This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Editor, In an observational study comparing simultaneous direct and video laryngoscopic views in the same patients in an out-of-hospital setting, Hossfeld et al.1 showed that the use of the C-MAC videolaryngoscope was associated with improved visualisation of the glottis and an excellent success rate of tracheal intubation. Accordingly, they suggest the use of the C-MAC videolaryngoscope as a first-line device for out-of-hospital emergency tracheal intubation. In our view, however, there are several aspects of this study that need to be clarified before adoption of the C-MAC videolaryngoscope into routine practice. First, the Cormack and Lehane grades of the video and direct laryngoscopic views obtained by the C-MAC device were used as the primary endpoints. Furthermore, the direct laryngoscopic view in 120 patients (53.8%) was Cormack and Lehane grade II to IV. When quoting the direct laryngoscopic view, however, we are interested to know whether external laryngeal pressure was used to optimise the laryngeal view. It is generally recommended that the external laryngeal pressure should be an inherent part of direct laryngoscopy and an instinctive reflex response to a poor laryngeal view by direct laryngoscopy, because it can frequently improve the laryngeal view by at least one entire grade according to the Cormack and Lehane grading system.2 We are concerned that by not using external laryngeal pressure during direct laryngoscopy this may have underestimated the performance of the C-MAC videolaryngoscope as a direct laryngoscope. Second, as the authors described, one merit of the C-MAC videolaryngoscope is to provide the option of changing from video to direct laryngoscopy when necessary. In this study, all tracheal intubations were performed using the videolaryngoscopic view and about 10% of tracheal intubations required two or more attempts. The authors did not specify the possible reasons for multiple intubation attempts. We noted that difficult videolaryngoscopy was mainly attributable to bright ambient light and lens contamination of the micro camera at the distal end of the blade by blood, secretions and vomit. It is unclear whether in the study by Hossfeld et al.,1 multiple intubation attempts using the videolaryngoscopy were also caused by these same problems. If so, we would like to know whether the intubators had attempted to switch from video to direct laryngoscopy for tracheal intubation, because these problems rarely affect direct laryngoscopy.3 Because the design of the C-MAC blade has the unique advantage of providing both direct and indirect glottic views, this is actually an easy and rapid process. In a previous study comparing video and direct laryngoscopy for out-of-hospital emergency intubation, initial intubation with the videolaryngoscopy failed in 20 cases but was followed by successful intubation with direct laryngoscopy.4 Third, every intubation in this study was performed routinely using a stylet, but the authors did not state the curved angulation of stylet. McElwain et al.5 showed that the C-MAC videolaryngoscope performs best when using a hockey-stick stylet. Finally, the study by Hossfeld et al.1 did not report on the intubation time. Other than the success rate of tracheal intubation, the intubation time is also an important endpoint for evaluating the performance of airway management devices in the out-of-hospital setting, because any prolongation of intubation time increases the risk of hypoxia or bronchopulmonary-aspiration, especially in those patients who are critically ill, or are trauma patients or who are already hypoxic or are in the process of aspirating.6 In a prospective, multicentre, observational study assessing the performance of the C-MAC videolaryngoscope for out-of-hospital emergency intubation, the maximum time required for successful intubation was 300 s.7 Evidently, this is clinically unacceptable in critical out-of-hospital situations. Thus, we would argue that further clinical studies are still necessary to determine whether the C-MAC videolaryngoscope can be used as a first-line device for out-of-hospital emergency intubation. Acknowledgements relating to this article Assistance with the letter: none. Financial support and sponsorship: none. Conflicts of interest: none.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Li et al. (2015) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: