Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Debates on generative and agentic AI are often framed through two simplified images: AI as a productivity tool and AI as an autonomous agent. The first tends to understate how AI can help actors move across fragmented domains of expertise; the second tends to overstate the extent to which current systems can independently navigate the institutional, relational, and normative complexity of real-world action. This paper argues that AI can function as a bridge across expertise, but only within broader forms of human, institutional, and technical coordination. The claim is developed through an analysis of the Conyngham–Rosie episode, a widely reported case in which Paul Conyngham, seeking treatment for his dog Rosie’s terminal cancer, used AI tools together with scientific collaboration and institutional support to advance a personalized experimental treatment pathway. The case is best understood not as expert replacement, but as an instance of hybrid sociotechnical agency: a distributed form of effective action emerging from the interaction of human initiative, AI-supported analytical mediation, expert knowledge, institutional processes, and practical constraints. On this basis, the paper develops a bridge-across-expertise account of generative AI, introduces hybrid sociotechnical agency as the configuration through which such bridging becomes practically effective, and identifies five structural limits of autonomous systems in open human environments. The paper concludes that a more promising direction for agentic AI lies less in autonomous substitution than in the design of accountable forms of human–AI–institutional collaboration.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Fabrizio Marozzo (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: