Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The objective of this trial was to compare different conventional insecticide programs targeting CM, OFM, PC, and PLH against an untreated check and a standard conventional program. Treatments were applied to 2-tree plots in a 48-yr-old planting of semi-dwarf ‘Red Delicious’ apple trees on an 18 × 20 ft tree by row spacing at the Trevor Nichols Research Center in Fennville, MI. Treatments were replicated 4 times in an RCB design. Applications were made using an FMC 1,029 tractor-mounted airblast sprayer calibrated to deliver 100 gpa at 2.5 mph. Treatments were designed as season-long programs beginning at bloom, with degree day-driven timings for CM. Degree-days were calculated with a base temperature of 50°F and the weather station at the Trevor Nichols Research Center was used for these calculations (https://enviroweather.msu.edu/). CM biofix for the first generation was 4 May and the biofix for CM second generation was 15 Jul. Foliar applications of Inspire Super, Luna Tranquility, and Manzate Pro Stik were applied over the season and across the block to manage diseases. In addition, 2,4-D, glyphosate, SimTrol 4L, and Solicam were banded below the trees for weed suppression as needed. Plots were assessed for OFM larval shoot damage on 50 terminal shoots on 28 May. PLH nymphs were counted on 30 terminals per plot on 14 June. Fruits were assessed for PC stings on 100 apples per plot on 31 May and OFM/CM entries (apples with frass) on 50 fruit per plot on 1 July. Harvest evaluation occurred on 22 Aug. One hundred fruits were collected per plot and assessed for PC stings, leafroller surface feeding damage (LR), and internal lepidopteran tunneling (OFM/CM). Internal lepidopteran tunneling was assessed by cutting the fruit in half or at exit/entrance holes. Assessments of insect damage were strongly zero-inflated and a negative binomial distribution in a generalized linear mixed model was used (glmmTMB, R v.4.2.2) for analysis. Replicate was used as a random effect, and treatments were fixed effects. The models were tested for fit and overdispersion and post-hoc comparisons of treatment effects were conducted using Tukey’s HSD. Phytotoxicity was evaluated on 28 May, 14 Jun, 26 Jun, 9 Jul, 22 Jul, 5 Aug, and 19 Aug; no phytotoxicity was found. Treatment programs Endigo ZC/Altacor/Delegate/Assail, Rimon/Assail/Imidan/Verdepryn, and Spear Lep + Javelin/Endigo ZC/Altacor/Delegate/Assail had numerically fewer OFM damaged shoots per 50 shoots sampled (Table 1), although none of the treatment means were significantly lower than the untreated check due to low and variable pressure throughout plots. There were significantly lower mean PC stings in all treatment programs on 31 May except Spear Lep + Javelin/Endigo ZC/Delegate/Assail when compared to the Untreated check (Table 1). The incidence of PLH was numerically lower in all treatment programs compared to the Untreated check (Table 1). Lepidopteran entries were too low on the 1 Jul assessment to run a statistical analysis; however, all programs had fewer lepidopteran entries than the untreated control. Fruit assessed at harvest time in Endigo ZC/Altacor/Delegate/Assail program resulted in significantly fewer PC stings per 100 apples, all other treatment programs had numerically fewer stings than the untreated check (Table 2). Leafroller damage was significantly lower in treatment programs Actara/Plinazolin/Imidan/Assail, Rimon/Assail/Imidan/Verdepryn, and Spear Lep + Javelin/Endigo ZC/Delegate/Assail, and was numerically lower in all other treatment programs versus the Untreated check (Table 2). Internal lepidopteran damage (OFM/CM) was lower in all treatment programs compared to the untreated check (Table 2).1 Means followed by the same letter do not significantly differ (P ≤ 0.05, Tukey’s HSD). A = Apr 30 (Bloom), B = May 10 (Petal Fall), C = May 23 (CM Biofix + 250DD50ºF), D = June 7 (C + 14 d), E = June 19 (D + 14 d), F = July 3 (E + 14 d), G = July 17 (F + 14 d), H = July 31 (2nd Gen. CM Biofix + 250DD50ºF), I = Aug 14 (H + 14 d). Means followed by the same letter do not significantly differ (P ≤ 0.05, Tukey’s HSD). A = Apr 30 (Bloom), B = May 10 (Petal Fall), C = May 23 (CM Biofix + 250DD50ºF), D = June 7 (C + 14 d), E = June 19 (D + 14 d), F = July 3 (E + 14 d), G = July 17 (F + 14 d), H = July 31 (2nd Gen. CM Biofix + 250DD50ºF), I = Aug 14 (H + 14 d). Means followed by same letter do not significantly differ (P ≤ 0.05, Tukey’s HSD). A = Apr 30 (Bloom), B = May 10 (Petal Fall), C = May 23 (CM Biofix + 250DD50ºF), D = June 7 (C + 14 d), E = June 19 (D + 14 d), F = July 3 (E + 14 d), G = July 17 (F + 14 d), H = July 31 (2nd Gen. CM Biofix + 250DD50ºF), I = Aug 14 (H + 14 d). Means followed by same letter do not significantly differ (P ≤ 0.05, Tukey’s HSD). A = Apr 30 (Bloom), B = May 10 (Petal Fall), C = May 23 (CM Biofix + 250DD50ºF), D = June 7 (C + 14 d), E = June 19 (D + 14 d), F = July 3 (E + 14 d), G = July 17 (F + 14 d), H = July 31 (2nd Gen. CM Biofix + 250DD50ºF), I = Aug 14 (H + 14 d).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
DeVisser et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: