Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The clinical librarian project, at what is now Barnet Primary Care NHS Trust, has been operating since January 2000.1, 2 The aim was to facilitate evidence-based practice and life-long learning by providing busy clinicians with easy access to patient-focused information at the point of clinical need. The clinical librarians are integrated into specific multi-disciplinary teams with whom they meet at venues where information needs arise. These include ward rounds, team meetings, referral meetings and educational meetings. Taking information resources out to clinicians enables them to seek answers to questions that may otherwise go unasked and so helps contribute to patient care. The clinical librarians use their contextual knowledge to guide the formation of clinical questions. This includes the discipline of the clinician, whether the request is for background information or to confirm a diagnosis or a treatment plan, and whether the information retrieved is for the sole use of the clinician, or if it is to be shared with the patient or carer. The gathering of such information to help in conducting well-formed searches is not unique to the work of clinical librarians. However, the presence of the clinical librarian at the case discussions at which questions are generated allows a greater understanding of the context of the question. The question covered in this article was posed by a psychiatrist working with one of the general adult community mental health teams. This is a busy team serving a relatively deprived catchment area in the borough. For the team, Tuesdays are taken up with outpatient appointments at a small, community-based clinic. The mornings are usually spent carrying out multi-disciplinary assessments of newly-referred patients, with the afternoons devoted to monitoring existing patients. Despite the hectic schedule, the team comes together during the lunch break for informal discussions of cases and team business matters. The team uses the time to learn about any service developments that may be underway, or to meet with representatives of outside bodies, such as voluntary organizations whose services may be of benefit to the client group. This is also an opportunity for clinicians to ask the opinions of their colleagues, or to discuss the appropriateness of, for example, a proposed treatment plan for a particular patient or a referral to another body. It is at this point that the team have found the presence of the clinical librarian useful. A wide range of questions arise during the course of the discussions. For example a clinician may ask for background information on a co-existing medical complaint and how it affects the patient's mental state. At other times there are questions about the relative effectiveness of possible treatments. Clinicians frequently seek information about support groups or outside agencies which may be able to offer assistance to the patient or his or her carers. Depending on the urgency of the situation, the clinical librarian will either search for the information there and then or will take the search away and report back at a later time. The question covered here concerns diagnosis. The psychiatrist had just come from an appointment with a young man who had recently been referred to the service. Five months prior to the appointment, the patient had inadvertently eaten a small amount of cannabis which had resulted in a psychotic episode with visual hallucinations and panic symptoms. The patient had been treated with an antidepressant which had eased the panic symptoms, but he was left with residual visual disturbances with symptoms of high blood pressure and blackouts. Other than the single incident of cannabis ingestion, the patient was not a drug user. The patient had, however, survived civil war in his home country, although he himself dated his difficulties to the time he ate the cannabis rather than to any trauma he had experienced previously. With this in mind, the team wanted to differentiate between the long-term psychiatric symptoms of eating cannabis, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and a psychotic disorder. As the patient had a follow-up appointment in six weeks' time, the clinical librarian was able to take the question away and carry out a comprehensive search for information. Several individual lines of enquiry were followed. Firstly, searches across medline, embase and PsycInfo were carried out to find out if the specific symptoms suffered by the patient could be the result of post-cannabis psychosis. This revealed a number of papers3, 4 which suggested that ingesting cannabis, particularly in naïve users, could cause psychotic episodes but that this episode was likely to be brief. A case report5 did suggest a possible link between the patient's persistent panic symptoms and the previous use of cannabis. However, the authors recognized that the use of cannabis was likely to have unmasked a predisposition to the disorder rather than to have caused it. Secondly, a search was undertaken to confirm that the symptoms reported by the patient could be the result of the trauma he had experienced in the past. Again, searches across medline, embase and PsycInfo revealed that many patients with PTSD experience severe panic symptoms.6 It was found that patients with PTSD often experience psychotic symptoms7 and that these differ only slightly from those experienced by patients with schizophrenia.8 The literature also suggested that the visual disturbances experienced by the patient could be linked to panic disorder.9 Finally, to double-check the conclusions reached, the clinical librarian contacted the local drug information service. They in turn contacted a drug information service specializing in the effects of non-prescription drugs to confirm the findings. Both services reported that the on-going symptoms experienced by the patient were unlikely to be the result of eating cannabis. Having carried out a comprehensive search of evidence, the clinical librarian was able to report back to the psychiatrist that the evidence suggested that the patient's symptoms were more likely to be the result of post-traumatic stress disorder than post-cannabis psychosis or a psychotic disorder. The psychiatrist could then be confident that the correct course would be to treat the patient for PTSD. This is not an isolated example of the impact of the clinical librarians. During the lifetime of the project the clinical librarians have carried out over 1000 searches for information related to patient care either directly, as here, or indirectly. Some of these searches would have been carried out even without the involvement of the clinical librarians. However, local statistics indicate that the numbers of information requests made by teams with access to the clinical librarians is far higher than by other teams in the Trust.2 Through their intense involvement with the teams they serve, the clinical librarians bring a depth of contextual information to the searches they perform, making the information retrieved highly specific to the cases in question. The provision of the clinical librarian service enables clinicians to apply the evidence to their clinical practice and ensures that patients receive the best quality of health care possible.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rigby et al. (2002) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: