Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
First described over three centuries ago as ‘pore-like’ structures on the surface of leaves (Malpighi, 1675), the functional significance of stomata was realized only with the discovery of their unique ability to actively open and close. The English botanist Joseph Banks (1805) noted that the epidermis of corn was ‘furnished with ... rows of pores or mouths, shut in dry, open in wet weather’. Subsequently, Francis Darwin, Charles Darwin's son, demonstrated that high atmospheric CO2 concentrations, dry air and tissue water deficit cause stomata to close (Darwin, 1898). The ability of stomata to open and close results from osmotically induced increases in guard cell pressure (Fig. 1), as de Candolle (1827) first suggested. Indeed, the stomata of virtually all extant land plants operate with this same basic physiological mechanism. So far, there have been no exceptions to this observed ‘mode of action’, raising the fundamental question as to whether stomata have always operated like this. Huperzia prolifera (a; bar, 1 cm), a lycophyte, is one of the most ancient plant forms. Its stomata (b; bar, 20 µm) operate like those in all other plants: photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) stimulates an increase in guard cell pressure which opens stomata, thereby increasing stomatal conductance to water vapour and CO2, and darkness causes the reverse (c). Guard cell pressure was inferred from the relationship between stomatal aperture and pressure for H. prolifera (inset) taken from Franks & Farquhar (2007). Stomatal conductance to water vapour is from P. J. Franks (unpublished data). ‘Following dehiscence, the outer wall of the “guard cells” often ruptures – arguably the ultimate cellular sacrifice, stomatal suicide to perpetuate the generations.’ The earliest examples of stomata in the fossil record post-date the appearance of land plants by some 50–60 million yr, and are associated with fragmentary coalified axes (leafless stems) from Silurian rocks, dating to 410 million yr ago (Edwards et al., 1998). Plants had evidently hit upon a winning design because it has remained more or less unchanged (even for the elongated guard cells of cereals) ever since. Rather than substantially modifying this basic design as plant evolution progressed over the ensuing 410 million yr, variations in the control of maximum leaf conductance to sites of CO2 assimilation (and therefore photosynthetic capacity) occurred through co-ordinated changes in the size and density of stomata as the Earth's atmospheric CO2 concentration changed (Franks & Beerling, 2009). Biomechanical inferences drawn from lower Devonian coalified plant axes suggest that the stomata of early vascular land plants were probably operational, that is, had the capacity to at least partially open and close (Edwards & Axe, 1992), and possibly in a manner analogous to the behaviour of stomata in the clubmoss (Lycophyta) Huperzia (Fig. 1). Scanning electron micrographs (SEMs) of fossil axes indicate that guard cells were held within a rigid cuticularized epidermal cell framework, and this coupled with their less cuticularized outer periclinal walls appeared to allow them to bulge inwards at low turgor to close the pore (Edwards & Axe, 1992; Edwards et al., 1998). Similarly, in Huperzia, the lateral expansion of guard cells is strongly restricted and pore adjustment achieved through inflation and deflation effects on the inner wall of the guard cells (Fig. 1) (Franks & Farquhar, 2007). This situation is also reminiscent of the structurally defined stomata of mosses within the Funariaceae and Bryaceae families, and hornworts (Paton, 1957). From both a structural and phylogenetic standpoint, therefore, our understanding of stomatal function in early land plants is closely tied to the study of stomatal physiology in ‘lower’ land plants (i.e. mosses, hornworts, club mosses and basal ferns) with which we can undertake experiments. But this is a long-neglected research field, and the difficulties in working on often slow-growing ‘lower’ plant groups demand exceptional painstaking efforts. This is why the report by Duckett et al. (2009) in this issue of New Phytologist (pp. 1053–1063) is a welcome contribution to the debate, with the added twist that it challenges established ideas about the role of stomata by focusing on the highly unusual stomata (pseudostomata) in the sporophytes of Sphagnum moss. The role of regular stomata on leaves and stems of vascular plants is to allow plants to optimize their carbon gain with respect to total water lost in response to fluctuations in environmental conditions (Cowan, 1977; Cowan & Farquhar, 1977; see also Raven, 2002). Plants can increase stomatal apertures under conditions favouring or requiring photosynthesis (e.g. increasing photosynthetically active radiation (PAR), high humidity or low CO2) and reduce stomatal apertures when transpirational water loss threatens excessive water deficit or becomes wasteful (e.g. in dry air, drought, high CO2 or darkness). This function may have proved especially beneficial for controlling the rate of water loss from early Palaeozoic land plants with limited rooting and water-conducting systems experiencing conditions of restricted water supply or high evaporative demand (Edwards et al., 1998; Raven, 2002). Duckett et al., however, propose a reverse function for stomata in Sphagnum sporophytes by suggesting that ‘drying out and capsule shrinkage ... is the sole role for the stomata in Sphagnum’. Duckett et al. arrive at this conclusion after setting out to test the long-standing ‘air-gun’ hypothesis for the explosive release of operculum ‘lids’ from moss capsules. The hypothesis suggested that capsule drying and shrinkage raised the internal air pressure by compression until triggering the explosive release (or ‘popping’) of the operculum. One particularly vivid description of this ‘mechanism’ (Andrews, 1909), in reference to observations by von Nawaschin (1897), likens it to a gun cartridge: ‘the spores occupying the position of the shot, the compressed air that of the powder, the operculum corresponding to the outer wad, the membrane of the spore-sac to the inner one’. In a simple but elegant experimental test of this dogma, Duckett et al. demonstrate that, under drying at 20–22°C, punctured and entire spore capsules both dehisced and, therefore, that explosive dehiscence cannot be a result of a build-up of air pressure within the capsule. Indeed, punctured capsules had higher rates of dehiscence and water loss than unpunctured capsules. Instead of the ‘air-gun’ hypothesis, Duckett et al. therefore propose the rather more straightforward explanation of differential shrinkage and buckling of the capsule walls during dehydration as the cause of sudden release of the rigid operculum. SEMs on capsules leading up to the moment of dehiscence implicate a role of pseudostomata in facilitating capsule dehydration. SEMs revealed that it is only after the outer coating of the capsules (calyptra) splits and breaks away to uncover a surface scattered with primitive ‘stomata’ that the capsule undergoes the dehydration process. Until the rupture of the calyptra, capsule cells remain fully hydrated and the stomata have swollen guard cells, and lack a central pore. Shortly after drying, small central depressions appear on the guard cells which eventually lead to guard cells becoming deeply shrunken. Following dehiscence, the outer wall of the ‘guard cells’ often ruptures – arguably the ultimate cellular sacrifice, stomatal suicide to perpetuate the generations. To what extent should we be tempted to speculate that the pseudostomatal structures of Sphagnum sporophytes provide a window into the physiological function of stomata in early land plants? In Sphagnum capsules, Duckett et al. are probably correct in claiming that the primary role of pseudostomata is to facilitate drying. But can this conclusion be extended to the stomata of early land plants? Ever since the pioneering studies of a succession of German botanists in the late nineteenth century, it has long been known that Sphagnum stomata are structurally very unusual compared with those of higher plants. They lack substomatal cavities and potassium ion regulation, and develop beneath the calyptra where the microenvironment is presumably humid with locally elevated CO2 concentrations from cellular respiration. Interestingly, in higher plants grown under high relative humidity, stomates are propped partially open, unable to close completely on turgor loss (Franks & Farquhar, 2001). Nevertheless, on the basis of the basal phylogenetic position of Sphagnum relative to other mosses, Duckett et al. propose a monophyletic origin of pseudostomata and take the bold step of suggesting the possibility that ‘stomata first appeared on plants as structures that facilitated sporophyte drying out before spore discharge’, and that stomata ‘only subsequently acquired their role in the regulation of gas exchange’. And it is this claim that is likely to attract further detailed scrutiny because it raises the startling possibility that stomatal function in extant plants might be derived from structures that at one time were designed to open rather than close under desiccation (Fig. 2). Schematic representation of the basic functional difference between true stomata in vascular plants (a–c) and pseudostomata in the walls of spore capsules of Sphagnum (d, e). The blue shapes are pairs of guard cells viewed in cross-section, and the black lines are epidermal or subsidiary cell walls in cross-section. True stomata are closed at low guard cell turgor (a; deflated state), and are usually less circular in cross-section. Specialized wall structural properties, including differential wall thickening, result in the guard cells becoming more circular and bending away from each other to create the stomatal pore as turgor increases (b; inflated state; thick arrows indicate vertical displacement of guard cells). Many lower vascular plants (ferns and lycopods) are restricted to this range of movement. Higher vascular plants such as angiosperms, particularly grasses, exhibit additional wall extensibility and biophysical attributes allowing lateral movement into adjacent cells (c), overcoming the substantial opposing force or ‘mechanical advantage’ of these cells (grey arrows) and creating a wider stomatal pore. The pseudostomata in Sphagnum capsules appear to behave in the opposite way to those in vascular plants in that their ‘guard cells’ remain pressed together at full turgor (d; see Duckett et al.), and tend to partially separate upon turgor loss (e; redrawn from von Nawaschin, 1897). Duckett et al. posit that stomata may well have originated as structures like those in Sphagnum that facilitated, rather than prevented, desiccation. The implication is that the more recognizable stomata occurring in the sporophytes of later evolving moss genera, such as Funaria, are derived from, or originated independently from, pseudostomata like those of Sphagnum, and this switches the focus of the debate concerning the evolution of functional stomata to molecular genetics. The prospects for evolutionary developmental biology (‘evo-devo’) to yield significant insights into fundamental questions concerning the initial function of stomata, when they appeared in land plants, and what the precursors were, appear good. For example, the genetic modules of the signalling networks underpinning the action of the drought hormone abscisic acid (ABA) on guard cells in the higher plant Arabidopsis have been identified (Li et al., 2006), and Funaria stomata apparently also respond to ABA (Garner & Palillo, 1975). When allied to the completed draft genome sequence of the moss Physcomitrella patens (Rensing et al., 2008), which develops horseshoe-shaped guard cells around the base of its sporophyte (Paton, 1957), these complementary advances provide a road map for addressing whether the molecular sequences and function for guard cell signalling are conserved in mosses and angiosperms that last shared a common ancestor over 400 million yr ago. Finally, we note that the history of science is replete with examples whereby an intuitively good idea is accepted without question and soon becomes part of the accepted dogma (Beerling, 2007). Palaeobotanists repeated the fallacious argument that evergreen trees could not survive in the high latitudes under the warm polar winters of past greenhouse eras because of excessive respiratory carbon losses from the canopy during the long, dark, warm winters. Like the airgun hypothesis for Sphagnum capsule ‘popping’, this explanation became accepted dogma, until it was dispatched by experiments (Royer et al., 2003). Duckett et al.'s study serves to remind us of the need to challenge received wisdom in science with scepticism and, more importantly, experiments.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Beerling et al. (2009) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: