Key result
Dual cascade algorithm achieves ~86% agreement between IIF and LIA testing for antinuclear antibodies.
Why the study?
The dual cascade algorithm involving screening and confirmation of ANAs by reflex testing is widely used but its diagnostic agreement and limitations require investigation.
What is the agreement between indirect immunofluorescence screening and line immunoassay confirmation in the dual cascade algorithm for diagnosing antinuclear antibodies in patients with suspected systemic autoimmune rheumatic diseases?
Cross-Sectional (n=475)
What is the agreement between indirect immunofluorescence screening and line immunoassay confirmation in the dual cascade algorithm for diagnosing antinuclear antibodies in patients with suspected systemic autoimmune rheumatic diseases?
There is moderate agreement between IIF screening and LIA confirmation tests for ANAs, with discrepancies varying by pattern type, suggesting a need for clinical-laboratory collaboration rather than strict reflex testing.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May warrant integrated clinical-laboratory ANA interpretation over rigid reflex testing; leaves open prospective validation of optimal algorithms.
Background The dual cascade algorithm which involves screening and confirmation of antinuclear antibodies (ANAs) by further reflex testing is widely used in the detection of ANAs. We aimed to investigate this algorithm which is commonly used in many laboratories. Methods A total of 475 sera obtained from patients with a clinical suspicion of systemic autoimmune rheumatic diseases (SARDs) upon which three expert assessors agreed for interpretation in the indirect immunofluorescence (IIF) test were determined and tested by the line immunoassay (LIA) containing 16 antigens. The results of the tests were statistically compared and evaluated. Results In 141 of the sera (29.7%), there was an agreement between ANA-IIF(+) and LIA(+) results. The overall agreement rate between the two tests for positivity and negativity only was 85.5% with a Cohen’s κ coefficient of 0.69. In 118 of these 141 sera (83.7%), pattern and associated ANA agreement was detected with an overall agreement rate of 80.6% and a Cohen’s κ coefficient of 0.57. The highest agreement between the pattern and associated ANAs was seen in centromere, dense fine speckled (DFS) and cytoplasmic reticular patterns. In these patterns, the rate of anti-centromere-associated protein B (CENP-B), anti-DFS and anti-antimitochondrial antibody M2 (anti-AMA-M2) antibodies were 93.4%, 92.3% and 66.7%, respectively. Conclusions We found an overall moderate agreement between IIF screening and LIA confirmation tests. However, the level of agreement varies according to the pattern type. The discrepancy in agreement rates may cause false reflex test requests. Our results highlight the need for collaboration between clinical and laboratory professionals in selected cases instead of the reflex testing approach.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ecemiş et al. (2019) conducted a cross-sectional in Systemic autoimmune rheumatic diseases (SARDs) (n=475). Dual cascade algorithm (IIF screening and LIA confirmation) was evaluated on Overall agreement rate between IIF and LIA tests for positivity and negativity (Cohen's κ 0.69). The dual cascade algorithm demonstrated an overall agreement rate of 85.5% between IIF screening and LIA confirmation tests for antinuclear antibodies.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: