Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In recent years, a steady improvement in survival after radical surgery for esophageal carcinoma has been observed. Earlier detection, refinements in surgical technique, perioperative management, and adjunctive chemo/radiotherapy regimens1,2 have led to a substantial increase in both overall- and disease-free survival, with 40% of patients alive up to 5 years after radical surgery.3 As survival improves, symptoms unrelated to the original disease become relevant for the patient and impact on his/her quality of life. These symptoms include reflux, early satiety, malabsorption, diarrhea, and postprandial dumping.4,5 While commonly associated with gastrectomy and gastric bypass procedures, dumping syndrome is an intermittently reported and poorly understood complication of esophagectomy. Dumping syndrome may be classified into early and late dumping based on the relationship between the time elapsed following oral intake and the onset of symptoms. Early dumping, which typically occurs within 30 min of ingestion of a meal is characterized by palpitations, abdominal cramps, diarrhea, and nausea. These symptoms are believed to reflect the excessive secretion of gastrointestinal hormones and fluid shifts that accompany the rapid influx of hypertonic gastric chyme into the proximal small bowel. In contrast, late dumping typically occurs within 2–3 h of oral intake and is characterized by symptoms of hypoglycaemia (dizziness, faintness, cold sweats, and hunger). The pathophysiology of postesophagectomy dumping is incompletely understood. Factors believed to contribute to its development are principally related to disruption of gastric anatomy and function, including tubularization and transposition of the stomach into the thorax, reduced gastric capacity, vagotomy and gastric denervation, and disruption of mechanisms that regulate normal gastrointestinal function.6 The aims of this systematic review are (i) to define the incidence of dumping syndrome following esophagectomy; (ii) to identify risk factors for dumping syndrome after esophagectomy; and (iii) to determine strategies for the prevention and management of this complication. A literature search (title and abstract) of the EMBASE, MEDLINE, PsycINFO, and Cochrane Library databases was conducted independently by two reviewers (PRB and JRH) on July 9, 2015. The search strategy was as follows: “esophagectomy AND ((Quality of life) OR (dumping) OR (hypoglycaemia) OR (diarrhea) OR (dizziness) OR (sweating) OR (diaphoresis)).” The titles and abstracts of studies identified through the electronic searches were screened and the full texts of potentially relevant articles were obtained. The reference lists of acquired studies were hand-searched to identify further potentially relevant studies. Inclusion criteria were studies published in the English language (without restriction on the year of publication) reporting dumping syndrome in human subjects following esophagectomy. Esophagectomy was defined as any surgery removing all or part of the esophagus by any approach. Studies reporting esophagectomy for cancer or benign disease by any surgical approach were eligible for inclusion. Studies reporting outcomes of patients who received neoadjuvant of adjuvant chemo/radiotherapy were also eligible for inclusion. Studies that reported the same patient population were excluded, except for the most recent or complete publication or where further subgroup analysis yielded relevant information as to dumping syndrome within this population. Abstracts and unpublished data were excluded. One reviewer (PRB) extracted data from the studies including primary author, year of publication, country (and center) of origin, design of study, number of patients who underwent surgery and/or completed follow-up, surgical approach (transthoracic, transhiatal, and minimally invasive esophagectomy), site of anastomosis, concurrent pyloric drainage procedure, method of reconstruction including details of the conduit used and mediastinal passage, and length of follow-up. Thirty-three studies matched the selection criteria and were eligible for inclusion in this systematic review.7,–39 Search results are presented in Figure 1. A summary of eligible studies including details of surgical approach is presented in Tables (1–3). In addition to these studies, seven review articles were also identified, within which dumping syndrome was documented as a postoperative complication of esophagectomy.4,6,39–43 Systematic search and selection strategy. Details of included studies University of Southern California Keck School of Medicine, USA. University of Michigan Hospitals, USA. Mayo Clinic, USA. Details of included studies University of Southern California Keck School of Medicine, USA. University of Michigan Hospitals, USA. Mayo Clinic, USA. Demographic details University of Southern California Keck School of Medicine, USA. University of Michigan Hospitals, USA. Mayo Clinic, USA. Determined from the highest rate of dumping observed at a any point in time during a study. Demographic details University of Southern California Keck School of Medicine, USA. University of Michigan Hospitals, USA. Mayo Clinic, USA. Determined from the highest rate of dumping observed at a any point in time during a study. Details of procedural factors University of Southern California Keck School of Medicine, USA. University of Michigan Hospitals, USA. Mayo Clinic, USA. Two patients (0.3%) did not undergo reconstruction. PP, pyloroplasty; PM, pyloromyotomy; BI, botulinuminjection; FB, finger bougie; THE, transhiatalesophagectomy; TTE, transthoracic esophagevtomy; MIE, minimally invasive esophagectomy; O, other; PM, posterior mediastinum; RS, retrosternal; SC, subcutaneous; G, gastric; SB, small bowel; C, colon; E, esophagus; O, other; C, cervical; IT, intrathoracic. Details of procedural factors University of Southern California Keck School of Medicine, USA. University of Michigan Hospitals, USA. Mayo Clinic, USA. Two patients (0.3%) did not undergo reconstruction. PP, pyloroplasty; PM, pyloromyotomy; BI, botulinuminjection; FB, finger bougie; THE, transhiatalesophagectomy; TTE, transthoracic esophagevtomy; MIE, minimally invasive esophagectomy; O, other; PM, posterior mediastinum; RS, retrosternal; SC, subcutaneous; G, gastric; SB, small bowel; C, colon; E, esophagus; O, other; C, cervical; IT, intrathoracic. Of the 32 included studies, 10 publications reported outcomes from three institutions.10,16–18,22,23,25,29,31,37 Outcomes from these publications are included as in each instance, they yielded additional information as to the occurrence of dumping syndrome in different patients groups within the same case series. When calculating the pooled incidence of dumping syndrome across all included studies, only data from the most informative study were used, where multiple publications from the same institution were found. Sixteen studies reported either a description of dumping symptoms (11 studies)14,17–20,22,25,28,31,33,34; details of a dumping assessment tool (3 studies)12,13,15; or clinical and/or biochemical criteria for the diagnosis of dumping (2 studies).21,26 Specific symptoms of dumping identified in 11 studies were postprandial: diarrhea (10 studies)14,17,19,20,22,25,28,31,33,34; abdominal cramping (6 studies)14,17,18,22,25,31; dizziness (5 studies)18,19,25,28,34; diaphoresis (4 studies)18,19,25,33; nausea (4 studies)14,20,25,34; palpitation (2 studies)18,34; flushing20; and tiredness.34 Two studies adopted the Japanese Society of Gastrointestinal Surgery questionnaire for dumping after gastrectomy to characterize this complication after esophagectomy.12,15 Rates of symptoms associated with postesophagectomy dumping syndrome have been reported by several studies. Diarrhea (range 27–56%), abdominal cramps (32–64%), nausea (15–46%), diaphoresis (11–38%), and dizziness (8–14%) were the most commonly experienced symptoms in patients with dumping following esophagectomy.12,14,23,25 The most comprehensive assessment of dumping syndrome after esophagectomy was performed by Sinha et al.26 In their study, they correlated subject's symptomatic response to 150 mL of oral 50% dextrose, as well as their gastric emptying time, variation in pulse rate, plasma volume, and blood glucose. Importantly they reported that of those patients who complained of symptoms of dumping syndrome, <50% demonstrated objective physiological or biochemical evidence of this condition. The pooled outcomes of eligible studies demonstrate rates of dumping syndrome after esophagectomy between 0% and 78%. Of the 2044 patients for whom complete data was available, 412 (20.2%) were observed to have symptoms of dumping syndrome following esophagectomy. The severity of dumping and its impact on patient's quality of life were inconsistently reported. In the cohort presented by Greene et al., 40% of patients reported dumping symptoms less frequently than once a month, while 30% of patients had dumping symptoms at least once daily (no patient reported dumping with every meal).10 Baker et al. reported a single patient with dumping symptoms that occurred daily.8 Scipione et al. reported that postprandial dumping symptoms (abdominal cramping or diarrhea) were characterized as mild (no treatment required), moderate (occasional medical therapy required), and severe (regular medical therapy required) in 24%, 9%, and 2% of patients, respectively.17 An earlier report by the same group observed severe refractory dumping in 4% of patients,22 while Mehran et al. reported 2% of patients were incapacitated by dumping symptoms.12 Other studies have described relatively mild symptoms of dumping syndrome that were responsive to treatment. All patients (8%) with suspected dumping reported by Ludwig et al. had mild symptoms that did not require dietary modification or additional medical therapy.20 Another study, however, observed that of those patients with symptoms of dumping 5 years after esophagectomy, 41% required treatment.31 In the series reported by King et al., all patients with dumping syndrome responded to treatment.37 Several studies observed an improvement in dumping syndrome with increasing time after surgery. De Leyn et al. observed almost complete resolution of dumping symptoms within 1 year of surgery (18% at 3 months vs. 1% at 1 year).34 Similarly, in another study, dumping syndrome was observed in 16% of patients within the first 6 months of surgery and only 1.5% of patients with more than 2 years follow-up, with most symptoms easily controlled with treatment.35 Although follow-up was not complete, dumping syndrome was not observed beyond 3years in patients reported by Kuwano et al.30 Haverkort et al., however, reported a stable rate of dumping syndrome in patients assessed at 1 week (74%), 3 months (78%), 6 months (78%), and 1 year (75%) following esophagectomy.13 A similar trend was identified by Antonoff et al., who determined broadly equivalent rates of dumping syndrome at 0–6 months (13.6%), 6–12 months (15.6%) and >12 months (17.9%) after esophagectomy.9 The disparity between the rates of dumping syndrome reported by these two studies is however striking.9,14 Factors predictive of dumping syndrome after esophagectomy were reported by several studies. These can be broadly categorized in terms of patient-specific factors, pyloric procedures, vagal sparing esophagectomy, and surgical approach and method of reconstruction (Table 4). Factors influencing dumping syndrome after esophagectomy Centre for Evidence Based Medicine, Oxford Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine. http://www.cebm.net/index.aspx?o=5653 Factors influencing dumping syndrome after esophagectomy Centre for Evidence Based Medicine, Oxford Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine. http://www.cebm.net/index.aspx?o=5653 The potential effects of patient specific factors on rates of dumping syndrome after esophagectomy were reported by three studies. A comparison of obese and non-obese patients undergoing esophagectomy found that the incidence of mild (24 vs. 24%), moderate (8 vs. 10%), and severe (1 vs. 2%) dumping were not significantly different (P = 0.89).17 This study also reported equivalent rates of dumping in obese and non-obese patients who underwent surgery for malignant (P = 0.94) and benign (P = 0.62) disease. The same group also published equivalent rates of dumping more than 5 years after esophagectomy for malignant and benign disease (23% vs. 20%). Finally, McLarty et al. observed higher rates of dumping syndrome in younger patients (P < 0.05) and women (P < 0.01).25 The effect of pyloric drainage procedures on the occurrence of postoperative dumping has been reported by five studies. A randomized-controlled trial observed dumping syndrome occurred only in patients who had undergone pyloroplasty.26 Furthermore, in these patients, pyloroplasty was associated with faster gastric emptying (P = 0.018), a greater change in pulse rate (P = 0.01), but equivalent plasma volume and blood glucose levels.26 Similarly, Wang et al. reported higher rates of dumping syndrome following esophagectomy in patients who underwent pyloroplasty compared to patients with no pyloric drainage procedure (33.3% vs. 6.9%).32 Another study determined rates of dumping syndrome tendered to be higher following pyloroplasty/pyloromyotomy (21%) and pyloric dilation with botullinum injection (13%) compared to patients who received no pyloric intervention (0%), although this trend did not reach statistical significance (P = 0.144).9 One randomized-controlled trial did not observe any significant difference in rates of dumping syndrome after either pyloroplasty or pyloromyotomy.24 This complication was considered by the authors to be “uncommon,” although the exact incidence was not declared. Likewise, Eldaif et al. found rates of dumping syndrome were equivalent in patients who received botulinum injection (11.7%), pyloromyotomy (2.4%), or pylorplasty (8.6%, P = 0.25).9 Finally compared to patients who underwent finger bougie only, pyloroplasty was not associated with higher rates of dumping syndrome after esophagectomy.15 In one study, vagal sparing esophagectomy was associated with lower rates of dumping syndrome compared to both transhiatal and transthoracic esophagectomy (4% vs. 33% vs. 43%, respectively, P = 0.0004).16 The same group published the outcomes of a limited subgroup of their case series, confirming dumping syndrome rates were significantly lower in patients who underwent vagal sparing esophagectomy (6.7%) compared to patients who underwent esophagogastrectomy with colon interposition (30%, P = 0.002), but equivalent in patients who had esophagectomy with gastric pull-up (10%, P > 0.05).18 Significantly lower rates of dumping syndrome were observed in one study in patients who underwent high thoracic anastomosis via a posterior mediastinal route (22%) compared to patients with cervical anastomosis via either a posterior mediastinal (71%, P = 0.02) or retrosternal route (58%, P = 0.48).15 Finley et al. also reported cervical anastomosis was associated with higher rates of dumping syndrome (6%) compared to intrathoracic anastomosis (0%).28 Two studies, however, did not report a difference in the rate of dumping syndrome in patients with either intrathoracic or cervical anastomosis.34,38 Likewise, Kuwano et al. found dumping syndrome rates were similar in patients who underwent reconstruction via a range of methods, including cervical anastomosis and intrathoracic anastomosis (12%) and cervical anastomosis with either antethoracic (11%) or retrosternal (13%) conduit placement.30 Finally, Cerfolio et al. reported no correlation between conduit type, conduit position and site of anastomosis with long-term functional outcomes of esophagectomy, including dumping syndrome.29 One study which compared open versus minimally invasive esophagectomy found no significant difference in the rate of dumping symptoms,12 while another study found no association between dumping syndrome and the width of the gastric conduit.7 As previously discussed, the severity of dumping syndrome following esophagectomy may often be mild and can be managed conservatively without need for medical therapy. Two studies commented that symptoms of dumping syndrome could be effectively managed with simple dietary advice including: eating smaller and more frequent meals; consumption of liquids after, rather than during meals, to avoid gastric distension, and; avoiding meals rich in carbohydrates.24,34 However, no study investigated the influence of regular dietetic involvement in respect to the prevention and management of dumping syndrome after esophagectomy. Reported medical therapies for the treatment of postesophagectomy dumping syndrome included diphenoxylate, tincture of opium, loperamide, somatastatin, and acabose.21,22,31 The efficacy of these therapies, for the treatment of dumping syndrome following esophagectomy, has not been assessed in either randomized or nonrandomized comparative trials. This is the first systematic literature review to comprehensively examine dumping syndrome as a complication of esophagectomy. The important findings are (i) establishing the prevalence of dumping syndrome in patients who have undergone esophagectomy; (ii) characterization of the nature and severity of symptoms experienced by patients with this condition; and (iii) recognition of potential risk factors for the development of postesophagectomy dumping syndrome. Findings confirm the significant burden that dumping syndrome has on the postoperative recovery of patients following esophagectomy and highlight those factors that are potentially responsible for its development. Uncertainty as to the mechanism(s) by which dumping syndrome occurs in patients following esophagectomy remains. While a number of studies have reported factors associated with dumping syndrome, outcomes from a small number of studies with both methodological heterogeneity and often contradictory findings limit the strength of conclusions that can be drawn. Two studies, including one randomized-controlled trial, associated pyloroplasty, performed at the time of esophagectomy, with higher rates of postoperative dumping syndrome.26,32 Importantly, in one of these studies, this observation was correlated with faster gastric emptying time and physiological changes suggestive of dumping syndrome.26 When the outcomes of patients who underwent a range of pyloric procedures (pyloroplasty, pyloromyotomy, finger bougie, or botulinum injection) were compared, no specific intervention was found to be associated with significantly higher rates of dumping syndrome. Disruption of vagal innervation to the stomach, an often unavoidable consequence of esophagectomy, is hypothesized to provoke dysregulation of normal gastric secretomotor function promoting dumping syndrome. While one center has reported lower rates of dumping syndrome in patients who underwent vagal sparing esophagectomy, these findings should be viewed with caution on account of a small sample size18 and confounding due to the routine use of pyloroplasty in patients undergoing “standard” surgery.16 Gut hormones may also play a role in the pathophysiology of postesophagectomy dumping syndrome. While a number of studies have demonstrated the importance of gut hormones in regard to postoperative functional outcomes following gastrectomy and gastric bypass procedures, these findings are yet to be comprehensively explored and replicated in esophagectomy patients. The exaggerated postprandial insulin response that is observed in patients after gastric resection cannot be attributed to postoperative hyperglycemia alone, prompting investigation of alternative mechanisms. Incretins, insulinotropic substances released by the gastrointestinal tract are proposed to be, at least, partly responsible for increased insulin release and concurrent hypoglycemia. A rise in postprandial plasma glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1), an incretin released from ileal L-cells, has been observed in patients following esophagectomy.44 Compared to controls, patients who have undergone esophageal resection had significantly higher GLP-1 levels at baseline and within the first 30 min after consumption of a standard test meal, which was associated with a concurrent rise in insulin and a delayed fall in serum glucose. Similar changes in plasma GLP-1 and insulin levels have been observed in a patient suffering from reactive hypoglycemia secondary to late dumping syndrome following esophagectomy.21 This response was effectively attenuated by treatment with acabose, an α-glucosidase inhibitor.21 While the symptoms of dumping syndrome are often mild and improve over time, there remain a small proportion of patients (2–4%) who suffered severe long-term morbidity from this condition. In spite of its significance, no universally adopted criteria exist for the assessment and diagnosis of dumping syndrome after esophagectomy. Half of the studies, reporting dumping syndrome as a complication of esophagectomy that are included in this systematic review, provided neither a description of the condition nor criteria for its diagnosis. When reported, the most commonly observed symptoms of dumping syndrome in patients who had undergone esophagectomy were diarrhea, abdominal cramping, dizziness, and nausea. While was that the of studies described early dumping syndrome, the of observed symptoms was often not there is a for a of postesophagectomy dumping syndrome. In the of a the Japanese Society of Gastrointestinal Surgery questionnaire for dumping syndrome an for the characterization of dumping symptoms. to the nature of dumping criteria should to objective physiological and biochemical evidence of this condition. A similar to that described by Sinha et al. may be for this of gut levels may also have a in the diagnosis and characterization of this condition. In of this approach is the observation that of those patients who with symptoms suggestive of dumping syndrome, less than may demonstrate objective physiological or biochemical evidence of this Dumping syndrome the recovery of one in five patients after esophagectomy and has the potential to the quality of life of an increasing number of patients who long-term disease-free survival following this surgery. reporting of dumping syndrome after esophagectomy has led to as to the burden of this condition and its Although no single surgical approach to the occurrence of dumping syndrome, procedural including pyloric drainage procedures may symptoms. studies should to criteria for the diagnosis of both early and dumping syndrome after esophagectomy. of biochemical of postesophagectomy dumping syndrome, including the role by gut define the pathophysiology of this complication and may also
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Boshier et al. (2016) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: