Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
FigureDashboards, commonly known as report cards, are a way to display data in a graphic or colored layout that simplifies the identification of trends or areas needing improvement. Dashboards can also be used interactively for the user to drill down into more specifics, driving change, framing conversations, supplementing continuous performance improvement, and highlighting outstanding work.1,2 However, dashboard creation is typically spearheaded by nonclinical staff; if the data aren't chosen or displayed in a user-friendly manner, the dashboard can easily become white noise. For this reason, dashboards need to be created in a way that provides ease and flexibility for the user.1,3 If organizations don't condense unit outcomes into easy-to-use dashboards that provide both unit and individual data, nurse managers have the potential to miss relationships between the data, unit outcomes, and individual staff. Two nurse managers on medical-surgical units implemented a nonconventional approach using a traditional tool by piloting individual report cards to influence staff behavior, thereby linking individual accountability and performance to unit and organizational goals. These report cards allowed for a proactive approach to individualized data provided to RNs, patient care associates, and unit secretaries. The report card pilot, driven by data from an easy-to-use, succinct dashboard of information, created an environment where shared learning occurred. Staff members were aligned and supported, demonstrating their individual contributions to achieving organizational goals. The pilot program The pilot was conducted at an acute care, not-for-profit Magnet®-recognized community hospital in northern New Jersey. Full-time, part-time, and per diem staff on the two medical-surgical units consisted of approximately 50 RNs, 20 patient care associates, and eight unit secretaries. The two nurse managers identified that their staff members hadn't consistently received feedback regarding their individual performance and weren't able to correlate how their individual performance related to unit outcomes. If feedback was given, it was provided inconsistently throughout the year, initiated due to an issue with the individual, or generalized based on unit-level data with periodic individual-level data. There was also a varying practice of providing staff with both praise and opportunities to improve. Feedback was often focused around a particular issue that needed to be addressed, limiting staff members' ability to sustain unit initiatives. The nurse managers recognized that positively reinforcing performance would engage staff members to become accountable for their own professional practice, driving change from the individual level. The nurse managers concomitantly held themselves accountable to be fair and transparent with all staff. They wanted to transform how leaders interacted with staff regarding performance, changing the process from being corrective in nature to transformative and engaging. To combine multiple data points, individual dashboards, known as report cards, were created to stimulate monthly conversations with staff. These conversations provided a mechanism to recognize and praise high-performing staff and make a deliberate effort to counsel or address behaviors or trends in a timely fashion. The report card was a one-page document populated with individualized administrative and quality data that gave unit supervisors a way to provide a single source of feedback to the employee. Unit supervisors are charge nurses who support the nurse manager and have supervisory responsibilities, including unit evaluation, coaching, and counseling. The administrative data included items such as unscheduled absences, tardiness, overtime, and per diem hours worked. Quality data were customized based on unit initiatives, including bar code medication verification and pain reassessment rates. Using the existing time and attendance interface, quality data, and the electronic medical record, a report was generated that combined these multiple data points into a single report card for easy tracking and trending. After reviewing the report cards, the nurse managers determined if any next steps needed to be taken based on the data for each individual employee, including both recognition and coaching opportunities. The nurse managers then provided the report cards and subsequent actions to the unit supervisors, who discussed the report cards with staff. Each review took only a few minutes per staff member unless further discussion was needed regarding improving performance. The expectation was that the report card served as a monthly review of accountability with each staff member, thus driving the content for the yearly evaluation. The two outcomes initially tracked were bar code medication verification and incidental overtime. Goals were removed once the processes were hardwired; however, previous data items were still tracked monthly to reinforce goals when necessary and allow for a precise approach to any deviation from expected outcomes. For example, once bar code medication verification significantly improved and was hardwired, the next quality goal tracked was pain reassessment rates. Results On the first unit, the communication domain of the Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (HCAHPS) survey increased by 12%. (See Figure 1.) On the second unit, the nurse communication domain increased by 3%. (See Figure 2.) Incidental hours were reduced on unit 1 by 41% and on unit 2 by 32%. (See Figure 3.) Quality metrics regarding bar code medication verification and pain reassessment rates improved on unit 1 by 11% and 8%, respectively. On unit 2, which had higher initial baselines, bar code medication verification increased by 1% and pain reassessment rates by 5%. (See Figure 4.)Figure 1:: Unit 1 patient satisfactionFigure 2:: Unit 2 patient satisfactionFigure 3:: Incidental hours—all staffFigure 4:: Pain reassessment ratesSenior nursing leadership and the executive team recognized the sustained impact that the report cards had on the two pilot units and implemented them throughout the organization, including both nursing and non-nursing areas. Through a modified hospital-wide report card process, the organization was able to elevate its overall bar code medication verification rate to above the goal of 95%. This success gave hospital leadership the confidence to adopt this method of providing feedback to staff as an organizational best practice. Throughout the organization, both nursing and non-nursing areas have customized the report cards based on their department-specific goals while connecting individual performance to the broader organizational goals. Discussion Empowering staff members with accountability enables them to have the power to drive care outcomes.4 Staff members who have a personal stake in accountability make decisions to their highest professional standard.5 Report cards fostered a team environment and unit cohesion, which increased performance.5,6 Each month, staff members saw incremental improvement in both their own scores and unit scores, which cultivated healthy competition and looking for ways to do better. They all wanted to receive “straight As,” and in doing so elevated the unit even more by creating a sense of pride in themselves and the unit. The nurse managers discovered that before the report cards, staff members weren't aware of how they individually impacted the unit as a whole and were unable to make the connection between self-accountability and unit initiatives. Before the report cards, staff members often felt that broad organizational goals didn't apply because they thought they were always doing what was expected. Without knowing the expectations and where they stood, meaningful change couldn't be made. Individualized, specific data were necessary because generalized unit data didn't help staff members understand their relationship to the data.6 Although the tools necessary to provide individualized feedback were available before the use of report cards, they weren't being used in a way that translated to consistent staff improvement. In fact, before the report cards, there were so many sources of data that it became overwhelming. Creating one source of clear and consistent data facilitated individualized feedback, which fostered self-accountability that led to unit transformation. When presenting data to staff, nurse leaders need to have a heightened awareness of unintentional bias. In the past, policies, procedures, rules, and standards may have been unfairly skewed toward high performers, failing to optimize individual capacity.7 The report card process highlighted what the nurse managers needed to focus on daily so they didn't set themselves up for unintentional bias. For example, if a staff member was late or called out, the nurse manager was often given a “heads up” to “keep an eye” on that individual, which meant that the nurse manager wasn't equally looking at everyone. The report card created a sense of security and confidence for the nurse managers that they were equally evaluating everyone in the same way each month. Implications for nursing leaders Unit-level data are useful; however, they still need to be translated in a way for staff members to understand their role in shaping unit outcomes. Staff need to know that data are accurate, reliable, and not always punitive in nature but rather a way to improve outcomes.6 Individualized data are crucial as a way to encourage staff engagement in improvement opportunities.6 To provide individualized data, organizations need to build dashboards for high-level data that can then be drilled down. This will help nurse leaders spot individual or unit trends impacting the overall data. For nurse managers to use data effectively and efficiently, the data should ideally be centralized and collated. Too often, administrative and quality data are in separate systems, causing more work for nurse managers to collate and analyze. By combining data into a single dashboard, nurse managers can better use their time on translating the data for staff. Through staff feedback, the report card now includes a focus on resiliency by promoting staff members' personal goals, self-care, and patient connections in addition to the achievement of unit goals. Although the report card process takes roughly 1 hour each month to complete, the investment in time pays dividends in accountability, quality and, most important, building relationships with staff.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Piech et al. (2021) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: