Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
II Similarities between Chayanoy and KondratieyEspecially with regard to their careers, we can find striking similarities.They lived during turbulent years in Russian historM and cooperated with each other frequently Their common experiences are as fbllowsj:(1) The Same Generationand the Influence ofNarodnik Ideas Chayanov(born in 1888) and Kondratiev(born in 1892) both experienced the 1905 revolution when they were teenagers.They gradnated from universities shortly before the 1917 revolution, and both belonged to the last generation of those who received an imperial university education.When compared with the older generation who were strongly influenced by Maxxism, Chayanov and Kondratiev were under the influence ofnarodnik ideas, rather than Marxism.Ybung Kondratiey in particular, entered a neo-narodnik partM the Socialist Revolutionary (SR) PartM in 1905, and was arrested the fo11owing year.Chayanov never belonged to any political partM but we can easily find the infiuence ofnarodnik ideas in his work.(2) The year 1917 Both Chayanov and Kondratiev actively cooperated with the Provisional Government.When Kondratiev was only 25 years old he became the Vice- Minister ofFood Supply in the Kerensky Administration6.Chayanov was also active as the Vice-Minister ofAgriculture, when he was 29 years old.Thus, they concurrently occupied the highest position in the political bureaucracy concerning agricultural affairs, ifonly for a very short time.They also played leading roles in the Central Land Committee and the League fbr Agrarian Refbrms'.Furthermore, they cooperated in the Shaniavskii People's University, Hemp Producers' Central Association, the Cooperative Institute, and so on.(3) The 1920s Though many eminent intellectuals exiled themselves after the revolution, both Chayanov and Kondratiev remained in Russia to work in the Bolshevik government8.When Kondratiev visited the United States in 1924, he was asked to stay and work there by his old ftiend R Sorokin who had already been exiled from Russia.But he dared to refuse Sorokin's advice, returning to the Soviet Union.Meanwhile, Chayanov actively encouraged N.P Makarov andA.N.Chelintsey two old ftiends who had emigrated after the revolution, to return to the Soviet Union.The JapaneseSociety for Slavic and East European Studies COMPARING CHAYANOV AND KONDR2U'IEV Chayanov and Kondratiev played important roles as economic experts in the Soviet bureaucracy throughout the l920s.Chayanov was active at the People's Commissariat ofAgriculture (NKZem) from 1919, and he established and led the Institute ofAgricultural Economy at Moscovv Agriculture University9, under thejurisdiction ofNKZem.This institute became an important brain trust fbr the NKZem, especially in the first halfofthe 1920s, and it was here that the "Organization-Production School;' under his leadership, develeped their energetic research activities.He worked on a committee fbr fbod tax in 192 1, drafting a plan for agricultural reconstruction and many other agrarian bills as well.Chayanov was recommended to the staffofGosplan by Lenin.This did not come to pass, but he did serve as a representative ofNKZem at Gesplan.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Shuichi Kojima (2004) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 9 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: