Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Theoretical legal analysis reveals persistent fragmentation across Ukraine's justice sector, highlighting the need for outcome-oriented systemic criteria to evaluate reform success.
The article provides a comprehensive theoretical and legal analysis of the reform of Ukraine’s justice system from the perspective of its integrity, functional coherence, and orientation towards achieving a final legal outcome. Justice is considered a specific sphere of legal activity carried out by public authorities, related to the implementation of the State’s law-enforcement function and aimed at identifying, recording, and legally assessing violations of law, resolving the relevant legal conflict, applying measures prescribed by law, and implementing the adopted decision. The main areas of reform of constitutional, administrative, criminal, civil, commercial, and disciplinary justice are analysed. It is established that the regulatory and institutional changes mainly concerned the legal status of individual actors, the redistribution of their powers, the renewal of case-handling arrangements, and the establishment of new bodies. However, such changes did not always ensure proper functional links between the individual stages of the protection of law. It is substantiated that the effectiveness of justice system reform cannot be assessed solely by the number of adopted legal acts, established or reorganised bodies, and introduced arrangements for legal activity. The decisive criterion is the capacity of the reformed system to ensure a consistent transition from identifying a violation of law and providing its legal assessment to adopting and implementing a decision, restoring violated rights in practice, and re-establishing the proper legal order. It is concluded that further reform of Ukraine’s justice system should be based on a unified conceptual framework, provide for a clear delimitation of the competence of its actors, ensure coordination of their activities, and guarantee the implementation and enforcement of adopted decisions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Iryna Kunenko (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: