specific antibodies might be too simplistic, as we learn about the exciting discovery of T follicular regulatory (Tfr) cells. It appears that the process of affinity maturation is actually regulated and not just a preprogrammed differentiation process of activated B cells. While necessitating a reappraisal of previous interpretations of the mechanism of antibody formation, these new findings also point the way to developing novel means of manipulating antibody responses, i.e. boosting desired vaccine responses and blunting autoantibody reactions. Following on the discussions on secondary lymphoid tissues, Dieu-Nosjean et al. 31 concentrate on a variation on the theme, namely the formation and function of tertiary lymphoid tissues (TLS). These structures are of great interest for many reasons. First, they offer an unprecedented opportunity to examine the mechanism(s) by which such tissues can emerge de novo in the adult organism. Second, because TLS usually develop at unusual sites, they provide a unique window into the morphological and functional consequences of immune reactions. Dieu-Nosjean et al. 31 focus on the role of TLS in regulating the immune response to tumors, highlighting not only the developmental requirements for the induction of these inducible versions of lymphoid organs but also considering the possible prognostic value of examining their cellular composition and structure in cancer patients. The volume concludes with a discussion of recent advances in the understanding of the ontogeny and function of lymphatic vessels. Betterman and Harvey 32 illustrate that what once appeared to be a mere conduit for immune cells is now appreciated as an integral part of the immune system. Previously considered to be a passive conduit only, the lymphatic system is shown to be capable of modulating the quality and quantity of immune responses. It does so predominantly by regulating the traffic of naïve and activated effector cells, which, considering the requirement for a spatially (and often also temporally) resolved mechanism(s), has important implications for our understanding of a wide variety of human pathologies, including chronic inflammatory disorders. Our understanding of the development and function of lymphoid tissues has increased dramatically over the past few years. Yet, further advances are needed to arrive at an even more detailed view of immune system function. It is hoped that the collection of reviews in this volume points the reader toward exciting future research directions, in particular with respect to a revitalization of comparative analyses using different animal models and the further development of spatially and temporally resolved recording facilities. The combination of such approaches will provide the necessary information for the development of new strategies for manipulating the function of the immune system, to minimize the impact of infectious disease and autoimmune disorders, and to harness the power of immunity to fight malignant disease. Work in the author's laboratory is supported by the Max Planck Society, the European Research Council and the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft.The author has no conflict of interest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Thomas Boehm (2016) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: