Key result
Surgical simulation training is increasingly necessary in gynaecology due to diminishing live surgical caseloads for trainees and consultants to attain and retain credentialed skills.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The editorial highlights the critical shortage of live surgical caseloads for gynaecology trainees in Australia and advocates for the integration of simulation training to achieve and maintain surgical competency.
Surgical skill acquisition and the process of credentialing those skills are hot topics in gynaecology, with increasing pressure to have trainees and consultants attain and retain skill in a variety of simple and complex surgical procedures. The Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RANZCOG) provides statements on both the requirements of surgical attributes for fellows that include both adequacy and currency of training1 and credentialing.2 External bodies including the Australian Council of Healthcare Standards (ACHS)3 and individual hospitals require that gynaecology services be staffed by appropriately trained and skilled doctors; however, there is no single agreed and defined pathway on how to achieve this training. When speaking with current trainees, they bemoan the lack of surgical caseload, the increased nonclinical requirements for training (across obstetrics and gynaecology) and diminishing number of work hours in which to obtain appropriate surgical training.4 For women who attend gynaecology services, expectations that their surgical procedure will be undertaken by a highly skilled and experienced surgeon are high; however, this is diametrically opposed to the potential to train in a live setting. At some point of time, we all have to do our first ‘live surgery’ case in a real woman with a real problem, and this underpins the ongoing success of the specialty. Training in gynaecological laparoscopic surgery lends itself to simulation with long instruments that can be tracked through fixed pivot points in the (virtual) abdominal wall and viewed on a monitor providing realistic surgical ergonomics and reproduction of a procedure. The possibility of creating ‘virtual complications’ and managing these in a training environment is preferable to experience in a training environment with no risk, versus first dealing with complications in the high-risk live surgical setting. Systematic reviews report that virtual reality training appears superior to either box training or no training; however, there remains a dearth of evidence for how this translates to real-world surgical practice.5, 6 In this edition of ANZJOG, Janssens and colleagues report on how a dedicated simulation training module works in practice at one large Australian teaching institution and how this is then translated to a live surgical environment7. The authors have explored a number of issues that are often raised when simulation training is discussed, such as access to the simulator (they made a box trainer available in the delivery suite) and time (protected time was provided for simulation practice). The difficulties and complexities of adding another requirement to training are highlighted. There are a number of tough questions that are repeatedly raised for trainees and indeed our profession when it comes to gynaecological surgery: Let us consider these questions together as they are inextricably linked. It is apparent that we are not able to train everyone in all aspects of surgery within the 6-year college time frame. For example, in 2014, there were 655 trainees registered by RANZCOG and 1678 consultants practising in Australia (apologies New Zealand, but the Medicare data required me to make this distinction).8 For the 2014 calendar year, there were 319 Medicare claims for all types of ectopic pregnancy managed surgically across Australia. This likely reflects that outside of the public sector (where Medicare claims generally are not paid with the exception of fee-for-service consultants) there are few ectopic pregnancy surgical procedures performed; however, for any newly graduating year from college training, there are only 0.2 ectopic pregnancies/consultant/year. Is this enough to keep all fellows adequately credentialed? Even if we allow for three times this many to be performed entirely within the public sector (and not Medicare billed), this comes to 1.3 ectopic pregnancies/trainee/year for a grand total of 10 surgically managed ectopic pregnancies during training. An extension of training may be to consider a more complex procedure (eg. laparoscopic hysterectomy), where appropriate skill would automatically equate to credentialing in a procedure requiring less skill (a laparoscopic ectopic pregnancy procedure). For laparoscopic hysterectomy (item numbers 35750, 35753, 35754 – 6589 procedures), these data are 3.9 laparoscopic hysterectomies/year. Should it be considered that the minimum number of laparoscopic hysterectomies to be continuously credentialed was 20/year, then only 329 consultants (20%) of fellows would continue to be credentialed and the issue of ectopic pregnancy management would follow. The data for abdominal hysterectomy are even more troubling with a simple abdominal hysterectomy (item 35653–2694 procedures) allowing only 1.6 procedures/consultant/year or with the 20/year sensitivity 134 consultants (8%) to remain credentialed. The impact that these data have on how we continue to train the entire specialty including for peripartum hysterectomy and who performs these procedures in both rural9 and tertiary obstetric centres10 is problematic. These data require us to reconsider the approach to training and remaining skilled as surgeons and take a more considered approach to alternate options on attaining and retaining surgical skills. Simulation may well be part of the answer to teach the technical aspects of a surgical procedure, and as Janssens and her colleagues report, reduction in organ injury, blood loss and complication rate may follow (although this is yet to be borne out by evidence). The inclusion of a simulation requirement in the training program will seem unpalatable both in its instigation and oversight from governing bodies; however, trainees do respond positively to structured surgical training and feel it worthwhile.11 Simulation and haptic training are possible not just for minimal access surgery, but for open procedures,12 and it may be that this will extend to open hysterectomy in the future, where the need is great but training opportunities are diminishing. With obstetric emergency simulation being on the table,13 we have initiative, opportunity and possibility of simulation in all aspects of our profession. Perhaps our old aphorisms need to be revisited and very reasonably, as high stakes outcomes are at risk and our future will move from see one, do one, teach one to sim as many as it takes to be credentialed, do as many as is necessary to be competent, teach only when you are competent. A mouthful yes, but outcome driven, not aphorism driven.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jason Abbott (2015) conducted an editorial in Gynaecological surgery training. Surgical simulation training was evaluated. Surgical simulation training is increasingly necessary in gynaecology due to diminishing live surgical caseloads for trainees and consultants to attain and retain credentialed skills.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: