Key result
This letter cautions against the uncritical use of dynamic indices to predict volume responsiveness in spontaneously breathing patients and in the immediate postcardiac arrest period.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Dynamic indices for predicting volume responsiveness should be used with caution in spontaneously breathing patients and those with right ventricular failure, as their validity in these settings remains questionable.
To the Editor It is with great pride for our specialty and with clinical intrigue that we read the narrative review by Moitra et al1 and McEvoy et al2 focused on the evidence-based management of intraoperative cardiac arrest. Indeed, the authors of both associated reviews are to be congratulated for distilling what is a large and complex body of literature into a useful, pragmatic, and clinically relevant set of publications. We would like to clarify a few points that we believe are of particular import to the practicing anesthesiologist. First, hypovolemia is the most common cause of postoperative hemodynamic compromise.3 As such, methodologies to accurately determine volume responsiveness should be applied by practitioners before volume administration to assure that patients who require volume receive it, and those who do not, don’t. The authors suggest that a “growing literature” exists supporting the use of dynamic indices to predict volume responsiveness in spontaneously breathing patients. The 2 cited articles in Moitra et al,1 authored by Zollei et al4 and Hong et al,5 included patients who were spontaneously breathing under highly specific conditions that may not be readily accomplished in the general surgical population: forced inspiratory breathing and trained patterned breathing. While the methodology of both cited studies is valid, the strength of the conclusions based on study size is questionable and is remindful of Professor John Ioannidis’ first corollary, “the smaller the studies conducted in a scientific field, the less likely the research findings are to be true.”6,7 Second, while we agree that the presence of acute right ventricular (RV) shock often yields elevated dynamic indices that are generally false-positive, patients with RV failure may also be volume responsive, and dynamic indices may be predictive in this setting; however, further evaluation is required. Indeed, Mahjoub et al8 prospectively demonstrated that tissue Doppler assessment of peak systolic velocity of tricuspid annular motion can discriminate patients with true-positive and false-positive dynamic indices in the setting of RV failure. Third, relative to the use of dynamic indices for predicting volume responsiveness, we completely agree with the authors that the interpretive pitfalls are legion, and that fluid should only be administered after other assessments of volume responsiveness such as stroke volume change to a fluid bolus or a passive leg raise confirm the existence of volume responsiveness. However, to our knowledge, there are no studies validating the use of either dynamic indices or a passive leg raise test to predict volume responsiveness in the immediate postcardiac arrest period. Joshua A. Bloomstone, MD, MSc, CSSGBEnvision Physician ServicesPlantation, Florida[email protected] Brian H. Nathanson, PhD, DSHSOptiStatim, LLCLongmeadow, Massachusetts William T. McGee, MD, MHAUniversity of Massachusetts Medical SchoolBaystate Medical CenterSpringfield, Massachusetts
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bloomstone et al. (2018) conducted a letter in Volume responsiveness and intraoperative cardiac arrest. Dynamic indices was evaluated. This letter cautions against the uncritical use of dynamic indices to predict volume responsiveness in spontaneously breathing patients and in the immediate postcardiac arrest period.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: