Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Despite considerable risk of alcohol use disorder (AUD) among civilians affected by armed conflict, the humanitarian response and research on this issue are inadequate. There needs to be greater engagement with AUD among humanitarian, developmental, United Nations, governmental, donor and research agencies. There also needs to be more comprehensive guidance and tools on ways to address AUD. There are currently more than 50 million people forcibly displaced from their homes as refugees and internally displaced persons (IDPs) due to armed conflict—the highest number since the Second World War. There are also many millions more who remain in areas affected by conflict or have recently returned to them after displacement. The vast majority are in low- and middle-income countries. There are a number of reasons why we should be concerned about alcohol use disorder (AUD) among conflict-affected civilian populations in low- and middle-income countries. They are often exposed to high levels of violent and traumatic events which are strongly associated with mental disorders such as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), depression and anxiety 1. Both exposure to traumatic events and these mental disorders are, in turn, associated with AUD 2-6. Conflict and forced displacement of refugees and IDPs also lead commonly to worse living conditions and impoverishment; the loss of family, friends and livelihoods; and erosion of social support, self-esteem and resilience. Alcohol may be used as a form of self-medication or a coping strategy. Poor living conditions and limited access to health care further increase the disease burden per unit of alcohol consumed 7. The post-conflict environment may also witness a scaling-up of alcohol promotion as new markets open up and national and transnational alcohol companies expand their activities 8, 9. The effects of AUD on conflict-affected populations include elevated risk of non-communicable diseases (NCDs), which are an increasing health burden among conflict-affected populations 10, and also communicable diseases such as HIV/AIDS and tuberculosis and interruptions in their treatment, as well as causing or perpetuating mental disorders. The social impacts of AUD may also be magnified in such populations; for example, with its links to gender-based violence, which is a major concern in many conflict-affected settings. Systematic reviews suggest that AUD is present in a range of conflict-affected populations 4, 5, and subsequent studies note high AUD levels among current drinking men such as IDPs in Uganda and Georgia and refugees in Thailand and Nepal 2, 3, 11, 12. However, these systematic reviews also note an extremely weak evidence base on AUD among conflict-affected civilian populations, particularly in low- and middle-income countries. They highlight the limited number of studies and common methodological weaknesses related to sampling, statistical analysis and failure to use standardized and validated measures of alcohol use and harms 4, 5. This is all in marked contrast to the far stronger evidence base on AUD among the military (albeit in high-income countries) 13. Humanitarian guidelines are limited in their engagement with AUD. While some note the need to measure and address AUD, they provide no detail on how this should be carried out. This suggests that activities to address AUD may be inadequate. Indeed, we could identify only one intervention-related AUD study; this was a pilot study addressing feasibility, rather than effectiveness 14. It appears that AUD remains off the radar for many humanitarian actors 8. What might explain this failure to recognize the issue of AUD among conflict-affected civilian populations? The humanitarian health sector's focus on immediate life-saving activities understandably meant that longer-term chronic and behavioural issues, such as AUD, were viewed as beyond the scope of humanitarian agencies—particularly given the enormous challenges of insecurity, limited time and resources, population flux and competing needs in conflict-affected settings. However, the rising burden of NCDs and chronic diseases among conflict-affected populations 10 means that humanitarian agencies will increasingly have to engage in these diseases and their key risk-factors such as AUD. In addition, conflicts are increasingly protracted in nature, with IDPs and refugees commonly displaced for years and decades. The combination of rising burden of NCDs and protracted conflicts and population displacement means that there is an increasing necessity for humanitarian agencies and governments to now address longer-term drivers of poor health such as AUD. Worryingly, the limited financial, human and technical resources within the humanitarian sector remain a barrier for addressing AUD 8. In addition, developing effective AUD responses and appropriate guidelines is inhibited further by the lack of evidence. What should be done? There needs to be much greater engagement with AUD among humanitarian, developmental, United Nations, governmental, donor and research agencies. This requires a public health approach; for example, ensuring that work on NCDs addresses underlying risk factors as well as treatment; exploring community-based responses; supporting better coordination between different sectors such as health and protection (e.g. with regard to AUD and gender-based, intimate partner and family violence) or mental health and psychosocial support with communicable disease control activities (e.g. HIV/AIDS and tuberculosis); supporting stronger alcohol control policies in post-conflict environments; and ensuring that the needs of conflict-affected civilians are recognized in global alcohol control activities. There also needs to be much more comprehensive guidance and more tools on ways to address AUD. Routine screening and intervention for AUD can be incorporated into health service provision. Brief community-based interventions 15, 16 have demonstrated high levels of effectiveness and cost-effectiveness in high-income stable settings 17 and could be adaptable, acceptable and feasible in lower-resource conflict-affected settings. The heavily gendered nature of AUD among conflict-affected civilians also suggests that interventions should be gender-sensitive 2-5, 11, 12, 18. Importantly, this all needs to be underpinned by more and better data in order to understand more fully AUD patterns and effective and appropriate responses; for example, routinely including AUD in rapid assessments and monitoring 19; conducting more epidemiological and qualitative research on AUD risks, consequences and comorbidity with mental disorders such as depression, anxiety, PTSD and locally determined mental illness; and, crucially, evaluating the feasibility, effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of AUD interventions, including using experimental designs. The benefits of reducing AUD effectively include improved physical and mental health and functioning; reduced risk for NCDs, communicable disease and injuries/accidents; reduced harms and violence to others; improved family and social relations; and improved economic productivity and reduced health-care costs. However, without greater engagement, AUD and its consequences among conflicted-affected civilians will remain neglected and the multiple benefits of tackling it will continue to be ignored. None.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Roberts et al. (2015) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: