Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Plastic surgery education has changed substantially over the past 40 years, as many residency programs have transitioned to integrated training models.1 Although the American College of Graduate Medical Education Residency Review Committee and the American Board of Plastic Surgery provide educational curriculum guidelines to plastic surgery training programs, room for substantial interprogram variability remains. Thus, many components of plastic surgery integrated training are determined by the program and program directors, sometimes involving input of a curriculum committee.2 Current literature lacks a review of educational curricula and residents’ perceptions of curriculum utility for integrated training. Thus, we designed a cross-sectional survey distributed to integrated programs across the country to (1) characterize current integrated plastic surgery residency curricula and (2) assess resident satisfaction with educational resources for in-service and board examination preparation. An online survey was designed using the Qualtrics platform and distributed to plastic surgery chief residents in the top 25 Doximity “reputation” ranked residency programs. Selection criteria included programs that (1) had at least 14 residents and (2) had an integrated training program established for at least 3 years (n = 21 programs total). The response rate was 90.4 percent (19 of 21 programs), with a mean of 1.8 resident responses per program (total n = 34 chief resident responses). Our study found substantial variability in educational curricula even among the top plastic surgery training programs (Table 1). Using a Likert scale ranging from 1 to 5 to indicate satisfaction with curricula, median satisfaction was 3 (interquartile range, 2 to 4), with the majority of chief residents satisfied (38.2 percent) to very satisfied (29.4 percent) with existing didactic structure (Fig. 1). There was a substantial cohort of residents who did not find their curricula to be a worthwhile time investment (23.5 percent) or more worthwhile than self-study time (26.5 percent). Table 1. - Characteristics of Educational Curricula Component Chief Resident Responses (%) Top educational program influence Chief residents 47.06 Program director 32.35 Chief/chair of the division/department 11.76 Other residents 5.88 Other faculty 2.94 Foundation of didactics (select all that apply) PSEN (ASPS EdNet) 67.65 CoreQuest 20.59 Other 35.29 Textbooks 32.35 Essentials (Janis) 23.33 Michigan Manual (Brown et al.) 10.00 Grabb & Smith (Chung) 23.33 Green’s Operative Hand Surgery (Wolf) 16.67 Plastic Surgery (Mathes) 13.33 Other 13.33 Preparation and presentation of didactics (select all that apply) Faculty (plastic and reconstructive surgery) 79.41 Faculty (other) 38.24 Residents 91.18 Curricular adjuncts Cadaver dissections 73.53 Formal in-service preparation 61.76 Standalone oral boards preparation 55.88 Simulation 29.41 Specialty-specific conferences Morbidity and mortality 100 Indications 73.53 Craniofacial 55.88 Aesthetics 38.24 Hand 88 Imaging review 17.65 Other 8.82 Research requirements There is a research project requirement 50.00 There is a required research year(s) 23.53 Yes, there are specific research didactics 17.65 There is no formal research curriculum 38.24 Resident perspective Worthwhile time investment Yes 76.47 No 23.53 Formal didactics are more worthwhile than self-study time Yes 73.53 No 26.47 PSEN, Plastic Surgery Education Network; ASPS, American Society of Plastic Surgeons; EdNet, Education Network. Fig. 1.: Chief resident satisfaction with current educational curriculum.Educational curricula seek to accomplish multiple overlapping goals in plastic surgery training, including preparing residents for operative cases, the in-service examination, and the board examinations. Previous studies have identified that residents in plastic surgery report mixed learning styles, and many prefer active experimentation to traditional learning styles.3,4 For example, the use of three-dimensionally–printed surgical models has been shown to enhance resident education in craniofacial surgery.5 The present study shows only a small subset using simulation (29.4 percent). The use of simulation and cadaveric dissection has been studied in other medical and surgical specialties, and may allow for added objective, real-time feedback in resident education. There are numerous resources available for plastic surgery resident education, leading to the substantial variability in educational curricula observed in this study. Currently, there are no guidelines on use of existing resources to create comprehensive and efficient curricula. We aim for this study to provide a foundation for future efforts to standardize resident training curricula to optimize in-service and board examination preparation. Based on our results, further exploration into optimizing and standardizing integrated curricula through the educational committees within our plastic surgery societies is warranted. DISCLOSURE The authors have no financial interest to declare in relation to the content of this article. No funding was received for this article.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Wickenheisser et al. (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: