Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
There is a well known difficulty in understanding Aristotle's answer to central question of Nicomachean Ethics:' what is eudaimonia? Some, leaning on Bk. X, chapters 6-8, maintain that Aristotle's answer is contemplation to exclusion of anything else. Others, leaning on Bk. I, hold that eudaimonia includes other goods besides contemplation, especially (what I will call) moral action, exercise of moral virtues. Still others hold that Bk. X contains an exclusive of eudaimonia as consisting in nothing but contemplation, and is not in end reconcilable with Bk. I's inclusive account. At present, a consensus seems to be growing that at least we can be sure that Bk. I propounds an inclusive account of eudaimonia.2 Hence, if Bks. I and X fit together into a coherent account, Bk. X must be brought into line with such a position. I'll call this the comprehensive view of eudaimonia. The comprehensive interpretation relies on a number of arguments to support its of NE I, above all criterion of self-sufficiency laid down at 1097bl4-21. In present paper I will argue that appeal to selfsufficiency as well as other arguments fail to prove comprehensive
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Robert Heinaman (1988) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: